Sammie Ebbing
Came on a Saturday so we knew the line was gonna be long. This was our first (and very sadly, only) time coming here. Ordered after waiting an hour and a half (not bad given how long the line was). Food was quick. Pizza was delicious. I loved the cheese toast. Onion rings had a tasty batter, but were a little raw so we took them home to finish cooking and then they were delicious. I’m so sad this place is closing
… moreStephanie Koory
We get Johnny Sortino’s at work all the time! I grew up in Ralston and my parents have been bringing me here my whole life. Our family has hosted numerous birthday parties here, and I even had my baby shower here for my second baby! We love this place and will be missed by our whole family. Great place, great food, great people.
… moreErick Castro
Went with a co-worker on his recommendation, since this was a place he visited often as a kid. Overall, it was ok. Building is definitely older and dated looking, but perfectly fine in a nostalgic kind of way. Walked in and bam!! Right into a long line. Apparently 1130 am is a huge time for lunch rush hour. At 12:00. There was almost no line. When we ordered at the counter, the lady taking the orders was gruff and abrupt but not necessarily, unpolite. I handed her my credit card, she tossed it back… Same with my coworker. Ordered the pizza lunch special and got a side of garlic bread. If you have any kind of appetite, definitely get a side if you’re ordering the lunch pizza special, as the pizza is really small. however, the pizza and garlic bread were really good. Overall, Not a bad experience. I definitely would not seek this place out on my own. But if you’re in the area and want a taste of Omaha nostalgia, it might be worth a stop in.
… moreMomma & Papa Behr (Papa)
Just ‘had’ to try their hot wings & 8″/mini Johnny’s Pizza – not disappointed! Keep their sauce off your lips or get plenty of napkins. I couldn’t help finish off the 3 slices; no need for a take out box!
WOW – to think it took me so long before stopping in to this pizza parlor, it’s my loss! We didn’t mind the Arcade section but avoided the adjacent dining area for their game day setting. The four screens provide ample coverage, if your game is airing during their scheduled times. We looked beyond the dated decor and discovered a new HIGH BENCHMARK with their manicotti!! EXTREMELY flavor filled Red Sauce paired with an ultra buttery cheesey bread and side salad (we opted for the house dressing).
We don’t order pizza at a burger joint, so we didn’t consider their burger options. The 8″ pizza provides enough for two people but can easily be polished off by a hungry teen or elder. The crispy crust compliments the sauce very well with plenty of choice toppings for everyone, including anchovies for any adventure seekers. The checkered cut is standard but it didn’t detract from our enjoyment. One might consider ordering extra meatballs with your pasta if you or your crew enjoys a meaty pizza. We found the food and friendly service more than compensation for the decor.
COVID caused them to adjust hours, so call early or make sure you get there before they close. Either way, your taste buds will thank you!!
… moreSophia Sophia Yall!
The lady that took my order was very nice. I don’t know if this was intentional or what but it was wayy too many olives on the slice of pizza. It had to be about 20 olives per slice. I rated it a three because the crust and the sauce was good.
… moreKyle Nordyke
We stopped here on a Saturday night after driving by and reading some reviews while visiting Omaha. The place was absolutely packed but we were seated right away and because of the way you order we got our food quickly.
The onion rings and cheese sticks were good and I would order again.
We got a large 4 meat pizza and it was delicious. I liked the crust and the volume of toppings they put on.
The cost was less than expected so that makes it all taste that much better!
… morebswi007
Family pizza parlor that’s been around about 40 years now! BEST pizza in town! Busses was hit hard by COVID and still have limited hours if operation.
… moreJordan Brigham
Soild fours! The service was kind and courteous! And the pizza was made quickly, even during their lunch rush! I got a pepperoni and Italian sausage pizza! It’s delicious, hot, and hearty! And I love how it’s not super greasy! The crust and sauce are probably my two favorite parts of it! The crust is crunchy and crisp. While the sauce is hearty and savory! Definitely gonna have to try different pizzas and other dishes! Happy I looked up local pizza places!
… moreS Collins
Best in Omaha, best in Nebraska. Throw back to a better time in pizza with real ingredients going into a pizza parlor style product. A nod to the Italian immigrant speciality that made the food famous 80 years ago. Outstanding food.
… moreiSpent 2Much
Favorite pizza spot in Omaha. I drive over an hour just for a good pizza. Their marinara is simple and delicious! I may just order a gallon of it, if they will let me!
… more