Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
New American & global fare in a welcoming bistro where drapes & framed artwork set a quaint scene.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 45 Foster Ave, Sayville, NY 11782
Phone: (631) 589-4600
Website: http://www.cafejoelle.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.comtoasttab.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Dining Experience | Joelle | Barroom + Cafe | Sayville, NY
Enjoy a unique dining experience with international flavors. Visit us! Sayville, NY.
Joelle • Barroom + Cafe (@cafejoelle) • Instagram photos and videos
6.9K+ followers · 708 following · 1213 posts · @cafejoelle: “Landmark restaurant and bar in the heart of Sayville”
Cafe Joelle | Sayville NY – Facebook
Cafe Joelle, Sayville. 5074 likes · 63 talking about this · 8114 were here. Located in downtown Sayville NY. This 25 year staple has been recently…
Reviews
Natalia Ilina
Updated December 11, 2025.
We had lunch and thoroughly enjoyed it. Thank you!
The beautiful Christmas decorations created a very cozy atmosphere.
***
This restaurant is ideally located for my friend and me, we selected it for our lunch outing. It was my first visit to a new location.
For my lunch, I chose the onion soup, which I found to be quite enjoyable.
The flavors were well-balanced, and I appreciated that it wasn’t excessively salty, a common issue in many other restaurants.
The staff was both friendly and efficient.
I liked the restaurant’s decor; it strikes a perfect balance between formal and casual.
It’s a good place for a relaxed lunch with a friend or a dinner gathering with a larger party.
In my opinion, it may be somewhat noisy for a business lunch if your group exceeds four people, but that’s just my perspective.
The seating arrangements cater well to both couples and larger groups, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.
I also liked the artwork on the walls, which added a charming personal touch to the ambiance.
Best wishes for your new location!
I look forward to come back.
… moreWe had lunch and thoroughly enjoyed it. Thank you!
The beautiful Christmas decorations created a very cozy atmosphere.
***
This restaurant is ideally located for my friend and me, we selected it for our lunch outing. It was my first visit to a new location.
For my lunch, I chose the onion soup, which I found to be quite enjoyable.
The flavors were well-balanced, and I appreciated that it wasn’t excessively salty, a common issue in many other restaurants.
The staff was both friendly and efficient.
I liked the restaurant’s decor; it strikes a perfect balance between formal and casual.
It’s a good place for a relaxed lunch with a friend or a dinner gathering with a larger party.
In my opinion, it may be somewhat noisy for a business lunch if your group exceeds four people, but that’s just my perspective.
The seating arrangements cater well to both couples and larger groups, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.
I also liked the artwork on the walls, which added a charming personal touch to the ambiance.
Best wishes for your new location!
I look forward to come back.
CB
Went here for a party! Service and drinks were great! The penna alla vodka was pretty good, but the chicken francese with pasta was dry. Would definitely try this place again.
… morekim saur
A busy lunch crowd but Maria was still attentive. Lunch was delicious and the over atmosphere was pleasant.
… moreErin Giuliano
Loved Cafe Joelle when it was on Main Street. Now it’s just ho hum. Service was terrible and my husband made the reservation for my birthday and the table next to us got the cake and sung to! Lol entrees and app were good, but there’s so many other places out there with excellent food and the server doesn’t act like you’re putting them out and we’re very easy with no extras or changes!
… moreSharon Treadwell
Valentines Dinner was a bust! My husband had the blackened Snapper he fully enjoyed it, I ordered the sauerbraten! OH boy! The top piece was like rayhide the 3 other pieces were dried out around the edges! The potato pancakes were hard and cold! The waitress offered another meal or soup? But I wanted to enjoy a meal with my husband, then the manager came over and said ya the ends come out like that?? REALLY the chef should have never sent it out of their kitchen! We paid for the whole meal and they took my glass of wine off the check! Very disappointed! Our reservation was at 3:30, not prime time rush! The waitress was very sweet
… moreMfr Tech
Wife and I went for an early dinner I had strip steak mashed potatoes asparagus , My wife had the chicken prosciutto sandwich with fries ,For dessert we shared a Peanut Butter Oreo Brownie served over a giant chocolate chip cookie with vanilla ice cream, drizzled with warm peanut butter I gave a four star for service only because the waiter didn’t come around for an extended amount of time to ask if there was any thing we needed, My wife wanted blue cheese for her sandwich but other than that all was good clean place plenty of room for a wheelchair I didn’t use the bathroom while I was there but my wife tells me the women’s room would be very tight for a wheelchair we will be returning for another dinner in the future.
… moreDaniel Tusso
I went to this restaurant yesterday with family and we all loved it so much! For appetizers, we ordered bacon wrapped shrimp, grilled calamari, and pulled pork pierogis. Then, for my entrée, I had the Traditional Reuben which was really delicious and filling! The side of French Fries was really delicious too, and I would have something like that again. Wonderful experience overall!
… moreBlanca
Very busy for 6:30 Saturday night (and extremely loud). Lucky thing we had reservations because it was a long wait. Shelby was our server and she was good. We all enjoyed our meals and dessert. Very surprised to see an Albariño on the wine list. I spoke to Jake (one of the owners) & said it was the best one I’ve ever had.
… moreStephanie Zentgraf
This was our second time at Cafe Joelle and both times were great.
The food was fresh and hot. Chicken francese and penne a la vodka were my favorites.
The desserts were delicious -homemade gelato served in a delicious waffle cup and tonight I had the apple tart with vanilla ice cream. Really delicious!
The service is friendly and attentive, there is plenty of staff asking if there is anything you need.
The cafe is brand new and very pretty. It was Friday night and it was packed but still did not have to wait long for anything.
Also, the drinks looked great. I had a mocktail and it was delicious!
We actually liked it so much we booked our daughters baby shower there! They seemed to be flexible and happy to work with you without crazy rules.
… moreThe food was fresh and hot. Chicken francese and penne a la vodka were my favorites.
The desserts were delicious -homemade gelato served in a delicious waffle cup and tonight I had the apple tart with vanilla ice cream. Really delicious!
The service is friendly and attentive, there is plenty of staff asking if there is anything you need.
The cafe is brand new and very pretty. It was Friday night and it was packed but still did not have to wait long for anything.
Also, the drinks looked great. I had a mocktail and it was delicious!
We actually liked it so much we booked our daughters baby shower there! They seemed to be flexible and happy to work with you without crazy rules.
Richard Westley
What happened to this place? They previously had one of the best burgers around but now it seems like it came out of a box of frozen ones. The fries were ok but also frozen. I had ordered the burger medium rare but it come out nearly well done.
The top was grey and it was horrible. When restaurants try to fool customers they will get hurt.
… moreThe top was grey and it was horrible. When restaurants try to fool customers they will get hurt.