Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Family-owned haunt providing a selection of traditional Italian dishes in a comfortable atmosphere.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 111 S Magnolia Dr #17, Tallahassee, FL 32301
Phone: (850) 878-7781
Website: https://www.littleitalytlh.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Little Italy: Home
111 South Magnolia Drive, Suite 17. Tallahassee,FL. 32301. Home · Menus · Contact Us · Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant. OUR RESTAURANT …
Little Italy Tallahassee – Facebook
Little Italy Tallahassee, Tallahassee. 2815 likes · 4 talking about this · 3072 were here. Classic homemade Italian food serving Tallahassee, Florida…
Little Italy, 111 S Magnolia Dr, Ste 17, Tallahassee, FL 32301, US
Little Italy is a locally owned pizzeria and restaurant in Tallahassee, Florida, that has been a beloved community staple since 1987.
Reviews
Anne Todd
We enjoyed a quick pizza here while travelling through Tallahassee. Service was friendly. Everything seemed clean. Food was tasty. Nice decor. Seats comfy enough.
There was also outside seating.
… moreThere was also outside seating.
Christopher Starnes
Walked in and the decor/ambiance felt like an older, family owned restaurant and I was excited to enjoy some homemade Italian food. I couldn’t have been more disappointed.
It was $75 (including a 20% tip) for 3 entrees. No drinks, no appetizers, and no dessert. If this was the best Italian food I’ve ever had, then I could justify this, but it was actually some of the worst. The spaghetti and meatballs were watery and flavorless, the chicken parm was just cheese and breading with the same watery sauce, and the salad was straight out of the Family Guy cutaway about pizza places making salads. Picture attached for reference.
Service was alright and the staff were nice, but there was no real effort to go above average. The restaurant itself was dirty and lacked neatness, with chairs and tables kinda haphazardly placed all about.
For me, the product needs to match the price or the price needs to match the product. Right now, it’s not happening, and your money is better spent at an Olive Garden where the portions are bigger, the prices are cheaper, and the food tastes better. I hope to see some changes at this place and return someday to enjoy what I thought I was going to get.
… moreIt was $75 (including a 20% tip) for 3 entrees. No drinks, no appetizers, and no dessert. If this was the best Italian food I’ve ever had, then I could justify this, but it was actually some of the worst. The spaghetti and meatballs were watery and flavorless, the chicken parm was just cheese and breading with the same watery sauce, and the salad was straight out of the Family Guy cutaway about pizza places making salads. Picture attached for reference.
Service was alright and the staff were nice, but there was no real effort to go above average. The restaurant itself was dirty and lacked neatness, with chairs and tables kinda haphazardly placed all about.
For me, the product needs to match the price or the price needs to match the product. Right now, it’s not happening, and your money is better spent at an Olive Garden where the portions are bigger, the prices are cheaper, and the food tastes better. I hope to see some changes at this place and return someday to enjoy what I thought I was going to get.
Kiesha Sheppard
Courtyard was very scenic. As you can see by the photos, we were given bread that was burnt. But other than that our food was ok. Atmosphere in the restaurant different, the area we were seated in had stained ceiling tiles, little lighting. So dim weneeded flashlights to read menu. Dont think I will be visiting again.
… moreDe Van
First walking in I had a bad expression about the place. I was looked at then the server walked away making me wait for ten minutes. The server only had one other customer in the restaurant. The food was portion size, there was nothing that represented anything about Italy or Italian food. As you can see I had spaghetti and meatballs. not even my 10 year old child full after eating the small bit of food, high price, that they give you. The only Italian about the first is the music and how they designed the place. Even the bread had Monterey day chemicals in it. I say they should change their name to American cooking.
… moreAshley Hirko
I don’t know if it was an off night as I’ve never ate here before but everything was lackluster. The Cesar salad was meh. Just average Cesar dressing, sprinkle parm, and lettuce. That’s it. The bread was burnt. The cheese bread was burnt which is bizarre since the cheese on top looked microwaved. The chicken alfrado was mostly bland sauce, not even half a chicken breast and light on the noodles. It was creamy but that’s it for seasonings. The chairs are cloth and filthy and the walls were filthy. I did hear the waitress repeatedly apologize and say the kitchen is backed up.
… moreTerry Lopez
Myself and some coworkers recently had lunch here at Little Italy. Being that it was lunch time was worried it would take a long time but it definitely was not. Service was great. She made sure our drinks were full and kept the bread basket full. Tried their oil to dip the bread and was really good! I had the baked ziti and was the perfect portion for me! The restaurant was small and quaint. Definitely will be returning!
… moreDrew Crouse
The chicken parm was excellent and the spaghetti and marinara. The salad was just ok and same for the bread.
… moreDonald Caswell
Decent pizza and friendly, helpful servers, but the restrooms need repairs. Neither one provides sufficient privacy. Situated next to a WinnDixie, parking is abundant. This restaurant has been operating in this location for more than 35 years.
… moreEmily Rose
No complaints on the food but the atmosphere definitely needs a remodel. Very dated interior and used the restroom to wash hands. I am so glad I didn’t have to use the toilet. Yuck.
If I ate here again it would have to be in the courtyard. Very cute outside
… moreIf I ate here again it would have to be in the courtyard. Very cute outside
Chandra Nicole
I had been running around town after work looking for costumes for my kids for Halloween and I was in the mood for some good lasagna! I searched but couldn’t find one and then I remembered this place. I’d never been before but I’ve passed by it (since it’s in the Winn-Dixie and Chick-fil-A shopping center) and wanted to try it. I looked up my trusty reviews and decided it was time to try it. They have a really nice outdoor patio area and it was busy for a Tuesday night.
I saw so many positive things about how the bread was delicious… and I’m a bread lover! I was torn between the lasagna and the Baked Cannelloni but decided I’d stick with the original plan for lasagna.
The lady at the register seems to be Italian and she was very nice, she suggested that I do the lasagna since she too loves it and that I should try the cannelloni the next time I was back 😉
When I got home with the food it was still hot, however there were a few cold spots in the middle. Nonetheless, I can say that I was pleasantly surprised at how good it was. I ate the entire container and the delicious bread all by myself! I’m a very picky eater and I will definitely be back to try more of the menu items. They are priced great for the portions and to be able to get a home cooked meal.
… moreI saw so many positive things about how the bread was delicious… and I’m a bread lover! I was torn between the lasagna and the Baked Cannelloni but decided I’d stick with the original plan for lasagna.
The lady at the register seems to be Italian and she was very nice, she suggested that I do the lasagna since she too loves it and that I should try the cannelloni the next time I was back 😉
When I got home with the food it was still hot, however there were a few cold spots in the middle. Nonetheless, I can say that I was pleasantly surprised at how good it was. I ate the entire container and the delicious bread all by myself! I’m a very picky eater and I will definitely be back to try more of the menu items. They are priced great for the portions and to be able to get a home cooked meal.