Social Profile: 
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Jimmy’s Hilltop Ice Cream and Eatery – Reviews, Photos & Phone …
Jimmy’s Hilltop Ice Cream and Eatery is a beloved local destination in Effort, PA, known for its extensive selection of ice cream flavors, …
Order Jimmy’s Hilltop Ice Cream and Eatery – Menu & Prices
Use your Uber account to order delivery from Jimmy’s Hilltop Ice Cream and Eatery in Effort. Browse the menu, view popular items, and track your order.
Untitled
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • Comfort Food • Desserts • $$. 2087-2095 U.S. 209, Effort, PA 18330. Available in 31 min. Allergens: These items may include …
Reviews
Dawud M
Jimmy’s Hilltop Ice Cream is very good, and they have a large selection of flavors to choose from. They also sell a small variety of food Whichever flavor of ice cream you choose, you can’t go wrong. They have a quality product with great customer service
… moreelyse kiel
Best ice cream and French fries in eastern PA. Ghost enjoyed his time here as well
… moreGreg Scholes
Classic ice cream stand like they were in the good old days. Great selection of flavors and assorted other offers, including non-dairy ice cream. We had various ice creams, all excellent. I had a banana ice cream shake, which was splendid. This is my favorite ice cream restaurant I have been to in the US.
… moreDana Hull
Love this place! I have been enjoying hilltop since I was a child and finally after years of back and forth with new owners, Jimmy found the hidden gem to make his own! The food is delicious, ice cream is amazing and service is excellent! The young group of teens that work there pep it up some with their bubbly personalities! The other staff members are just as wonderful! If you ever get a chance to meet jimmy himself he is great too! Love all of his locations!!
… moreCharleen Torrenti
Great menu selection of all sorts of items..ice creams in particular. The vanilla soft serve ice cream is very smooth and tastes great. The service was fast, even for the warm evening with a line it was smooth. The two who helped us were polite and friendly. They have a nice outdoor seating area and an area for kids to play next to it.
… moreTiffani George
Came here for the first time since I was a child with my 3 kiddos and boyfriend last night. It was as great as I remember it being years ago. All the women working the window were super friendly and cheerful! They have SO many options, including my fave… DIP TOP!
… moreJordan Shaw
I was really hoping this would’ve been better but it isn’t a place we’ll be going to again. Despite the sweet customer service, the ice cream was not flavorful (plus my waffle cone tasted stale) and the pretzel was very obviously heated from frozen in the microwave.
… moreChristeen Oneill
Their burger and french fries were delicious, but their onion rings were outstanding. And of course their ice cream is absolutely wonderful. Clean establishment and courteous staff.
… moreMichael Duffek (Michael Duffek)
Great shakes and a giant menu of flavors and items.
… moreRebekka Shepherd
Fast service despite a decent crowd. Gave every kid a $6 budget and ended up with so much ice cream plus toppings!
… more