Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Guests move between an adjoined upscale American restaurant & a casual sports bar with 200+ beers.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Legends Restaurant – New Suffolk
Home · MENUS · ORDER · RESERVE. 631-734-5123 | [email protected]. 835 First Street, New Suffolk, NY 11956. — L E G E N D S —. MAKE A …
Legends Restaurant | New Suffolk NY – Facebook
Legends Restaurant · It is with great pleasure that we announce the new ownership of Legends Restaurant by Andrea Tese. · Irish Boxty – on special at LEGENDS – …
Legends Restaurant & Bar (@legends_restaurant) · New Suffolk, NY
Legends Restaurant, another Main Road staple, continues to serve the community with its longstanding presence in the hamlet. For those drawn to life on the …
Reviews
Titan Mitchell
Went right when they opened and easily got a seat. A bunch of TVs and a great atmosphere. Asked about brunch but looks like they’ve gotten rid of it since so don’t count on the brunch menu. The fried lobster sandwich though was great.
… moreTina H
Meet up with two friends! Immediately ordered a Banana Old Fashion — really good ! We all enjoyed our food ! Presentation was great too ! I had the clams w rigatoni which was in the specials menu. When it arrived I wasn’t sure as I pictured a red sauce with clams in the shell on top of the pasta. It was chopped clams in a white creamy sauce ! It was absolutely delicious ! I cleaned the plate !
… moreSam Root
After our fishing trip, we hit up this restaurant bar with a late-night menu.
Ice-cold beers, solid service, and wings that really hit the spot.
The place was clean, had plenty of seating and service was good. A few locals were there having a beer which adds to the charm.
… moreIce-cold beers, solid service, and wings that really hit the spot.
The place was clean, had plenty of seating and service was good. A few locals were there having a beer which adds to the charm.
Irina D
We stopped by Legends to try some local oyster and watch Concacaf Gold Cup, we had a great time! Loved their cocktails, fried calamari was crispy and oysters were absolutely delicious. Great spot to watch sports.
… moreFred Callis
I’ve been going to Legends for 30 years. The food has always been outstanding. Unfortunately, with the new ownership things have slid downward. I had one of the worst flounder sandwiches I’ve had in a long time. Two tiny little pieces that looked they were cut off the front and back of a fillet, overcooked with so much tartar sauce on the top and bottom of the roll I had to scrape it off. Fortunately, the clam chowder is still good. A couple of my favorite dishes are no longer available as they seem to be transitioning into a sushi bar. Happily the bartenders are still first rate as are the rest of the floor staff. I wish I could say the same for the kitchen.
… moreIvan Mouzykin
Quite an impressive experience
Amazing service and very delicious food! Fish and chips, and Cheesecake – 5 ⭐️
… moreAmazing service and very delicious food! Fish and chips, and Cheesecake – 5 ⭐️
Christopher Artibee
First time here and so glad we came. Food and service was phenomenal! We had the wonton special for an app that was so delicious. I had seafood stew which was packed with flavor. All the various fish and shellfish were cooked to perfection. You could bottle the broth! Wife had the short ribs which were amazing so tender and delicious. The drinks were made perfectly and well balanced. The fresh made rolls were piping hot and so good! We will be back.
… moreJohn Guma
Very nice diversified menu containing steaks, seafood, vegetarian specials, chowders and some excellent starters. Large selection of draft beer and and ample wine list. The service is first rate, friendly and efficient. Nice selection of deserts and coffee. Give Legends a try.
… moreAgatha Capacchione
So excited for the new iteration – recently dined at the sushi counter with some friends and it was amazing. Such a welcome addition to the North Fork. Also love how they pay special attention to seafood only serving what’s local and sustainable in really inventive ways – ask Chef about their sustainability practices, it’s awesome. Great wine list to match too!
… moreJoséph Rincón
This week I tried two dishes: the fried calamari and the Legends Roll. Unfortunately, the calamari didn’t taste fresh, and the tuna in the Legends Roll didn’t taste good either. On the positive side, I really enjoyed the drinks.
… more