Rebeca Mcdonald
Have you seen those huge pizza slices and ever wondered how good they are?
Well we got to eat some delicious perfectly done pizza. The crust was not thick and not too thin, but thin enough to enjoy the actual toppings, sauce and cheese on top. We enjoyed the white ricotta slice, bacon chicken ranch slice, and margherita slice. It’s very tasty and satisfying without feeling heavy and full, I highly recommend. It’s the yummy smell you smell while walking on the boardwalk.
J’s Pizza Belmar
Belmar Beach NJ
… moreMindy Miller
Nasty. Pizza was hard, dry, and flavorless, but at least I could get it down. The garlic knot, on the other hand, was inedible. It was so bad that my friends were daring each other to try it. Even a tiny piece burned going down. The next day I could still taste the garlic, even though I’d tossed basically the whole thing. My friends had to get ice cream to try to wash the taste away. Definitely not going back here.
I will note, though, that my friend’s fries were really good (though she didn’t like them), and my fresh lemonade was good (though expensive).
It was also really stressful just trying to get my food plate when it was ready. I finally had to force my way between the huge line of noisy teens waiting to order. Very, very little space in there, and uncomfortably tight and chaotic. Not to mention the lack of enough seating outside.
… moreRandall Sparks
the pizza is really big and good and it filled my big belly adequately. the wings were also very very good, and they were very tasteful, delicious, etcetera, other things of this nature. go here if you like good pizza and good food and good wing. 10/10 will go again probably around the week of june 17th 2026 for the yearly beach escapade, adventure, etcetera. will see you there. be ready.
… moreBrad O’Dell
The Buffalo chicken empanadas were FANTASTIC! Rachel did a great job making them. Definitely recommend – best pizza place in Belmar!!!!!
… moreMilton Velez
We decided to give this place a try after a few hours at the beach across the street. We ordered a large plain pie, 2 fountain drinks and a bottle of water. $50 seemed expensive but it was convenient so I figured no biggie. We waited out front and the waitress told us she would call us when the order was ready. A half hour later and no pizza. I went inside to check on the order and there it was, sitting in the oven. The pizza was still warm but extremely oily. Everyone used a bunch of napkins to soak up the oil. The highlight of the order was the lemonade, which my son said was good. Overall, this place is convenient but that’s about it.
… moreMelissa Quin
Pizza is good, but the cost is so high! I got 3 slices for more than 2 pies. for that price you’d expect the best pizza you’ve ever had!
I haven’t tried the pizza places around the area yet, so I can’t compare, but definitely will next time to see which is better
… moreKaren Long
Amazing experience tonight. Got to the beach late this afternoon and ordered online. Hot pizza was ready for my entire family when we were ready to eat. We got amazing communication on a text message even asking us if we wanted to have extra cheese on our pizza order. Great crew incredibly efficient clean restaurant and great seating outside! We will definitely visit again.
… moreLiam B
I ordered a Caesar wrap today and it was so good! The two girls working greeted me when I came in and started on my food as soon as I ordered. I’ll definitely be coming back!
… moreNathaniel Krauss
Shi the first 2 times I had this pizza it was great, but today I was left with horrible news. They poisoned my girlfriend with pesto on her pizza when she ordered a margherita and is deathly allergic. God bless she’s okay but I don’t think I can ever go here again knowing this tragedy occurred. I’m deeply upset . Count your days J’s.
… moreEmoxitoAngelxX
Although the pizza and the wrap was good, I didn’t wait long for the pizza but the wrap I waited literally forever for ,even though it was pretty good I would have to give this place.a maybe three out of five stars because pf the long wait. The owner though was very apologetic and I appreciated that greatly not sure if I will be coming back or not if I’m ever in the area
… more