Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Red-checkered-tablecloth eatery for pizza, red-sauce pastas & other casual Italian fare.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6811 N Cocoa Blvd, Port St John, FL 32927
Phone: (321) 639-3333
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home | Kelsey’s Pizzeria in Port Saint John, FL
Historical Italian kitchen and bar on US1 with an incredible view of the rockets launching from Kennedy Space Center. Quality service and food.
Kelsey’s Pizza PSJ | Port Saint John FL – Facebook
We have seafood & soup available for the Lenten season. Open today 11:00am – 9:00pm Dine-in, take-out, or delivery. 6811 North US1 (PSJ) (321) 639-3333.
KELSEY’S PIZZERIA – Port St John, FL 32927 (Menu & Order Online)
Online ordering menu for KELSEY’S PIZZERIA. At Kelsey’s Pizzeria in Port St John, we serve Pizza, Calzones, Pasta, and a variety of other classics such as …
Last Updates
Reviews
C P
I was pleasantly surprised that the pizza was good here. Matt took good care of us. The place was pretty empty when we came, so we sat wherever we wanted. There are different sections with different vibes. There was the bar area, a more restaurant-style area, and the area in between that was more quiet. My daughter and I got a one-topping pizza and it was more than enough for us. We brought the leftovers home to hubby and there was enough for all of us.
… moreLillian Hernández Caraballo
Change is good! New ownership is slaying service and elevating the food quality. They treat you like family.. I asked for a Bloody Mary, they didn’t have tomato juice, so the owner literally went to the back and MADE ME tomato juice for my drink Like, she didn’t have to do all that, and I don’t know it they would always have time, but just saying — this is the kind of people they are. Place is cute, clean, food is very good, and prices are fair! We’ll definitely be back.
… moreViolet L
Having new ownership has
proved to be a good thing. Last night I had the mini Greek salad. That has always been excellent and well worth the $. I ordered stuffed shells with an order of Italian sausage and garlic knots. And a glass of red wine. Probably the best meal I’ve had there. (I’ve had other meals that were also good, which is why I keep going back) The sausage was really good as were the stuffed shells. Came home with leftovers that will feed me 3 more times. Price was very reasonable for the amount of food you get. I think the new owners have improved on the food. The servers are particularly helpful and efficient. Everyone was very friendly and it was obvious they want customers to have an excellent experience.
… moreproved to be a good thing. Last night I had the mini Greek salad. That has always been excellent and well worth the $. I ordered stuffed shells with an order of Italian sausage and garlic knots. And a glass of red wine. Probably the best meal I’ve had there. (I’ve had other meals that were also good, which is why I keep going back) The sausage was really good as were the stuffed shells. Came home with leftovers that will feed me 3 more times. Price was very reasonable for the amount of food you get. I think the new owners have improved on the food. The servers are particularly helpful and efficient. Everyone was very friendly and it was obvious they want customers to have an excellent experience.
Julie Taylor
I ordered the white pizza and I ordered the Supreme. I picked this order up, both pizzas had hardly any ingredients on them. To top it off the crust was hard and taste less, pizza was barely warm. I spent $47.00 on something that would’ve been much better quality and CHEAPER from your rivalries.
… moreBarbara Betts
Where do I start? How about, “wow, is this place in need of a major makeover”! It is dark, dank, and dated. I remember this place from the mid-eighties and it feels as though it hasn’t left that timeframe. The bar is almost 1/2 of the restaurant and it is dark and dank as well. Enough about that, though, I come for the greek (house) salad and that is one of the best salads I’ve ever had. I love the veggies and the way the lettuce is shredded, the dressing, the ham, etc. Just plain yum. I had a sausage grinder sub as well. Sausage was OK, needed help in the seasoning department, but good. The bread was not toasted enough and fell apart. Would not do that again. Hubby had a Kelsey’s special pizza, and while the fresh, not canned, mushrooms on the za were a VERY welcome addition, the za was not hot. Considering that it took a while to get, this was disappointing. To her credit, the server (whose name was not provided) offered to have it put back in the oven, but we declined. Amazing how different this Kelsey’s is from the one in Rockledge. That one is newer, so it is fresher and brighter, but I wonder if they are the same owners?
… moreScott Jensen
Looks like new owners for this location. We had great service and the food was good.
Does not seem like they have changed the menu so that’s good.
I think changes are on the way. Hopefully all good.
Give them a try, especially if you stayed away before.
… moreDoes not seem like they have changed the menu so that’s good.
I think changes are on the way. Hopefully all good.
Give them a try, especially if you stayed away before.
Brian Solmonson
You can’t go wrong. You’re taking care of by a team who cares, not just one person. Excellence from top to bottom to the food the atmosphere the service. Hats off to Matt!! Nice job..
… moreSync Word
Decided to try Kelsey’s after a long while, and after the recently-new mgmt and spotty reviews. We were warmly greeted at the door, looked at the menu – noticing neither offerings nor prices had changed (good) and sat down. Service was very attentive and the portions were as large as we remembered. The only difference we noticed is the marinara sauce: sweeter and more bland – important to us and cost a star for food in this review. The meat sauce was better, though it too could have used a little more complexity. Otherwise, the mini Greek salad was huge as always, and the spaghetti and meatballs dinner was tasty and large with a substantial take-home portion. They also still have the $5 hurricane drinks, though I didn’t buy one this time. Before tip our bill was under $20 – rare these days for eating out anywhere.
… moreJeffrey Kuhr
Nice play for all meal, the Italian sandwich was delicious as was the house salad. Calzones not all dough as some pizzeria’s have and was stuffed with plenty of filling. The plate size Greek and Antipasta salad were large enough to take some home. Would recommend..
… moreDawn Peck
We LOVE the two different feelings. One is Italian food fun and the other is fun
Contemporary food
The staff make you feel like you’ve come to Moms house and it’s a celebration. Thank you for making great food and a great ambiance
… moreContemporary food
The staff make you feel like you’ve come to Moms house and it’s a celebration. Thank you for making great food and a great ambiance