Suzy Pellegrino
Food was good. Had a chicken parmigiana hero and chicken parm pizza. Kids chicken fingers and fries. Fingers were delicious, crispy and tasty both pizza and hero nice. Plenty of chicken on the hero with a good amount of cheese too. Bread was not soggy. Pizza had a nice crust no flop and toppings were plenty. Nice atmosphere too. Service was great, very friendly people!
… moreBrittany McCall
I used to live in an Italian neighborhood in westchester then I mive up here. So far, this restaurant is the closest I get to taste like home. These other pizza shops in newburgh ain’t it.
… moreryan john
If you’re a true pizza lover, this place is an absolute must. From the first bite, it was clear — this isn’t just pizza, it’s a passion project turned perfection.
The crust struck the rare balance between crisp and chewy, with just the right amount of char from the wood-fired oven. You can tell they let the dough ferment properly — it had that beautiful tang and airiness that only comes with time and care.
We tried the classic Margherita and a specialty pie with prosciutto, arugula, and a drizzle of truffle oil. Both were out of this world. The tomato sauce was bright and fresh, the cheese melted into creamy perfection, and the toppings were high-quality and generously portioned without overwhelming the balance of the pie.
The atmosphere was cozy and unpretentious — just how a great pizzeria should be — and the staff were friendly, fast, and clearly proud of what they serve.
Whether you’re a pizza purist or a fan of inventive flavors, this spot delivers on every level. This is the kind of place you tell your friends about — then immediately come back with them.
Can’t wait to return. Five stars all the way!
… moreMeredith Baker
I’ve eaten here as well as taken the special Tesoro pizzas to Long Island with me for friends. I’ve also enjoyed the broccoli rabe & sausage pasta. I moved from New Windsor 2 years ago, but keep coming back.
… morerita c
Food was yummy yummy. Good portion, homemade soup delicious.
… moreDeb DG
Have been here twice for take out so far. The first time we ordered chicken parm dinner and meatballs. The food and portion was excellent. Recently we ordered a Margherita pizza and we weren’t as blown away. Unfortunately, disappointed in the pie. There was way too much sweet sauce on it , and the basil was lacking. I’m not sure if this is their way of making a Margherita or maybe a new chef?
I’ll try again soon, but may stick to a regular pie.
Service has always been pleasant!
… moreFreddy N
I’m not sure what’s going here, used to love the food but there a lady here that’s very rude and does not put in the orders when you call
Terrible customer service lately
… moreJordan Tamsey
Nice friendly service, food was satisfactory. Bit of an odd menu Prices were affordable. Plenty of parking. Will return.
… moreFritzstmire
This place just can’t stop burning the pizza! The last six times we got it they burned black, the last three times I specifically asked them to cook it light so that they wouldn’t burn it, but sure enough it was burnt to a cinder when I went to pick it up.
I’ve gave them enough tries, I will never return.
… moreSteven Summo
I went to Ivana’s Cucina for the first time ever. I can’t believe I didn’t find this place sooner. I’ve been in New Windsor for 14 years and I have tried a lot of pizza. Ivana’s has the best pizza by far, in my opinion. Ordered a large pie and it was FANTASTIC! This will be my new “Go To” place. My wife and 2 daughters also loved it. I was born and raised in the Bronx and let me tell you…This is really good pizza. I will try other dishes from Ivana’s as well. So glad I finally tried Ivana’s!!! Delicious!
… more