Jersey Bagel Cafe & Pizza

Order online at one of the best restaurants in Willingboro, NJ! Jersey Bagel Cafe & Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …

Jersey Bagel Cafe & Pizza Delivery Menu – Willingboro – Grubhub

Order delivery or pickup from Jersey Bagel Cafe & Pizza in Willingboro! View Jersey Bagel Cafe & Pizza’s March 2026 deals and menus.

Last Updates

Reviews

Brandon Sanderson

I’ve stopped here a few times for their fresh, soft bagels, which are always fantastic, so this time I decided to give their pizza a try. The flavor was really good — rich sauce, plenty of cheese, and a nice crust. I ordered what they called a Chicago deep dish, and while it wasn’t the classic thick style I expected, it still tasted amazing once I adjusted my expectations.

Their fries are also worth mentioning — thick, golden, and full of flavor. The only thing I’d tweak next time is asking for fresh mushrooms instead of the canned ones, though it didn’t take away from how tasty everything was overall.

This place continues to impress, and I’ll definitely keep coming back. Also, I still think they should lean into their name and start offering pizza bagels — that would be perfection!

… more

Breanna Gleason

The bagels taste like stale rolls. They didn’t taste like bagels at all. The everything bagel was way too salty. They were super hard to cut. Wouldn’t recommend wasting your time or calories on it. Service was fine just wish the bagels didn’t taste like a stale roll.

… more

C C

I just stumped on this place is tucked away in a little corner I was pleasantly surprised I got one of the best pizza I had it a long time then I went back for chicken wings it was a nice surprise to find whole chicken wings fried to perfection season extremely well it might be a good idea to stop in and see for yourself I was impressed

… more

Cool looks

You’re only getting the 1 start because the fries were good. The burger nooooo. Just take it off the menu you obviously don’t like making them. Look at the whole lettuce you put in it. Did you even try ? Hope the rest of the food does not go out like this.

… more

Love Bug

First time visiting. Excellent calzone and Baklava. Very cozy place. Friendly employees. The menu has so many delicious options. Can’t wait to go back and try something else.

… more

Deborah Capelli

I have no words to describe this review except for 100% pure disgust because my photos say it all! Never in my life have I ever received food covered in mold and on top of that was so angry when not only did I have to call Slice 6 times but this restaurant and was in shock by the most insincere apology I’ve ever experienced. I’ve gotten more sincere apologies and completely comped food from a bad meal versus something as disgusting an as inexcusable as this! An insincere apology won’t even come close to EVER make this okay in my book! “Sorry that happened we already refunded your $5.74 What else do you want me to say?” WOW!! ARE YOU SERIOUS??!!!!!! All I know is that entire order went into the trash! Good luck if you order from this establishment! That’s all I gotta to say!

… more

Margarita Rivera

The food is great, portions are perfect! It was a nice place to eat breakfast with the hubby!

… more

Jennifer houlihan

Stopped in for a bagel but walked by the pizza and had to change my mind. My son and I each got a plain and a sausage slice. Wish we chose a bagel breakfast sandwich instead, pizza was just ok. We were there before noon, but it was already pretty busy. Per the menu, there are a ton of choices, even a huge selection of pizzas. Not familiar with the area or restaurant I cant speak for the rest of the items, but it was busy and the phones were also busy. Fair prices and staff was nice.

… more

Keri Boyle

I ordered a pizza and the cheese was stuck to the top and im told its normal. Wouldn’t replace it and was only offered 10% off my next order. Bye thats not ok. Very unhappy

… more

Sarah Gummo

I did not follow my own advice today. I forgot to check my food before I left the shop. I went to the shop to order my food. The lady that took my order verified what I wanted on my hoagie. It was also written in the slip that is stapled on the bag. When I went home and open thr bag I immediately noticed that my order was once again messed up. I asked for a simple turkey hoagie with cheece mayo and pickles without lettuce tomato and onions, and what was on this hoagie? All of the stuff I asked not to be put on it.

Be 100% clear about what you want on your order and double-check it before you leave the shop. We have had our cheesesteak orders incorrect a few times. I asked for a cheesesteak sub with just cheese and a cheesesteak sub with grilled onions. I got the one with onions, but the other was a hoagie with lettuce tomato and onions. I’m not sure how that got mixed up. Even though my order got messed up, I will still get the cheesesteaks because I think they are the best around.

… more

… View more

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results