Little Italy Pizza

Little Italy Pizza. 10 South Plains Road, The Plains, OH. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 10 South Plains Road, The Plains, OH. ASAP•Pickup in 30 – 35 min. 8″ …

Little Italy Pizza, 10 S Plains Rd, The Plains, OH 45780, US

Get more information for Little Italy Pizza in The Plains, OH. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.

Reviews

Gracie Buchanan

I have eaten from Little Italy for 50 plus years. It’s the best pizza in Athens county. I drive from Meigs county for this pizza. They keep their prices affordable! The ingredients are fresh AND they are very generous with their toppings!!!! Best pizza around!!!!!

… more

Tommy Hart

I order from here once to twice a week and never know if I’m getting a good pizza or bad. I just ordered a jumbo like always 26.00 dollars wanted extra cheese like alway and I can barely tell they put cheese on let alone extra cheese Crazy. If I owned a business I would take care of the ones taking care of me. I’m done with the over price and poor quality pizza. I’m just done!!!

… more

jozlinh neilson

Visited Ohio and wanted to try a pizza place. We got a pepperoni pizza. The size of the pizza was good but the taste not so much. The pizza was very burnt, barely had any sauce on it, very oily, and had no flavor. The staff were very nice and friendly. Unfortunately will not be going back.

… more

Josh Radcliff

Embarrassing to say the least a local owner who is not involved enough to care about customers. Having a delivery driver go A wall crazy in your property and tell you you’re wrong as a customer because they can’t read your address number as a customer who has had the same address in the system for years upon years. 20 years plus it is pathetic. This place will be lucky to be here before long at this rate and that is sad to see. The food tastes the same no matter what you order. It’s bland. No seasoning the quality is gone. If you like grease c dry crust and terrible customer service this is it for sure.

… more

Nicholas

Updated review: Sadly this place has absolutely declined in quality since my original review. I have eaten a lot of pizza here. Not exaggerating I would suspect I’ve eaten here 100+ times. Maybe way more than that. So it wicks to have to lower my review. I’ve had multiple terrible experiences the last few months. The restaurant itself is absolutely vile now, it was always a little dingy but it’s gross inside now.

But the real issue is the current employees. They do an absolute slapdash job of preparing the foods. My pizzas often look like they’ve been thrown angrily into the oven after they just kinda tossed the ingredients on randomly.

And multiple times now they have closed early and I call to place an order a full 2-3 hours before listed close times. One time an employee picked up and literally just opened with “little Italy is closed”.

My last straw was ordering my taco pizza and receiving one that was covered in wilted and slimy lettuce. The owner needs to restructure his employees quickly or he’s going to lose this restaurant. For now I’ve quit ordering despite usually ordering twice a week or more.

Original review: I really like Little Italy. I eat here a lot. Fair prices, super quick service. The cheapest delivery around and a pickup window is good too. But more than anything I love their crust. It’s a great cracker like crust that still is thick enough to have substance. Customer service can be a bit spotty sometimes but honestly it’s barely worth mentioning. It’s just good pizza.

… more

Travis Miller

The food at Little Italy is very good. They offer a wide variety of options including a cauliflower crust pizza for carb or gluten sensitive people.

… more

julia Long-Yahn

We have had so many good experiences of having pizza from here but I have to tell you last night’s pizza was the worst that we have ever had. The crust seems like it was just a store-bought crust, there was no sauce on it to be seen. We actually ended up throwing the leftovers away. Too many other good pizza places in our area. Will not be trying this again.

… more

Boss money

I was Very impressed with the Pizza and with the fast delivery Still warm 5 stars all around

… more

Leona

Ordered a small cheese pizza, half garden salad, and a bottle of root beer. Place to order at 8:16 p.m. it is now 12:40 and still haven’t got it hasn’t been delivered.
Called multiple times and kept being told that the driver hasn’t returned.
My grandson went to bed and cried, all because he didn’t get the order.
THIS ISN’T THE FIRST PROBLEM FROM THEM.
Definitely the last!!!!!!!

… more

Jeffrey W Davis

Worst sandwich “roast beef” I have ever eaten, it was drywall, charbroiled cardboard with the flavor of dirt, for $9.90 I’ll take it as a lost and never go back!, oh by the way last week’s pizza was about the same, horrible, uneditable, I can’t believe I tried to eat their garbage again

… more

… View more

Little Italy Pizza

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results