Johnny Mustard’s has good vibes that you can eat!! Fast and casual grub on the cheap. Italian Sandwich deli classics with gourmet flair and summer time Hot Dog goodness like you never seen. Then there’s Mama Mustard’s signature chili… don’t even get me started! JM’s has got something for everyone! Come grab a bite!
Menu – Johnny Mustard’s
Ground Beef, Kidney & Pinto Beans, Onion, Bell Pepper, and Chipotle in a Tomato Sauce & our Secret Chili Spices! $4.50 – $8.50. Out …
Brianna Potts
It’s a cute little place, very limited counter seating The Chicago dog was authentic & very good, the Italian beef (not pictured bc me and my bf scarfed it down) was to die for & they let you order half and half with different peppers if you want to sub them out. I liked the Italian sub and I’m not normally a sub kind of girl 10/10 we will be coming back
… moreJocelyn Tomaszycki
Amazing Chicago style sub/hot dog place. Highly recommend! Got the Calabrese Italian, the Balboa, and a Chicago dog sub habanero mustard. Everything was perfectly spicy please stop by and grab a sub or dog! Also the au jus was incredible
… moreFrankie Reads
Ordered through Door Dash for the first time today and was blown away by how delicious my food was. Perfect chili dogs, think the best dog you’ve ever had at Coney but with better quality ingredients. Even though dasher executed two stops before dropping my order off, my dogs were still hot. Family said the sub was delicious. Bread and meat quality were really high with the perfect toppings.
My only request is; please add your side dishes (chips, potato salad, etc) to the Door Dash menu – thanks! Can’t wait to order from here again.
… moreC S
Couldn’t wait to try this new addition to the neighborhood, and it was worth the wait! Came with friends, we had the classic chili dog, Padrino Italian and Ciabano. All were tasty and filling. This is a great lunch spot and we agreed we’ll be back! The mural is pretty cool and super friendly staff, too!
… moreJoshua Pippin
I think the sandwiches are great here. And I enjoyed the Chicago dog as well. The place is clean. That being said, I was disappointed by the service recently.
I called to place an order for four sandwiches. I was told that was too large of an order 30 minutes before close. Four sandwiches? No modifications and only two different types of sandwiches. 2x turkey and 2x spicy Italian. Not ten minutes before closing time but 30. I understand having a cutoff time for orders, and me personally, I wouldn’t have even called if it was any closer to close. But just a heads up for anyone thinking of placing a “large” order so close to closing time.
… moreDaif Hassan
First time trying it and the food was great. Kyle’s service was exceptional and he did a good job at recommending some staples for me to try
… moreDon Larson
Their spices Italian sub was delicious! I tried their beef sub. It was dripping with sauce. Great flavor but to to be eaten on the road.
… moreDavid Goff
I’m an Italian sub aficionado, and I have to say—Johnny Mustard’s Padrino Italian Sub is probably the best I’ve ever had (and I’ve had some great ones). The quality sliced meats were generously stacked, and the bread roll struck the perfect balance between soft and hard. The peppers (banana and giardiniera), dressing/mayo, and seasonings were all perfectly portioned and came together to create a true masterpiece. Grab an ice-cold bottle of Coke to go with it. Awesome place and friendly people!
… moreHayleigh Zuk
First time trying their subs, and couldn’t be happier! I had the Johnny Primo which was delicious, the roast beef was high quality and very tender, just the right amount of horseradish to balance everything with a little kick. I also picked up the Calabrese Italian and the Padrino for coworkers, who gave rave reviews. Staff was friendly and easygoing. I’ll be back 🙂
… moreMiss Nicky
I saw the munu online and was super excited to try. It was Christmas Eve I think and the website said they were open but it was not sp I didn’t get to try it yet. So the reason for 4, stars was because It said they were open and my hope was up. But I intend to come back because the SS sandwich selection sounds amazing
… more