Johny C
La Finca truly lives up to its name.
From the moment the food arrives, everything feels homemade, warm, and authentic — just like eating “en la finca.”
The fresh juices are excellent, full of flavor and very refreshing. The baked fish was delicious, perfectly cooked, and clearly made with care. Every dish had that comforting, home-style taste that makes you want to come back.
We started with an appetizer of fish and shrimp — including a fish and shrimp ceviche — which was very well prepared and full of flavor. The patacón was outstanding: crispy, fresh, and perfectly done. Portions were satisfying, and the service timing was on point.
One important suggestion for improvement, especially considering it’s winter: the restaurant could be better heated. It felt quite cold inside, particularly around the legs, which makes you want to leave sooner instead of staying longer to enjoy dessert or another beer.
Overall, La Finca offers delicious Colombian food with a very authentic, home-cooked feel. With better temperature control during colder months, the experience would be even better
… moreAmy Kang
I found authentic Colombian restaurant! Cozy place with attentive service and authentic good food.
Steak, chicheron, chicken soup were delicious! Beans were soupy so you can mix rice and so tasty.
We loved drinks! Lemonade with mint was so refreshing and guanabana juice was the best I’ve ever had!
Staff were very friendly and professional.
Highly recommend if you are looking for authentic experience of Columbian food.
… moreCristian J Borja
Delicious but 3 shrimps for a $36 dollar plate…
… moreLee Gee
I’ve been to this establishment quite a few times however not for many years until just recently. The food quality is very good but the meal portion of Maduro shrunk since then. The steaks were delicious and presentation is always fun as it arrives on a sizzling platter. Keep that in mind when you’re ordering so the steak isn’t overdone by the time you’re ready to eat it! The waitress was very sweet and friendly. The music playing on the 2 big screen tvs was very good and not too loud. The decor is cute and colorful although the place is very small. The bar area has no room to actually sit which is a shame because I’m sure the revenue would greatly increase if both aforementioned were larger and had the capacity to accommodate more patrons. It was afternoon so didn’t try the sangria again but will soon at some point. I remember it was very good years ago. So this little gem is worth the stop. The menu is true Colombian so if that’s what you’re after this place doesn’t disappoint Also good location close to Hicksville LIRR. Enjoy!
… moreDelia Quinlivan
The food was not fresh and La arepa had a weird taste . Little piece of meat over cooked while I asked medium rear. The service was horrible not friendly, the waiter didn’t care. He said if the food was not good, I shouldn’t have eaten it. He did ask a couple of times, but I was afraid they were gonna spit up my food so and I was starving. Seems like they don’t care. They want to charge your even for another cup of coffee
… moreLuz Almonte
We were seated immediately by the friendly staff. The appetizers came out hot and were freshly made. I ordered fried fish which is one of my favorite dishes and I was not disappointed. The food was hot when it reached our table, freshly made crispy salads, seasoned to perfection. Will definitely be returning for the authentic Colombian Food
… morepriscila alvarez
This place is amazing. The service was outstanding. The food is delicious and generous portions. All 10/10. A hidden GEM in Hicksville. Definitely WORTH THE TRIP!!!
… moreLeann
I am so glad I stopped in, because it’s an easy place to miss from the outside. Inside it’s a beautiful place with amazing service. The atmosphere is extremely welcoming and the food is incredible! You get so much for your money and the dishes are phenomenal!
… moreJuan E Montenegro P
Excellent service. The place was very clean and also the bathrooms looks brand new. The Venezuelan guy was very friendly, he gave us a very professional service. I’ll come again next time I’m around there
… moreAlex Bejar
Amazing place for second year in a row. I coach a travel soccer team from stroudsburg Pennsylvania and this is our third time in two years attending this place!!! Hands down some of the best Colombian food in the area and highly recommend it to anyone. Friendly and accommodating staff…
Gracias a todos hasta el cocinero!!!!
Salimos campeon de torneo (Sub-19). Gracias por la comida que nos dio energia para ganar!!!
Hasta la proxima!!!
… more