john smith
Lady behind counter was rude and not a very nice person. Ordered a Sicilian pizza and paid $29. The pizza was subpar at best. Dough was bland and like rubber. The sauce was most definitely from a can ragu would have been better, the cheese was fake and nasty it tasted like cardboard. Overall the pizza horrible and the service lacking. Me and my family have order multiple times hopeing it would get better. It has not, unfortunately their are not many good pizza options in Hawley please avoid this place and save your money it was a truly bad bad pizza. Frozen is so much better and that’s not saying much.
… moreDaddyWags
8/2025. I don’t give many crappy reviews but unfortunately the food here was less than stellar and did not match the price point. The meatballs were pretty good but the rest…. not so much.
The cheese steak stromboli was a lot of cheese and not much steak. The calamari was extremely chewy. The gnocchi was sub par and the Italian sandwich was made with ham so think you could use the slices for roof shingles. Now I know some people like their ham cut thick but for me, no good. If you’re like me and you like deli meats sliced super thin and piled high, this is not the sandwich to get. The tomato slices were also incredibly thick.
This restaurant needs to step up its game a bit unless we caught it on an off day. My guess is it stays in business just due to sheer volume of people in the area going to lake wallenpaupack.
… moreTodd Brinkmann
The pizza is almost as good as in NYC. The Garlic Knots are a must have, best I’ve ever had. I purposely drive out of my way to stop there to get them.
… moreNatalia Decelle
Unacceptable Service – A Full 50-Minute Wait for a Half-Cooked Pizza!
I am beyond furious with the service I received today. I placed an order and was told it would be ready in 25 minutes—reasonable, right? Well, 25 minutes passed, and I waited. Then 30 minutes… 40 minutes… and I still hadn’t gotten my pizza! After a FULL 40 minutes of waiting, they finally handed me my order, but it gets worse. I was asked to wait ANOTHER 15 minutes while they “finished” preparing it.
That’s right—FIFTY MINUTES in total for a pizza that was *not* even properly cooked! The crust was soggy, the toppings were raw, and the entire thing was an absolute disaster. How do you mess up something as simple as a pizza?
It’s completely unacceptable to quote one time and then leave customers hanging for nearly double. And when the food finally arrives, it’s not even close to what was expected. I will never be ordering from here again, and I strongly recommend others to avoid it unless they want to waste an hour of their time for a terrible meal.
Zero stars if I could give them that. Avoid this place at all costs.
… moreManny Montañez
We love local places. Here, the atmosphere is so nice. The staff and the public were full of humor and spirits were high. The prices were reasonable and the portions were amazing. This is a great place to visit. Just be ready to eat. Go on an empty stomach. And enjoy.
… moreLauren Moore
I really wanted to like Joe and Lorenzo’s, but my experience was disappointing from start to finish. The woman at the front was not friendly or welcoming at all, which immediately set the tone. While we waited to order, our waitress sat by the door playing a game that they had in the waiting area and complaining about other workers instead of helping customers. We had to wait for her to finish before she even took our drink order.
We decided to order pizza by the slice, but it was definitely iffy. It seemed like older pizza that had just been reheated with extra cheese tossed on top to make it look “fresh,” but it definitely wasn’t. Overall, the service and food left a lot to be desired, and I won’t be rushing back.
… moreDamaris Ortiz
Ist time at this restaurant. We took a train ride here from honesdale pa. Food is fantastic. Definitely recommend.
… moreJudith Maurer
Just because you’re busy doesn’t mean you should ignore me and throw the menu at me not even say hi or acknowledge me just threw a menu at me. Then I proceeded to wait 15 minutes and you still never came over to my table. The only thing good about your place is is pretty inside. And the pizza cook when people order pizza you wear your gloves and you don’t eat the pepperoni off the top of the pizza and cover it with cheese that was absolutely disgusting. I watched you do it. Maybe I’ll decide to pop in again and give you a better review hopefully I’ll get better service but it won’t be very soon that’s for sure….. Totally unacceptable!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
… moreBrandy Fahy
Walking into this establishment we were greeted by the sweetest Italian lady and just knew the food would be amazing. && she did NOT disappoint! Great food, great service, and the price wasn’t bad!! Definitely stop in!
… moreanthonyelevatorguy
Prices are good ! Food is delicious, lived here 21 years and came up on weekends before that , it’s worth the few inconveniences that some might feel or not , it’s not Chuck E. Cheese try it ! My photo is from the side of building.
… more