Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Founded in 1958, this local pizza chain also offers casual Italian sandwiches & entrees.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3 S Main St, New Salem Borough, PA 17371
Phone: (717) 792-3078
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Comings & Goings Jim & Nena’s pizza in New Salem will close this …
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty has over 30 offices serving Maryland and Pennsylvania … Jim & Nena’s in New Salem borough has …
Jim & Nena’s Pizzeria – Delicious Pizza in New Salem Borough
Enjoy mouthwatering pizza and a cozy atmosphere at Jim & Nena’s Pizzeria in New Salem Borough, PA. Perfect for families and friends alike!
Reviews
Eric J
We moved away almost 6 years ago and have been trying to find or emulate the strombolis they serve here but have only come marginally close. The Italian stromboli was as delicious as I remember and hits the spot every time. We love this Jim and Nena’s location and talk about often to our friends and family from out of the area. When we lived here, we would bring our guests to this location and were never disappointed. Great food every time!
The dining room has been updated and it looks great! It used to have yellow paint and miamatched furniture but now everything matches and has greatly improved the feel/atmosphere. We will definitely be back the next time we are in the area.
… moreThe dining room has been updated and it looks great! It used to have yellow paint and miamatched furniture but now everything matches and has greatly improved the feel/atmosphere. We will definitely be back the next time we are in the area.
Katie Hollingshead
Best pizza around I come here quite often, and they never failed to disappoint. Food is always great, my kids even love the food and the workers are very friendly and outgoing every time I come in they recognize and remember me, which is nice. Could use a little upgrade in the dining area, but overall a nice little family owned business. Keep up the good work
… moreWendy Fischer
Had stopped when I first moved nearby, but seemed average. New old management info popped up so I took a chance, it was great. Called in on my phone to pick up a pizza, positive vibe. Really busy when I got there, but waited while staff worked well together to fill orders. Really positive,welcoming place. Pizza was in oven, but there was no hurry up and get it to the customer even if it’s not done attitude. The pizza was great, cheese and pepperoni with just the right crust. Price was good too. Will return to try out something else on the menu.
… moreDarlene Wolinski
Pizza was great and they had gluten-free options too. The service was stellar and the atmosphere authentic and charming.
… moreIsaiah Campbell
Such a cool little pizza shop, but more importantly probably the most friendly staff I have witnessed in today’s world. And everything there has always been amazingly tasty!
… moreCorinne Clinch Gray
Love the 3rd Saturday worship times. And my Hawaiian pizza had so many good toppings on it!
… moreAngela Marie
I’ve been eating at this Jim and Nina’s since I was a little girl. The quality has not wavered. Love it and thank you!
… moreDavid Reist
Worth driving for!
Pizza was amazing! Hard workers at this location.
Dining in ambiance is tasteful and very reminiscent of a classic pizza shop. Exposed beams and “stained glass” door panels along with a faux mantel piece really bring character to the building.
… morePizza was amazing! Hard workers at this location.
Dining in ambiance is tasteful and very reminiscent of a classic pizza shop. Exposed beams and “stained glass” door panels along with a faux mantel piece really bring character to the building.
Philip Keithley
Great food both eat in and take out. Normal sandwich shop, pizza menu. Quick service and good food.
… moreJohn Fiore
Great food and staff. New York good pizza!
Service: …
… moreService: …