Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menu – Little Italy’s Pizza
Menu · LITTLE ITALY’S DELUXE PIZZA Medium (12”) – $21.99 Large (14”) – $24.99 X-Large (16”) – $29.99 · The Deluxe sausage, pepperoni, ground beef, ham, bacon, …
Little Italy’s Pizza Mt.Carmel | Mount Carmel IL – Facebook
Come see Safe Haven staff and volunteers selling Little Italy’s Pizza Mt.Carmel at the last night of Chamber Days! Pizza, breadsticks, soda, candy! The best, …
Little Italy’s Pizza
Little Italy’s Pizza serving great pizza and sandwiches in Chatham, Auburn, Carlinville, Hillsboro, Girard, Brighton, Mt. Olive and Staunton, Illinois.
Reviews
1momof2miracles Ashley
The pizza was amazing. The wings were a tad mushy. The $10 grilled chicken salad was a joke, mostly iceberg lettuce with tons of mozzarella, mushy tomatoes, yucky ranch, and what looked to be the lamest frozen chicken you could thaw super quickly. My waiter was a bit shy at first but came around and did great. Also the salad and wings came out at the same time about 15 minutes after I ordered. Salad should always come out quickly, not that I ate it sadly. The pizza seemed to come out in a timely manner. The dining room was practically empty, seemed clean. Phone rang off the hook, so decent business.
… moreChristy Kelley
My wife and I ordered pizza and cheese bread from there tonight!
When I first walked in I loved the inside! It’s cute and small. Would be nice for a little family dinner or lunch. The service was good. The girls at the counter was sweet and one of the guys from the back was super nice! Bragging about how good the pizza is! Well he did not disappoint!
The pizza looked absolutely amazing! So did the cheese bread.
Their cheese bread was delicious. The crust was not too thick or too thin. We ordered a hand tossed 16” pizza! Look at how huge that pizza is!!! Wowzers! We both was very impressed with their pizza. It was so delicious. Their cheese sauce and marinara sauce was good for dipping sauces as well. The one thing we was hoping for. We ordered extra cheese and it just didn’t seem like we received extra cheese. But it’s not their fault! We are just cheese fanatics! Such a good quality pizza from a small family business!
Definitely recommend and we will be back!
… moreWhen I first walked in I loved the inside! It’s cute and small. Would be nice for a little family dinner or lunch. The service was good. The girls at the counter was sweet and one of the guys from the back was super nice! Bragging about how good the pizza is! Well he did not disappoint!
The pizza looked absolutely amazing! So did the cheese bread.
Their cheese bread was delicious. The crust was not too thick or too thin. We ordered a hand tossed 16” pizza! Look at how huge that pizza is!!! Wowzers! We both was very impressed with their pizza. It was so delicious. Their cheese sauce and marinara sauce was good for dipping sauces as well. The one thing we was hoping for. We ordered extra cheese and it just didn’t seem like we received extra cheese. But it’s not their fault! We are just cheese fanatics! Such a good quality pizza from a small family business!
Definitely recommend and we will be back!
kaboose gaming
I recently visited Little Italy’s with a coworker, curious to judge the establishment for myself after hearing persistent negative reports about its decline. We placed a simple order for a large pepperoni and sausage pizza for pickup.
The atmosphere upon entering was immediately alarming. We overheard loud, aggressive, and abusive shouting emanating from an area I presumed to be the kitchen or office. The person yelling, who I believe to be the owner, was using derogatory language while seemingly berating an employee or speaking to someone aggressively on the phone. This created an incredibly tense and hostile environment for both staff and customers.
Unfortunately, the quality of the food mirrored this distressing experience. I had hoped the negative social media buzz was mere sensationalism, but the pizza was genuinely poor.
It is disheartening to say, but based on my experience dining across the entire state, this pizza ranks as the absolute worst non-gas station option I have encountered; you would likely find a better choice at a place like Casey’s.
It’s a common truth that mistreating staff leads to low-quality output. If employees are stressed and treated with hostility, it’s reflected directly in the product they are producing. The management needs to immediately address both their unprofessional conduct and the resulting dip in food quality.
… moreThe atmosphere upon entering was immediately alarming. We overheard loud, aggressive, and abusive shouting emanating from an area I presumed to be the kitchen or office. The person yelling, who I believe to be the owner, was using derogatory language while seemingly berating an employee or speaking to someone aggressively on the phone. This created an incredibly tense and hostile environment for both staff and customers.
Unfortunately, the quality of the food mirrored this distressing experience. I had hoped the negative social media buzz was mere sensationalism, but the pizza was genuinely poor.
It is disheartening to say, but based on my experience dining across the entire state, this pizza ranks as the absolute worst non-gas station option I have encountered; you would likely find a better choice at a place like Casey’s.
It’s a common truth that mistreating staff leads to low-quality output. If employees are stressed and treated with hostility, it’s reflected directly in the product they are producing. The management needs to immediately address both their unprofessional conduct and the resulting dip in food quality.
Teea Jenkins
This place does not deserve any stars,
This place is disgusting. The food is gross and always cold. The owner talks to all of his employees like they are dirt. These young adults do not deserve to be treated this way Period. We were sitting there as a family eating when he went off on all of his employees, And fired one on the spot.
Absolutely, disgusting place to eat!
… moreThis place is disgusting. The food is gross and always cold. The owner talks to all of his employees like they are dirt. These young adults do not deserve to be treated this way Period. We were sitting there as a family eating when he went off on all of his employees, And fired one on the spot.
Absolutely, disgusting place to eat!
