Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
We are a small pizza shop, family owned and operated since 1959. We use our original family recipe to make our dough in-house, fresh daily just the way Grandma & Grandpa Catalfina made it when they opened Josie’s so many years ago. If you enjoy a mom & pop shop pizza experience, come see us!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3205 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43204
Phone: (614) 274-7822
Website: http://josieshilltop.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Josie’s Pizza Hilltop
Columbus, OH 43204 (614) 274-7822. Hours. Mon: Closed Tues – Thurs: 11AM … Josie’s Pizza Hilltop© 2022. All rights reserved. *Delivery orders accepted …
Order Josie’s Pizza Hilltop – Columbus, OH Menu … – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Josie’s Pizza Hilltop at 3205 West Broad Street in Columbus. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your …
Josie’s Pizza Hilltop 3205 W Broad St – Order Online
Josie’s Pizza Hilltop 3205 W Broad St. 3205 W Broad St, Columbus, OH. Pizza. Specialty Pizzas. Calzones. Appetizers & Side Items. 9″ Submarines. Salads.
Last Updates
Reviews
Collin Sims
Before I start, I want to say we ordered through DoorDash so I can’t give a truly authentic review since we didn’t stop in or interact with staff. That being said, the pizza was DELICIOUS! The sauce wasn’t too sweet and hit just right, the crust was thick enough without being doughy, and the toppings were perfect. Definitely one of my recent favorites in town. Will for sure be going back.
… more*Natalie *
Yum. I got a pep and cheese pizza. Reminded me of an old Mom and Pop style pizza parlor . Staff is very kind and knowledgeable.
Update: under new management. Pizza not the same. Edible but less flavor. Doughy and not thin like she didn’t let it rise enough. Also kind of mean on the phone. I miss the old lady won’t be back.
… moreUpdate: under new management. Pizza not the same. Edible but less flavor. Doughy and not thin like she didn’t let it rise enough. Also kind of mean on the phone. I miss the old lady won’t be back.
gopochiko
Sorry Josie’s, I like your food, but I just ordered from you this evening 12/23/25 and this is second time you’ve forgotten something. This time: the sauce for my wings. Just breaded wings, nothing else. No sauce in the pizza box either. Shame, I like(d) you guys.
… moreRon ponyicky
Great pie. Thinner crust with a nice crunch – pepperoni was tasty. $17 for a L is more than fair.
… moreDenise Giesecke Meyer
Amazing pizza, lots of cheese and quadruple layers of pepperoni!!! My first time here but we will be back!!
… moreLaura Slagle
We always do carry out, but this has been one of our staple places for 30 years. Old fashioned pepperoni is the best!
… moreVeronica O’Neal
I love ❤️ the pizza the staff cool wit me finna go get my pizza now
… moreDaisey Holley
Paid over 20 bucks, pizza was warm and they didn’t give us the lettuce tomatoes and ranch that was supposed to come with it. Good taste but a little over cooked
… moreDanny Plants
A co worker bought some Pizza from you guys.And I gotta say it’s the best pizza i’ve had in a while
… more