Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
New York Style pizza crust with a variety of sauces and specialty pizzas. Specializing in Old World Style pizzas using sliced fresh mozzarella cheese. This pizza will remind you of a traditional pizza made in Italy. We use made in Wisconsin cheese for the traditional NY Style pizzas. All pizzas are cooked in a stone revolving deck, very high heat brick oven! Enjoy the bendable crust that has made New York famous in small town Wisconsin.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
jamesstpizza.cloudwaitress.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
James Street Pizza
Welcome to James Street Pizza · 10″ Street Sticks. 10″ pizza dough topped with shredded mozzarella cheese and fresh garlic. Served with 2 ranch and/or marinara.
James Street Pizza Co. | Columbus WI – Facebook
Just a reminder we will be closed for lunch today but will be open from 4 to 9. Open for pick up or delivery for all your late night pizza cravings!! Thank …
James Street Pizza Company | Travel Wisconsin
About James Street Pizza Company. “New York Style pizza crust with a variety of sauces and specialty pizzas. Specializing in Old World Style pizzas using sliced …
Reviews
Terri B
We ordered sausage, mushroom, onion pizza. The crust was way too soft, couldn’t support the ingredients, and as a whole, it was soggy, watery, and the sauce was tasteless. The boneless wings were small & a bit costly, but OK. We love good pizza, and try to be supportive of local businesses. Unfortunately, we can’t in this case. It was disappointing.
… moreNick Woltring
Very small place but great food, better for pickup orders but enough room to dine in if you want. It’s no frills but good pizza and salad. Will definitely order again.
… moreMatthew
Amazing little pizza shop. Me and my boyfriend were the only ones there at the time, so we got all the attention, but the taco pizza was the best, brought me back to when pizza hut had one on the menu at least a decade back. If you need a quick slice or a whole pie, this place has got it all covered!
… moreSarah Rivera (Face)
This is my favorite pizza shop in town since it’s the closest I can get to an authentic NYC style pizza. No complaints whatsoever with the quality of food. Delivery is always on time, they follow delivery instructions to a science, and customer service is A. If an error was made they do their due diligence in rectifying the situation. I will only eat here for Pizza. Anyone complaining about the quality of food has an unseasoned palette and I don’t trust it. ♀️
… moreF Wille
Our “Old World” pizza was extremely soggy. Not like it wasn’t cooked, more like it was soaked in water after it was baked. Absolutely disgusting and not eatable. Straight to the trash it went! Plus the cashier tried to charge us a 2nd time after we had already paid online for our nearly $100 order.
Very disappointing seeing we drove 30 mins just to get James St pizza. Never again!
… moreVery disappointing seeing we drove 30 mins just to get James St pizza. Never again!
Jack Gadzala
Our margarita pizza was phenomenal! The freshness of the ingredients shown through to produce a wonderful relaxing dining experience. This restaurant reminds me of a small cozy European bistro. Exceptionally friendly staff and quick service. I was surprised to find such a gem in the small town.
… moreJennifer Kelly-karnum
Recently ordered 2 pizzas for takeout (which included a 15% tip) after JSP was highly recommended. Biggest complaint is that when my husband picked up the order he was refused a glass of water or, “just a little water in my water bottle.” He was told that he could purchase a plastic bottle, which he declined. This was a quick stop on a day with a very hectic schedule. He came home upset that, “they wouldn’t even give me a glass of water.”
The pizza was good, but not great… granted, we had it after a 30 minute drive home. The crust and sauce were good and the pizzas were cooked perfectly..the toppings great – jalapenos fresh and had some heat…green olives very tasty..thinly sliced garlic still had a bite and wasn’t overcooked…but…the extra sauce I ordered on the Old World wasn’t nearly enough..seemed like it was less than a standard should be. The NY was also lacking sauce. Reheated some later with garden tomatoes topping and was better. I saw a review of an Old World that was a soggy mess from excess sauce. Seems like it could be really good if it was standardized to have the right amount. There were also a lot of charred particles that we had to brush off the bottom of the crust. Seems like the oven could use more cleaning or scraping between orders. I’m fine with a little bit of char here and there but this was excessive..we ordered shortly before closing so I think we picked up extra char on the bottom from all of the previous pizzas.
… moreThe pizza was good, but not great… granted, we had it after a 30 minute drive home. The crust and sauce were good and the pizzas were cooked perfectly..the toppings great – jalapenos fresh and had some heat…green olives very tasty..thinly sliced garlic still had a bite and wasn’t overcooked…but…the extra sauce I ordered on the Old World wasn’t nearly enough..seemed like it was less than a standard should be. The NY was also lacking sauce. Reheated some later with garden tomatoes topping and was better. I saw a review of an Old World that was a soggy mess from excess sauce. Seems like it could be really good if it was standardized to have the right amount. There were also a lot of charred particles that we had to brush off the bottom of the crust. Seems like the oven could use more cleaning or scraping between orders. I’m fine with a little bit of char here and there but this was excessive..we ordered shortly before closing so I think we picked up extra char on the bottom from all of the previous pizzas.
Ashley Morton
We have always loved their buffalo chicken pizza, but just ordered it and there were maybe 2 chicken nuggets cut up on the entire 16” pizza. I’m not sure you can call it a buffalo chicken pizza when there isn’t any chicken on it. Very disappointing.
… moreMichelle Morris
Absolutely fantastic pizza! We had the one with sirloin and onion rings on it with this fabulous creamy BBQ-y sauce on a great crispy but soft hand tossed crust. Great service, very friendly and fast. The cheese bread is so delicious with the fantastic marinara sauce! I’d buy that sucks buy the bucket if so could!! So good! We will make the drive from the fox valley just for this food!
… moreSteven Zimmerman
The worst pizza I’ve ever had. They delivered it burnt. I don’t review stuff often but this needed something said.
… more