Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Italy Pizzeria
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Orlando, FL.
Menu – Italy Pizzeria
NY Style Pizza (Whole Pizzas). Our selection of Fresh Toppings: Anchovies, artichoke hearts, bacon, basil, broccoli, black olives, eggplant, extra cheese, …
ITALY Pizzeria – 2124 Edgewater Dr, Orlando, FL 32804 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Orlando, FL! ITALY Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy your …
Reviews
Michelle Kusmiskiy
this is me and my boyfriends favorite spot for pizza , thin crispy crust and quality cheese, definitely the best pizza in orlando IMO, we recently tried to the italy trio and the cheese paired with the vodka sauce is delicious and a great addition to their menu. the garlic knots also never miss. also affordable and in a very cute area in college park. the waitress is very friendly and accommodating always !!
… moreBen Adamo
Italy Pizzeria in College Park is an underrated treasure and one of the best pizzerias in Orlando. Whenever I have told people about this place they respond with, “What is it? No, I’ve never heard of them.” Despite this, I cannot recommend it highly enough. Their prices are fair, their portions are hearty, the wait-staff is friendly and prompt, and the food is top-notch quality. The pizza tastes authentically New York and has an excellent crust. In fact, I would argue that they have some of the best crust you will find anywhere around. This is a perfect lunch-time spot. A few blocks away you will find the College Park Pizza Bruno, and Italy Pizzeria trumps them in terms of price, quality, and service. If you haven’t already, do yourself a favor and check out Italy Pizzeria in College Park!
… moreKorab Kozgori
Authentic New York-Style Pizza in the Heart of College Park!
We had an amazing experience at ITALY Pizzeria College Park! From the moment we walked in, we were warmly welcomed by Tommy, the owner — a true pizza master with over 20 years of experience in New York. You can really taste that authentic NYC flavor in every bite — the crust is perfectly crisp, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and the toppings are super fresh.
We ordered a couple of pies and a pasta dish, and everything was made fresh to order and served hot. The quality is outstanding, but what really blew us away was the value — generous portions at very fair prices. It’s rare to find this level of flavor and authenticity without breaking the bank.
This place is the real deal. If you’re craving great pizza and want to support a local gem with heart, skill, and unbeatable value, ITALY Pizzeria is a must-try.
We’ll definitely be back — thanks, Tommy!
… moreWe had an amazing experience at ITALY Pizzeria College Park! From the moment we walked in, we were warmly welcomed by Tommy, the owner — a true pizza master with over 20 years of experience in New York. You can really taste that authentic NYC flavor in every bite — the crust is perfectly crisp, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and the toppings are super fresh.
We ordered a couple of pies and a pasta dish, and everything was made fresh to order and served hot. The quality is outstanding, but what really blew us away was the value — generous portions at very fair prices. It’s rare to find this level of flavor and authenticity without breaking the bank.
This place is the real deal. If you’re craving great pizza and want to support a local gem with heart, skill, and unbeatable value, ITALY Pizzeria is a must-try.
We’ll definitely be back — thanks, Tommy!
Ronald Orpilla
NYC style Italian food….just like the kind I had growing up. Been there a handful of times and consistently delicious. Had their chicken parm hero extra garlic, fried calamari, and a variety of pastas all excellent. And their RED SAUCE!!! I can drink it straight. Wonderful addition to College Park.
… moreXax N
This is my second time at this Italian spot, and it did not disappoint! I went yesterday with a group of friends, and we all loved it. The bruschetta was fresh and flavorful, the calamari perfectly crispy, and we couldn’t get enough of the best Nutella pizza ever. My boyfriend, who’s half Italian, was seriously impressed again, his vegetarian pasta was super good, packed with fresh ingredients and rich flavor. Definitely a place we’ll keep coming back to!
… moreBigHead Custom
Living in Winter Park, my girlfriend and I had to stop in and try this place out. It’s located in College Park so it was just a stones throw from our home.
Arrived slightly after 2 o’clock and got a seat no problem. The dining area was immaculate and our server greeted us almost immediately. She’s was super friendly and very attentive. We ordered a pepperoni pizza with an order of garlic knots. We didn’t have to wait very long at all. The garlic knots came out first and were flawless. I highly recommend them. Shortly thereafter our pizza came to the table. From the smell of it alone I knew we were in the right place. From the first bite I knew we would be returning. It was cooked to perfection. The dough was perfect, nice and thin. The cheese was the good stuff and the sauce was PERFECT. From my first bite until my last I have to say this pizza was flawless! An EXCELLENT experience all the way around! We wil be returning for sure and highly recommend! Thanks guys!!
… moreArrived slightly after 2 o’clock and got a seat no problem. The dining area was immaculate and our server greeted us almost immediately. She’s was super friendly and very attentive. We ordered a pepperoni pizza with an order of garlic knots. We didn’t have to wait very long at all. The garlic knots came out first and were flawless. I highly recommend them. Shortly thereafter our pizza came to the table. From the smell of it alone I knew we were in the right place. From the first bite I knew we would be returning. It was cooked to perfection. The dough was perfect, nice and thin. The cheese was the good stuff and the sauce was PERFECT. From my first bite until my last I have to say this pizza was flawless! An EXCELLENT experience all the way around! We wil be returning for sure and highly recommend! Thanks guys!!
Rick Colon
Stopped here out of curiosity and I was so glad I did! Everything from pricing, to portions, servers, presentation, cold beer, and especially the wonderful flavors, made my visit extremely worth my curiosity! I will be back for some pizza! My stromboli was amazing and I absolutely love the garlic knots!! Clean, easy decor. Bathrooms were clean! The girls were super attentive and knowledgeable! Great find!
… moreIsrael Leon
Food was amazing! I took my wife here on a spontaneous date night on a budget. The atmosphere was friendly and staff were very kind and helpful! We ordered the fries, onion rings and calamari as appetizers and we ate them all before we could take pictures. The wings were delicious, and the chicken Marsala is ALWAYS incredible! I’m from NJ and this place feels like somewhere you’d get a great slice of pizza on the corner. If I could give this restaurant another star I would.
… moreDon Clements
Ordered takeout from Italy pizza college Park and was very impressed. Not much parking but the calzone was the best I have had in quite a while. Staff very friendly ordering by phone and in person. We will definitely be back.
… moreDesi Myrteza
One of the best spots I’ve ever tried before. It’s way too worth it to give a shot. It reminds me a lot of Italy and Europe. I ordered a Shrimp Scampi and a Piccata, and the best dishes in Orlando. Pizza is really good too, especially Godfather one. One of my favorite pizzas. Good job guys!
… more