Craig Fenton
With all the competition Johnny’s faces in Mahwah, Ramsey, Allendale, and Suffern they have clearly shown from opening day to the present why they are the top choice. Every aspect of a business a customer would want they excel (product, cleanliness, customer service, and menu options). Besides a superlative slice of pizza their Sicilian is larger than others without being burnt on top (commonly found elsewhere), and their version of the Deep Dish slice is tremendous. If you want to dine in, take out, or not leave the comfort of your home and have the food delivered, they are the Must Go To spot in the area.
… moreJuan Miguez
These Albanians know how to make great pizza! A bit of a problem is that need to keep on service as they forgot some items and charge was a little off, but I’m ok with that. No penalty. So work on your service and then on a little atmosphere, there was some Italian music but stopped. Overall it was great!
… moreMichele Lefkowitz
After our favorite pizza place stopped delivering to our address, we tried several new (to us) pizzerias in the area. Johnny’s has become our new, go-to delivery choice. Sauce tastes fresh, delivery people are friendly, and delivery is FAST. Highly recommend the drunk grandma pizza (or anything with the vodka sauce), escarole and bean soup, and (battered) mozzarella sticks!
… moreAffan Rasool
Absolutely loved my experience at Johnny’s Pizza & Restaurant! The food was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection.
The Drunk Chicken and Buffalo Pie are amazing ❤️
The service was fast and friendly, and the staff made sure everything was just right.
The atmosphere was warm and inviting—perfect for a casual meal or a night out.
Highly recommend this spot to anyone looking for great pizza and a relaxed vibe!
… moreAndrew Dale
This is a great spot! The pizza choices are incredible and the food is crazy good. The garlic roll sliders are a must! Pizza is amazing. The BBQ slices are really good. The chicken sandwiches are also incredible. They also have unusual dessert options! Pizza desserts! Strawberries on a slice is out of this world! You must try this place! A+!
… moreMark Ferencevych
First time ordering from here since a family member recommended their Brooklyn pie. The cheese, sauce and the oregano sprinkled on top was excellent. One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a while. Looking forward to trying some of their other pies. Highly recommended.
… moreDavid Stivers
My go to place, Kids loved the pizza, and especially liked the Nutella and Strawberry pizza. Tried a few flavors and all of them were delicious and well made. Top notch place and will definitely be coming back.
If you’re not a vampire, I would recommend the chicken slider!!! It’s a giant garlic knot with a chicken cutlet, covered in vodka sauce with a fresh slice of mozzarella. Warning though, the garlic will stick around for about a day. But I wouldn’t care if it stuck around for a year, I wouldn’t eat one every day!!!
… moreChristine Aaron
Make sure to stop in and grab a slice. The pizza is amazing. We tried the chicken bacon ranch, plain, pesto and drunk penne chicken and all were great. The owners are also great. So excited to finally have a good pizza place nearby.
… moreMadame Tulipia
Ordered a whole pizza 1/2 meat lovers with mushrooms and 1/2 mushrooms with sausage.
.got 1/2 meatlovers with canned mushrooms and 1/2 with just mushrooms…I’ve been going to Johnny’s pizza since I was a kid…and they ruined this pizza with canned mushrooms…the sauce is still the bomb…but a $40 pizza should taste like one and be correct…totally disappointing
… morePatrick Doran
Some of the best pizza in north jersey better than a lot of places that have been here for decades. Fire salad too.
… more