James Hensley
Yet again outstanding food and service. The beautiful young waitress that waited on our table Thursday Feb 5th 2026 didn’t catch her name but she waited on us before she is always attentive and very polite. The beer was amazing!! cold and crisp. Tried the steak pizza. Amazing and i cannot find better garlic knots anywhere else. Got a kids meal for our almost 2 yr old grandson and tried a fry and chicken nugget. Even those were absolutely great. 1 of our top 5 favorite restaurants in the polk area.
… moreDonna Hewitt
It was pretty good! Pizza was crispy and the salad was fresh! We waited over an hour for our food! Not fun when you’re hungry! It was quiet so our party of 6 could actually have a conversation!
… moreThat One Christian Guy
I’ll start with the bad first and bring it around with a positive. Their hours on Sunday are 12-9. My family has had to sit in the parking lot til 12:30 on multiple occasions because they aren’t opening at the time they claim to. Which leads me to their customer service. They aren’t the friendliest. They aren’t necessarily rude, but they lack the customer service skills that create a positive experience. The food is really good, but again, they have lost out on business because they don’t open the doors when they are supposed to. It’s unfortunate but is what it is
… moreClarissa Johnson
I ordered lunch , spaghetti and meatballs . And four slices of cheese cake.I said I wanted to order six meatballs all together . When I got there to pick my order up i asked to make sure there were six meatballs all together. I was told yes they are I made sure myself so I trusted the employee. I got back to the house open the spaghetti and it was three meatballs cut in half to make it look like there were six in there. I called and asked to speak to the manager I was told there was no manager in and they didn’t know when the manger would be in. I can’t believe a restaurant would try to decieve a customer and not try to make it right.
… moreNate Watkins
I really like this place. Good food, and nice people who run it. It is great having a local place with NY style pizza. The buffalo chicken pizza is also really good and that is coming from someone originally from Buffalo.
… moreJohn Acevedo
The best NY slice I’ve had in Florida, reminds me of Brooklyn. Fast and Friendly service and great attentiveness. Would recommend 10/10
… morecarol sargeant
We have lived in Florida for 30 years. Always searching for great NY style pizza. We have heard about Stadium Pizza. But we live about 45 minutes away. We were in the area last month and came upon it in the shopping center. We were very impressed to the quality of the pizza. And excellent cannoli’s. We just returned 2 nights ago to have dinner. We will definitely keep coming back.
… moreMary Egidio
Just discovered this hidden gem and will definitely be back! We had the dinner portion Eggplant Parm and Manicotti. Excellent! As good as anything we’ve had in Lakeland OR Pittsburgh. Very authentic. Of course, we had to try the cannoli! We’ll be back for pizza soon.
… morelinda b
The most unremarkable pizza $20 can buy…2 toppings, so thinly sliced you hardly taste, and pretty SPARSELY placed…I forgot to take a picture before I covered it with shaker cheese (wasn’t much in the way of shredded cheese as a topping either, this the shaker cheese).
I did take a pic of the sausage topping, it’s about the width of a nickel, but thinner!
Not ever going to this place again.
… moreRebekah Kantowski
This was my first experience at this restaurant. I ordered the Fettuccine Alfredo and it was delicious. The bread…also amazing. The lady that took my order was nice and brought my food outside where I was waiting. I’ll be back. Thank you!
… more