Ed Alldredge
Place has been around for years. Pizza has a lot of toppings on it and the breadsticks are soft. Food comes out hot and delicious.
… moreFilia Desroches
I was just driving buy today with my family and we ordered pizza there today and the food was delicious. Good job to the cooks.
… moreGrim
I have just stomached all I could of the 6” Chicken Parmesean sandwich. This sandwich consisted of plain, seemingly unseasoned chicken breast, perhaps some mozzarella cheese (I could not discern any actual cheese taste or texture), two finger-sized peppers that I was not informed of prior to purchase, and some type of bread slathered in pasta sauce.
If I recall correctly, the paper menu, which lacked prices as far as I could tell lest I had temporarily fallen selectively blind, listed the bread as Italian. I could not confirm or deny that claim as this sandwich seems to have been dropped into a vat of red sauce before it was wrapped in tinfoil and given to me in exchange for real, human money that I worked for and was using to sustain myself. There is more sauce OUTSIDE the sandwich than betwixt the pieces of sopping, saucy bread. Nowhere on the menu does it warn the customer that what you will actually be buying is a sandwich encased in an orb of red, Italian goo. If the intention was to mask the inclusion of the dryest, most bland, hockey-puck-esque piece of chicken on God’s green Earth, this sandwich failed. I only choked down the first half of the sandwich because I am a firm believer in not wasting food, but this sandwich calls into question the very definition of “food”. I would not give this to my dog. Granted, I do not currently own a dog and would not give any of the spices in an average pizza sauce to a dog if I did own one, but this sandwich speaks for itself. At least, I fear it might start to.
The only positive aspect about this sandwich is that my hunger-fueled hubris was limited by this sandwich only being available in 6” portions, meaning I will be using less gasoline to rid myself of this cursed “food” item.
I also ordered the mozzarella sticks and some cheese sauce and was surprised when my meal total came to over $20, as I was expecting an appetizer-sized portion of cheese sticks dipped in breadcrumbs and then fried to go along with my “sandwich”.
I was surprised when I found a pizza-sized, sectioned circle of bread and cheese in my ownership, however this time the surprise was pleasant as I am a cheese enthusiast of sorts. This would almost make up for the lack of cheese in my atrocity of a “sandwich”, but upon consumption the bread feels as if it has sat out too long and the food item as a whole was practically absent of ANY flavor, even with the assistance of the almost-equally-flavorless cheese sauce. This food item, at least, I will be able to stomach with another meal or two once I have properly seasoned it.
The restaurant looked fine and the person working register was nice though.
… moreIf I recall correctly, the paper menu, which lacked prices as far as I could tell lest I had temporarily fallen selectively blind, listed the bread as Italian. I could not confirm or deny that claim as this sandwich seems to have been dropped into a vat of red sauce before it was wrapped in tinfoil and given to me in exchange for real, human money that I worked for and was using to sustain myself. There is more sauce OUTSIDE the sandwich than betwixt the pieces of sopping, saucy bread. Nowhere on the menu does it warn the customer that what you will actually be buying is a sandwich encased in an orb of red, Italian goo. If the intention was to mask the inclusion of the dryest, most bland, hockey-puck-esque piece of chicken on God’s green Earth, this sandwich failed. I only choked down the first half of the sandwich because I am a firm believer in not wasting food, but this sandwich calls into question the very definition of “food”. I would not give this to my dog. Granted, I do not currently own a dog and would not give any of the spices in an average pizza sauce to a dog if I did own one, but this sandwich speaks for itself. At least, I fear it might start to.
The only positive aspect about this sandwich is that my hunger-fueled hubris was limited by this sandwich only being available in 6” portions, meaning I will be using less gasoline to rid myself of this cursed “food” item.
I also ordered the mozzarella sticks and some cheese sauce and was surprised when my meal total came to over $20, as I was expecting an appetizer-sized portion of cheese sticks dipped in breadcrumbs and then fried to go along with my “sandwich”.
I was surprised when I found a pizza-sized, sectioned circle of bread and cheese in my ownership, however this time the surprise was pleasant as I am a cheese enthusiast of sorts. This would almost make up for the lack of cheese in my atrocity of a “sandwich”, but upon consumption the bread feels as if it has sat out too long and the food item as a whole was practically absent of ANY flavor, even with the assistance of the almost-equally-flavorless cheese sauce. This food item, at least, I will be able to stomach with another meal or two once I have properly seasoned it.
The restaurant looked fine and the person working register was nice though.
Linda A. Kolb
This pizza parlor is the bomb! We’ve been getting some foods for years now.
They do it all right!
Whether sandwiches or salads or pizza or pasta, it’s all delicious!
The chef chicken salad is a wonderful way to end a hot summer day with. The sub sandwich is top notch! We love the Italian version. Pasta and roast beef are excellent choices for a meal.
Stop by for a delicious meal.
Little Italy ‘s , “we love to feed you!”
… moreThey do it all right!
Whether sandwiches or salads or pizza or pasta, it’s all delicious!
The chef chicken salad is a wonderful way to end a hot summer day with. The sub sandwich is top notch! We love the Italian version. Pasta and roast beef are excellent choices for a meal.
Stop by for a delicious meal.
Little Italy ‘s , “we love to feed you!”
Jay Savage
I get people want to go home when their shift is done but this restaurant loves to close 10 mins earlier every night. If you want to close at a certain time do that. Don’t advertise one time and close whenever you want.
… moreKyle Dunn
Food is always dry and unflavorful. Service is just about nonexistent. Look elsewhere for pizza. Owner yells at his employees and at customers who don’t like their food.
… more