Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Joe Cristiano’s Pizza is your neighborhood pizzeria! What does that mean to us? Well for starters – exceptional food, service, and value. We work hard every day to not be your ordinary pizza restaurant. Our team works hard to go above and beyond in every way that matters to you, our customer. Premium pizza is our priority, so we use only the finest and freshest ingredients available. But we don’t stop at just pizza. Guests also rave about our wings, pastas, and hot subs! Our diverse menu is sure to have something to suit your cravings, and all at a great value, too. We understand that you have many choices when it comes to feeding your family or friends so at Joe Cristiano’s Pizza we always do our best to be your pizzeria of choice!
No-frills outlet dishing classic & creative pies along with a variety of Italian basics & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1225 NY-9G, Hyde Park, NY 12538
Phone: (845) 229-8125
Website: https://www.joecristianospizza.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Joe Cristiano’s Pizza
For over 15 years, at Joe Cristiano’s Pizza, our focus remains clear, a smaller menu, done right, the way a pizza place should be. We offer pizza, wings, …
Joe Cristiano’s Pizza – Hyde Park, NY – 1225 NY-9G – Hours, Menu …
Order Hours About. 11:30 AM-9:00 PM; Shop address is 1225 NY-9G, Hyde Park, NY 125381225 NY-9G, Hyde Park, NY 12538; (845) 253-4668.
Joe Cristiano’s Pizza – 1225 NY-9G, Hyde Park, NY 12538 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Hyde Park, NY! Joe Cristiano’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Reviews
Grenisha Meekins
I did delivery, I got meatball sliders & fries. The sliders come individually but, I ordered 4 was surprisingly full around the 3rd one I ate. They gave me a bunch of fries lol which is always appreciated. No complaints. The delivery took a little long but maybe I was just hungry and getting impatient lol they did tell me 45mins- 1 hour it took exactly 1 hour lol. So can’t really be mad right? Lol anyways I would order again though.
… moreMichael Zastenchik
I don’t know man , this is just careless pizza craftsmanship by who ever made this. I’ve never had a pizza flop over like this and also with no cheese on half of the pie. I like to order from Hyde park because this isn’t the first time this had happened from the salt point location but because of my address they make me order from sadly point. disappointed to say the least and I’ve never left a review before or even complained but 55 dollars down the drain in this economy is upsetting as I had family over and this was pretty embarrassing to serve.
… moreN. M
The girl pretended they didn’t have my order so she could go smoke in her car. Then the food was there after we called and went back in, to verify we did not order from the wrong store. Then the wrap was literally saturated in dressing. Just all around not a good experience.
… morejames callaizakis
Joe’s has great pizza for sure! We have ordered from them for years because of the consistency. What I do not understand is how a Sweet Thai chili pizza is $27 when a meat lovers and most of the rest are $21. Chicken is cheaper than meat! Just don’t understand this! Other than that, Joes is great!
… moreJay Christy
Joe’s is our go to pizza place in Hyde Park. A few times a month and usually on a Friday, we will order up a pie and hot wings. Joe serves quality pizza and has a good selection of toppings. My only recommendation would be to cook their wings just a little longer. I plan to keep going back for more.
… moreTwo Spoons
Overall – Low profile presence but great quality pie
Food – Had a White Delight. Many places struggle with a good non-red sauce pizza, but they were on point. Good ingredients, cooked just right, and even larger than expected.
Service – Greeted promptly, ordering was easy, delivered timely.
Atmosphere – Mostly a takeout place, but there is room for a small group to sit and enjoy their meal.
Price – Very reasonably priced.
… moreFood – Had a White Delight. Many places struggle with a good non-red sauce pizza, but they were on point. Good ingredients, cooked just right, and even larger than expected.
Service – Greeted promptly, ordering was easy, delivered timely.
Atmosphere – Mostly a takeout place, but there is room for a small group to sit and enjoy their meal.
Price – Very reasonably priced.
Arina G
Hole in the wall spot. Can’t sit inside or outside. Really just there to call in order and pick it up. The Salt Point location has actual tables and chairs for sit down service. Service is slow, out of all the males working there only one was slightly pleasant to speak with while waiting a long time for the order placed. Food is delicious though.
… moreMessiah’s House
It was 7:45 on a Sunday night and we’d been traveling all day, car issues, up at 3am for an airport run, the whole 9. Anyhow, we’re getting to our airbnb and turned into Joe’s before their 8pm closing time. They’d just washed all the floors and were closing up for they day. They offered the nice variety of pizza by the slice, which was our choice and excellent! But offered to make us anything on the menu, not rushing us out, gave us free garlic knots and then came and offered an order of chicken wings because they’d just dropped it in the cooker when the order was canceled! Great food, amazing service, they bent over backwards! Highly recommend these guys and their wonderful pizza!
… moreDean Kresge
Purchased a classic pizza….with extra sauce.
The last classic bought here was terrible…only toppings on very middle of pizza…after 2 bites…i was eating a cheese pizza.
I figured id give them a second shot at it this go round.
There were plenty of toppings….although…The very middle of pizza had sauce …but 2 bites in any slice…and no extra sauce….or at all for that matter. The sauce makes the pizza for my taste buds. Being not what I paid for…i will never buy a pizza here ever again.
In past…the subs are good….will only buy subs here from here on out.
… moreThe last classic bought here was terrible…only toppings on very middle of pizza…after 2 bites…i was eating a cheese pizza.
I figured id give them a second shot at it this go round.
There were plenty of toppings….although…The very middle of pizza had sauce …but 2 bites in any slice…and no extra sauce….or at all for that matter. The sauce makes the pizza for my taste buds. Being not what I paid for…i will never buy a pizza here ever again.
In past…the subs are good….will only buy subs here from here on out.
Vic Collazo
Honestly not designed for atmosphere, it’s a in and out pizza joint
You want good pizza, and you want to get home to eat. This is your place. Try them out enjoy
… moreYou want good pizza, and you want to get home to eat. This is your place. Try them out enjoy