Kelly Hagen
Sharing adorable patio pics bc i didn’t see them posted anywhere! Deliciously perfect wood-fired pizza (both sauce and crust are on point, toppings are generous), and genuine “when you’re here you’re family” vibes! Service is so kind, everyone seems happy
Owner Alessandro is a real gem, came here from Sicily for love and stayed. Love that they also serve proper aperitif! In addition to Amaro they have not only limoncello but a rhubarb-cello that I want to try next!
10/10 had a fantastic time enjoying the wonderful patio vibes and yummy pizza!
… moreHaley Wild
We had It’s Good For You Pizza cater my bridal shower and they were absolutely perfect, I have no bad things to say! They set up a woodfired pizza oven right in our driveway (how cool!) and were incredibly prepared, they set up fast, were very self sufficient, had pizzas rolling out right on time and there was never a lull in pizza availability! The pizza was so so delicious and authentic – seriously the best pizza in Madison no doubt, everything was right on time, great communication, the team was SO friendly and easy to work with and very professional! The pizza was displayed very nicely (pictures attached), on a table they brought, with serving utensils, on cute checkered food paper, napkins, AND they boxed up all of the extra pizza and hand wrote/labeled which pizzas were in what boxes – truly a one-of-a-kind, high end catering experience! HIGHLY RECCOMMEND and will definitely recommend to friends! Couldn’t have asked for a better experience—thank you all SO much! Will absolutely be using them again in the future 🙂
… moreKyoko Felland
Chill place, delicious sights, sounds, smells and of course, the taste. They have delicious regular pizzas flavors and specials that change every couple of weeks. Nice spot outside to sit and eat, ok to bring your dog! Yum!
… moreColleen M
I ordered two pizzas and a Caesar salad. Only one pizza came. It was cold, uncut, and missing a topping we added. The Caesar salad was small and unimpressing. I don’t think I will order from here again
EDIT: I wanted to add since the business replied to this review that the hand written receipt on my order only had one pizza written on it… the dasher’s picture also showed only one pizza. I’m not sure what happened but someone messed up here. Also the pizza I did receive was incorrect and missing a topping I added, like I originally stated. I have had this pizza in a catering setting before and it was amazing, just did not hit the mark this time.
… moreDon
Ate here for the first time tonight and it is amazing! Customer service was great, they were willing to take the time to explain their pizzas, and I didn’t feel rushed at all. I chose the sausage pizza which was suggested by the employee taking my order. It was by far one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. For sure best in Madison. We will be coming back soon.
… moreTyler Gregory
Got takeout from here for the first time and highly recommend. Their warmup instructions worked great after our 30 min drive home. Absolutely delicious pizza. Very cute little interior as well. Will definitely return soon.
… moreSTIG RAHM
They catered at our house, pulled up with the pizza oven and created a great night for our son and his new brides rehearsal dinner. Excellent food, excellent service
… moreBarrett Lione-Seaton
I was trained under an Italian to make this style of pizza several years ago. They do it true to style, and they make their own Limoncello! I haven’t ordered it for take, only have eaten fresh, but this style is meant to eat fresh. However, I look forward to trying the reheat method they prescribe.
… moreMatthew Szlasa
Absolutely lovely local pizza place with a fun vibe and very kind service. The pizza itself is incredible. Hands down the best Neapolitan style pizza in Madison and probably the best overall pizza in Madison (and I have a high pizza bar that has mostly been missed by pizza in the area). Their sauce is incredible, and the dough is the perfect balance of chewy, soft, and light. Cannot recommend this place enough.
… moreMichael Comiskey
We were in Madison for the weekend, and stopped in here for two great pizzas (and some Two Hearted Ale!). Very good crust and flavors on the toppings. Reminiscent of WyEast in Wauwatosa. Very friendly vibe. Wish we lived here!
… more