Madhuri Mehta
Tried this gem in a hole place for the first time. Friendly staff and clean place. The menu is simple but it contains something for everyone. I tried the veggie pizza and cheese slice. Both were amazingly delicious. I hope I get the same quality and taste every time I order going forward. It’s definitely going to be my to go place for pizzas
… moreRhonda Martin
A local pizza spot that sells by the slice, Yay! Let me begin by saying, I’m a New Yorker so I’m a tough critic about pizza. This restaurant was clean, the staff was friendly and attentive and the prices are moderate. I ordered a slice with pineapple, ham, onion and green peppers. See my picture. My slice was pretty! No burnt crust or veggies. Yes! The toppings were tasty; my pineapple was sweet and juicy. And the crust had just enough crunch. I only wish the crust was more flavorful, maybe a hint more salt so I didn’t devour it like a prefer to do. Regardless, I’ll certainly return to try more on the menu.
… moreJennifer Stewart
Stumbled across this great spot while having my car serviced close by. Located in a plaza with plenty of parking. The five dollar lunch special caught my eye and that is what I ended up trying. Waited less than ten minutes to get two generous slices of pizza with the one topping I was able to add. Pizza is New York style with a nice crisp, thin crust. You can choose a drink from the wide selection available in the front display. There are many more items I plan to try from the menu I posted. Have to give a shout out to Arie, pictured behind the counter, who helped me! She was so friendly and chill; wished me a good afternoon and told me to be safe. You can’t beat small business quality and service- such a rare thing these days.
… moreEmily Howard
Amazing pizza and great service! The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh, and everything was full of flavor. The staff was friendly and the place felt very welcoming. Definitely one of the best pizza spots I’ve tried — I will be coming back!
… moreLive, Laugh Love LIFE
Heard all these amazing things about Italian Pie and how close to New York Pizza it is. We stopped in for lunch, and the girl at the counter didn’t even acknowledge us. We picked up the menu and asked her if they sold salads? She didn’t even answer us and just walked into the back and stay for a very long time. We can hear her back there laughing and talking to people. We decided to walk out. Then we stood in the parking lot trying to decide where else we were going to go for lunch and I saw her walk through and motion for me to come back in. We told her no thanks and walked out. I don’t care how good pizza or how good the food is. First impression is everything and it wasn’t worth it
… moreJames MacKenzie
We spent most of our lives in the NY, NJ, Philadelphia area and believe the pizza there is the best. We’ve been in Georgia for about five years now and today we found, by far, the best pizza that we’ve had in GA so far! This will undoubtedly be our go-to pizza place from now on!
… moreJanssell Figueroa
We’ve been coming to Italian Pie for a while now, and it never disappoints. The pizzas here are consistently delicious, with fresh ingredients and perfectly cooked crusts every time. The service is always friendly and efficient, making the dining experience even better.
While the prices are a bit on the higher side, you absolutely get what you pay for—quality food and great flavors. It’s worth every penny. Italian Pie has become one of our go-to spots, and we’ll definitely keep coming back!
… moreThomas Frederick
I got take-out at this restaurant. Their pizza is good, but for me their calzones are the best. Friendly staff and they are very accommodating for extra sauces and just any items you need to make your dining/take-out a great experience. Went to this restaurant 5 times(twice for pizza and three for their calzones)while visiting family in Snellville, Ga.
… moreIda Gray
Ordered the wing and fish combo. I should have checked the food before I left but when I got home the fish looked like it had been cooked in old grease and also the fries. The fries were stuck together and not crispness at all!! Called the store to let them know and the supervisor said that I can bring the food back and they will replace which is cool but do they think people live around the corner? I told her I took pictures of the food before I trashed it because it wasn’t worth eating. The breading on the fish just looked disgusting. The bad thing about it is I actually waited almost 30 min for some nasty old food. If I stayed close I would have went back and sat that food at the front door
… moreMalik Gonzalez
I drive all the way from conyers to get my pizza from them. Do not get them mixed up with the one that’s on Centerville Highway! This is the closest I can get to New York Pizza and I swear it’s always fresh and I’ve never had a problem with them!
… more