Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
A sizable menu of Italian-American comfort eats are offered at this informal, family-owned joint.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 11 E Mohawk St, Buffalo, NY 14203
Phone: (716) 883-8200
Website: http://casadipizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Our Menu – JJ’s Casa Di Pizza
CHOICE OF SAUCES traditional Buffalo Style (hot, med, mild), our homemade bbq, hybrid (hot & bbq), cajun, honey mustard, garlic parm, char-grilled-bbq …
JJs Casa Di Pizza – Buffalo, NY – 11 E Mohawk St – Hours, Menu …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for JJs Casa Di Pizza in Buffalo, NY. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
JJ’s Casa-Di-Pizza | Buffalo NY – Facebook
Since 1953 Family owned and operated full service restaurant and bar, large dog friendly outdoor patio, catering service, takeout and delivery.
Product
Reviews
338
I’m from Idaho, here on a business trip, Staying at the Hilton Down Town and googled pizza near me. This place did not disappoint. The Wings were Scrumptious, the Pizza even better. The Staff was Great and answered all my meticulous questions about good food and beer in Buffalo NY. I would say a Must goto in this area.
… moreURMy Sunshine
The deep dish pizza is very nice. They have wide range of beer and drink selection. Service is nice too.
… moreJoanne Zakowski
We ordered drop off catering for our office holiday party. Start to finish- everything was excellent. The customer service was friendly and accommodating. They don’t need much notice: we ordered on Monday for a Thursday party. Delivery driver was friendly and on time. The food was hot and delicious. We had the roast beef, lemon chicken, scalloped potatoes, Alfredo penne pasta and tossed salad. The delivery included paper products, plastic wear, serving utensils, rolls, butter, salad dressings and horseradish. Highly recommend!!! Everyone at the party commented on the quality of the meal.
… moreMary Krencik
Pizza was amazing!
The deep dish won my heart and the restaurant is very cozy!
… moreThe deep dish won my heart and the restaurant is very cozy!
David J
My family a party of 6 was just turned away at 5pm. The place had one table sitting eating. The eyes on us and the looks from the staff was evident they didn’t want to seat us as we walked through to the dinning room. I haven’t dined in cases di pizza since the last location on elmwood but as long as I can remember this establishment has been a staple to me of what a dining experience should be. Always had friendly staff and great food. I’ve never felt so unwelcome in a restaurant in my life. Clearly this isn’t the same establishment I grew up with and it’s a shame I wont be passing on the same experience my parents passed to me there
… moreHeather LaneMcCants
We had a small deep dish pizza with pepperoni on one half and peppers and onions on the other. I dunked mine in ranch. It was sooooo good. I’m still thinking about that pizza. The server was quick and friendly and the place had a hometown vibe without making us feel like outsiders. The Pepsi and the water were both good. They have a jukebox in the dining area and sports on the TVs. I appreciated the signs “All y’all are welcome but you gotta act right” and LGBTQ Safe Space. ❤️ I would definitely go again.
We managed to grab a parallel parking spot right out front, but there’s also a paid parking lot less than a block away. The bathroom was functional and clean, nothing fancy.
… moreWe managed to grab a parallel parking spot right out front, but there’s also a paid parking lot less than a block away. The bathroom was functional and clean, nothing fancy.
John Laub
This was supposed to be extra cheese and pepperoni.. and I drove all the way from niagara falls… smdh for $125 nope. Not again. Very let down.
… moreJeffry Jaskolka
My family and I stopped here for lunch after vacationing in Niagara Falls, and it was the best decision ever! As someone from Philly, I’ve always wanted to try real Buffalo wings, and these were the best I’ve ever had. The pizza was excellent too. Flavorful and perfectly sized. Great atmosphere, friendly staff, and our server Britney was fantastic. Highly recommend JJ’s Casa Di Pizza if you’re ever in Buffalo!
… moreCourtney Piazza
Pre ordered 3 pizzas and 30 tenders online at 8am before they opened. I used their recommended app “Slice”. My order was set to pick up at 2:55pm. At 2:08 they cancelled my order. No phone call or nothing just an email letting me know. I had to feed 15 people by 3pm so you can imagine the panic I was in. I ordered online so early because I was not going to have access to my phone until 2:45. Absolutely ridiculous. Will avoid this place
… moreJuli Sidor
I have on and off been a customer of Casa for 30 years and today was the worst experience I have had with them. I ordered a pizza at 2:15pm (Half Pepperoni/Half Mushroom) and they said it would be 25 min. I was on the 5 mins away went to the store down the street for at the most 10 mins and came to pick up the pie. I peeked at the pie and the mushroom side looked fine. The pie wasn’t hot but I didn’t consider why. The why was it was an old pie made of two separate halves and but together. Looking at the photos, you can tell by the cheese that this is comprised of two separate pies possible from the lunch service. It wasn’t even luke warm and they pulled the pie from the warmer when I arrived.
Why would it be in the warmer if I just ordered the pizza 15 mins ago? The fact that it was luke warm had me at a lost. In the past (even when they were on Elmwood) they were one of the best shops in town. I know places now days love to take short cuts including their competition but why do this when all you have to do is “Do the Right Thing”. When on Elmwood they had a dynamite display of pies during lunch and throughout the afternoon and now it feels like they just simply do not care as much as they did.
I’ve paid above average prices when I sat in and you know what… I didn’t mind as long as the food was good and the expeerience was nice. Look at the photos along side this review and tell me these came from ONE pie and not two. The pizza was tough and I am speaking on the half of an elderly woman I care for. I know they can do better but the question is will they? The moment you look under a pie and it’s blackened it one of two things. Either a dirty oven OR they warmed that pie (pies? slices?) a second time.
… moreWhy would it be in the warmer if I just ordered the pizza 15 mins ago? The fact that it was luke warm had me at a lost. In the past (even when they were on Elmwood) they were one of the best shops in town. I know places now days love to take short cuts including their competition but why do this when all you have to do is “Do the Right Thing”. When on Elmwood they had a dynamite display of pies during lunch and throughout the afternoon and now it feels like they just simply do not care as much as they did.
I’ve paid above average prices when I sat in and you know what… I didn’t mind as long as the food was good and the expeerience was nice. Look at the photos along side this review and tell me these came from ONE pie and not two. The pizza was tough and I am speaking on the half of an elderly woman I care for. I know they can do better but the question is will they? The moment you look under a pie and it’s blackened it one of two things. Either a dirty oven OR they warmed that pie (pies? slices?) a second time.