Phil O’Sullivan
Coming from New England, this pizza hits the mark, 8.9 on the Portnoy Scale! Crispy crust, good cheese blend, right about of flop. Best east coast pizza I’ve had on the west coast.
… moreDanika Guiley
We were thrilled to learn we could buy the vegan pizza by the slice. We tried it on our visit and were impressed with the quality of crust and flavor! This seems like a great option if you’re looking for a quick slice!
… moreElizabeth
Best pizza on Orcas and super nice staff. We loved the cheese pizza with pineapple + ranch.
… moreJorge Avila
I’ve eaten pizza in many places across the country and this is one of my favorite! It is light, crispy and very tasty. Staff is friendly and there’s enough seating. The only downside is I am not a local! Otherwise, I would be a regular customer.
… moreRobert Reed
Great pizza!!
My wife is an Italian from Queens and absolutely loved every slice!!
And, no joke, the homemade ranch is liquid crack. Seriously, get as many containers as you can.
… moreSasha Amy
Love this place! If I come back to orcas island I will be coming here again! We had the metza and wings soooo good! The hot sauce they give you for the wings was incredible.
… moreRebecca
We ate here last year when I believe they were a fairly new establishment. We loved it and looked forward to coming back for a whole year!
Today was the day…. and the pizza was lackluster in every way. It seemed to have been sitting out for quite some time to start with, had hardly any cheese, and was over cooked. The crust was hard. The service was also lackluster…not much of a change from last year honestly, but the pizza was so good then that we could overlook the service that seemed like they just wanted you to go away.
Maybe if you order a fresh pie, its better. But for the price and quality we recieved today, we won’t be coming back.
… moreYing
We ordered a whole pizza of combo, 18 inches.
* It tasted good. All the materials were in good quality. Right amount of cheese for us.
* The bathroom was clean.
… moreGrant
Absolutely the worst pizza we’ve ever had. Ate one slice and chucked the rest of the pie in the trash at the park down the street. Meat and veggies appeared microwaved and watery and very sparse. All the cheese was reduced to actual liquid grease.
Seating outside is a complete afterthought. One of those “well where else are you going to eat” type island establishments.
… moreKraig Fisher
I thought that the pizza slice to value was great. Service is great. Food and drink options are great, too.
… more