Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6115 York Rd unit 6, New Oxford, PA 17350
Phone: (717) 688-7250
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Johnny’s Pizza New Oxford
Traditional Pizzeria and Grill, Set in a classic Jersey Diner style. Pizza at johnnyspizzanewoxford.com.
Location & Hours | Johnny’s Pizza New Oxford
Location. Cross Keys Shopping Center. 6115 York Road, Suite 6. New Oxford, Pennsylvania. . Hours. Monday – Thursday 11:00 am – 8:00 pm.
Johnny’s Pizza New Oxford – Facebook
Details. . 98% recommend (63 Reviews). . 6115 York Road, unit 6, New Oxford, PA, United States, 17350 ; Links. . johnnyspizzanewoxford.com ; Contact info. . ( …
Reviews
John Majane
On our way back from an event in Abbotstown and we wanted something for a late lunch. Johnny’s got good reviews and was on the way. It is a small shop with maybe half a dozen tables and a counter. Decorated with various license plates, automotive items and some 50s memorabilia. The woman at the counter was very nice as was the staff who we encountered as the food was delivered and as we were leaving. My friends ordered cheese steaks, I ordered a lunch special, sausage and pepper sub with fries. When the first cheese steak came out we all went wow, they were huge! Not expected. My 1/2 sub was as big as a normal one and it was accompanied by a nice portion of old school krinkle cut fries. The sub was to hot to pick up, baked in the over so I started on the fries. Crisp, perfectly cooked and delicious. Didn’t need catchup they were so good. The sandwich roll cooled down enough to eat and it was excellent. Plenty of nice sausage, peppers and onions. It was great, very tasty. This was a nice find for us. The experience was great, food was great and pricing was very reasonable. I suggest visiting Johnny’s if you are in New Oxford
… moreRandomadventurer 13
I’ve passed this place so often and am thrilled I finally stopped to check it out. Their stuffed meat pizza has two layers of dough to keep all the goodness from slipping off. The pizza crust is like eating breadsticks, so well flavored with herbs and garlic! The Stromboli is packed with cheese, so gooey. Their bacon ranch fries were chock full of bacon. Portion sizes are ginormous! Staff is funny and friendly! 10/10 loved it!
… moreRobert Ebersole
Nice little hidden gem. I always drove past this on 94. The shopping center looks old, never really looked at any of the shops. Then, one day, I wanted pizza and noticed there was a pizza place there.
The inside looks very nice. Like a diner. It’s small but mighty. I guess a lot of people order to go. We were there, and maybe 10 people came in for pick up.
Delicious pizza. Picture perfect.
You order at the counter. Paper plates and such.
… moreThe inside looks very nice. Like a diner. It’s small but mighty. I guess a lot of people order to go. We were there, and maybe 10 people came in for pick up.
Delicious pizza. Picture perfect.
You order at the counter. Paper plates and such.
Greg Ganjon
I started doing electrical work in the area and stopped by to check this place out, and im glad I did. Their lunch menu has very good prices. Both gentlemen greeted me as soon as I walked in. The prices are better then going to a fast food place and spending 13-16 on one meal. Definitely worth a try if you’re in the area.
… moreCheryl Harrell
Hands down the best pizza locally. Dough was light and made to perfection. Side dish was excellent. Restaurant was clean and staff friendly. Prices affordable. It will be our pizza go to place. Looking forward to trying other menu items.
… moreLori Smith
My son and I just started ordering from here and discovered we love the food. Subs,pizza and stromboli are very good and the prices are so reasonable. We have gotten delivery which is always prompt. Will definitely be ordering again .
… moreThomas J Rinnus
Ordered online, website said 30 minutes. I arrived early and was waiting in the car for the time to lapse. The employee came and brought it out to me in less than. 20 minutes after I put the order in. Top notch pizza as well.
… moreMadison Morse
I got delivery for the first time tonight and everything was perfect. We got three pizzas with toppings, wings, and soda for under $60. Can’t beat the prices and quality of food. No delivery fee to go to Hanover. Will definitely be back soon.
… moreTOBIAS MOTTLEY
Great atmosphere and the customer service is top notch. The pizza and cheesesteak were good. I’ll be back.
… moreBarb and Ken Parvis
Stopped here for first time this evening. Why have we waited so long?? The cheese steak sub was fantastic. The steak was seasoned perfectly and the bread was delicious. The grilled chicken bacon club was very good and both subs had good portions. The onion rings were also delicious, made with onion slices, not frozen minced onion! The atmosphere is nothing to get excited about. Dont expect an air conditioned dining room, but the value and quality of the food outweigh this. Definitely will be back for more. Oh, and the staff was friendly and attentive.
… more