Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 432 W Lake Dr Ground floor, Montauk, NY 11954
Phone: (631) 668-5555
Website: http://www.kennyscastaways.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Kennys Castaways – there are no strangers here, just friends who …
*We will be closed Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, Christmas day and New Year’s day. WE ARE LOCATED AT 432 West Lake Drive, Montauk, New York 11954
Menu – Kennys Castaways
Kenny’s Castaways 432 West Lake Drive, Montauk, New York 11954. TEL: 631 668 5555 – Fax: 631 668 4444. Email: [email protected].
Barstool Pizza Review – Kenny’s Castaways (Montauk, NY) – YouTube
Dave is back to solo pizza reviewing in Montauk, and may have found an underrated spot. Download The One Bite App to see more and review …
Reviews
Dante Skidmore
In town for 5 nights, and came here twice. Dinner was excellent both times. Below is my espresso encrusted yellow fin tuna. Try the zeppole for desert!!! Staff is attentive, friendly and always helpful.
… moreDavid Laster
Had a great meal tonight on a cold rainy day. Chicken Parmesan and Spicy meat Pizza. Paired with an Aperol Spritz and Spicy Paloma. Excellent service by “Danny from Miami”
… moreNick Williams
I was staying at the hotel attached to this place so I decided to give it a try. The menu looked nice and I was excited. Upon walking in I could tell that there was mainly an older crowd in the restaurant (I’m 25) but I asked for a table regardless. The owner immediately seemed disinterested with my being there and persuaded me to sit at the bar, presumably so he didn’t have to wait on me. The food was good, but the tomato sauce for my lasagna was most definitely canned, and at over 100 dollars for my single meal and 3 drinks that was not nearly good enough in my opinion. Then, while I was eating the owner made some rounds to talk to everyone in the restaurant (even the other patrons at the bar) except for me. I’m guessing it was because of my age and he assumed I wasn’t able to pay for the food. Overall, 6/10 food with over the top prices and a discemenatory owner.
… moreSharon Regali
I have no clue how this place has ever been rated less than a 5. Ask for Mario he is absolutely outstanding… their food is filled with flavor and authenticity…. I now don’t want to eat anywhere else. The atmosphere is warm and very comfortable. Making the perfect dinner spot for Sunday family dinners …
… moreDouglas Koch
One of the best meals I have ever had. Owner took the time to talk to us. Don’t listen to the 1 star reviews. It’s political sabotage. I had the veal Parmesan special with linguini. My wife had penne ala vodka. Drinks and wine was very reasonable compared to other places. A must go to place.
… moreGrainne Ward
We ate at Kenny’s Castaways last. Night October 12th 2024 and it definitely surpassed even its best reviews! There was four of us and the appetizers were fresh and delicious, with an assortment of tuna tartare, beet salad, fresh mozzeralla and calamari! Our main courses consisted of grilled salmon, pasta, and pizza with various toppings! All the food was clean and fresh. Our waiter Mario was friendly and informative with an interesting personality which is sadly lacking in other restaurants. The overall ambience was cool, with background music that included some Van Morrison hits! I would have no hesitation recommending Kenny’s Castaway, great place to take friends and relatives!
… moreStephen O’Donnell
Great food & fantastic service. We tried four appetisers, main courses and dessert – all fantastic. Mario was great looking after us and advising us how much to order. Will come again
… moreEvangeline Kohn
Best dining experience ever. Mario and staff amazing. The lasagna was delicious. The place is warm and inviting. The treatment we received was the mark of a true professional restaurant. Thank you Mario we will be back. Any negative reviews don’t believe them. We recommended your place to 10 people back at our hotel.
… moreKari Miller
We were there Tuesday 6/25/24! On vacation with my husband! Wonderful dinner! Drinks were great! Beautiful outdoor seating! Great service! Owner and wait staff were extremely attentive! Highly recommend!
… more