Pies with housemade dough are served along sandwiches, salads & dinners at this basic cafe.
Kristy Johnson
The people are very kind, the service was fast, and there are many options. I can’t speak to the subs or salads and the like, but the pizza crust/dough is awful. It’s dry and tastes terrible.
I’m from New York, so I’m usually pretty Inwardly picky about pizza but accommodating because I know that I’m picky. I like the kind of pizza that you get at a Whole Foods. I can enjoy and appreciate a Chicago style pizza or even a frozen Newman‘s own.
This was so incredibly dry as to be inedible. I took the toppings off the top and I threw out the pizza crust.
The toppings were amazing. There were lots of creative options, and I made something delicious with the toppings, but they really need to change out the dough. It’s really gross.
Also a $16 small pizza was the width of my smaller hand. It was a tiny little box. Definitely not a good value.
… moreLeah Ledgewood
Islington Pizza really came through for us when we needed a last-minute catering order. They were incredibly accommodating, friendly, and fast! Even during what was clearly a busy time, everyone was smiling and so kind. A special shout-out to Michael, who took my frantic call and stayed calm, reassuring, and so helpful. Thank you for saving the day and making everything so easy — we’ll definitely be ordering from you again!
… moreVanessa P
There was a hair in the cheese pizza and they put olives with pits in the salad. I almost broke a tooth. They sell olives without pits, why not use that?
… moreD D
Fish was overdone. Could not even cut it with at knife, broccoli chicken Alfredo had no sauce on it chicken parm had no cheese
… moreIgor Drizik
Slow service, no air conditioning, and dirty. “Great” neighborhood pizza place. I will avoid going forward.
… moreS B
Nailed it. 5 stars well deserved. This is now our number one out of two places we really like near us for pizza. They make pizza an art and I will keep coming back for more. Great job on the xtra, xtra banana peppers. Absolutely love it.
… moreChris Sands
We recently starting a takeout from this place. The clerks on the phone are great, they take their time, and re-read to confirm the order back, so I never have doubts that I’m going to get what I wanted.
Prices are fair and delivery time is almost always under what they promise. Food is fantastic. I’ve tried a few things, thought they did a great job with every selection I chose. More importantly, girlfriend is extremely particular about her food and always asks for modifications. This place handles that Very well both in the production stages.
I did not offer an opinion on their atmosphere because I have never been to their facility. Always or takeout
My only regret is that I didn’t find them years ago. Gool ppl, great food, great service. A++++
… morePaul Kelly
My wife placed a $58. order. Had $4 coupon which we told cashier when called in order. Ran out of house without coupon, 3 visiting young grandchildren. My fault, given much business through the years thought they would honor coupon. After under cooked pizza, I went back up and gave them their $4. coupon and said DONE. Been supporting them from the day they opened with Evan.
… moreFatemeh T.
Excellent quality and variety of choices is what you get from Islington Pizza at a very reasonable price. Since we discovered this place a few months ago, we go there at least once a week. We love their gyros, Italian cold sub and burgers the best.
Very nice indoor and outdoor seating areas are a plus. Not to mention, friendly and accommodating staff.
… moreTinker Toy II
Fast paced restaurant. The woman taking orders was clearly skilled at her job. It took less than 10 seconds to place my order. There was a short wait to get my food, but this was most likely the busiest part of the day for them (12:15). The food was excellent and exceptionally fresh. I will be going back the next time I’m in the area.
… more