Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Unpretentious outpost serving pepperoni pies & calzones, plus sandwiches, burgers & wings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 30348 Overseas Hwy, Big Pine Key, FL 33043
Phone: (305) 872-7444
Website: http://clover.com/online-ordering/islandpizzacompany
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Island Pizza Company | Big Pine Key FL – Facebook
Come on in and get a fresh pizza today from 4pm- 9pm! To place an order call us at 305-872-7444 or get 5% by placing an online order at clover. com/online- …
ISLAND PIZZA COMPANY – BIG PINE KEY, FL | Online Ordering
ISLAND PIZZA COMPANY. 30348 OVERSEAS HWY, BIG PINE KEY FL. (305) 872-7444. Open 4:30 PM – 7:30 PM EST. Specials. 14″ Pizza and Sticks! $20.00.
Island Pizza Company | Big Pine Key FL – Facebook
Island Pizza Company, Big Pine Key. 551 likes · 1 talking about this. Island Pizza Company – NOW CLOSED.
Reviews
Nonrevkcin
5/5 Stars
This pizza is absolutely OUTSTANDING! I’ve tried every pizza around and this is the best. It ranks as some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. I never give 5 Stars but this got it. We got 3 pepperoni pizzas and they all were delicious! The staff was very friendly and quick with making the food. If you are looking for the best pizza around this is it! I enjoyed this pizza so much I forgot to take pictures of my pizza so I used pictures the staff had taken. They cut the pizzas
… moreThis pizza is absolutely OUTSTANDING! I’ve tried every pizza around and this is the best. It ranks as some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. I never give 5 Stars but this got it. We got 3 pepperoni pizzas and they all were delicious! The staff was very friendly and quick with making the food. If you are looking for the best pizza around this is it! I enjoyed this pizza so much I forgot to take pictures of my pizza so I used pictures the staff had taken. They cut the pizzas
Emma Kim
I went to the Miami stop by this restaurant for lunch.
First, I didn’t expect it. But It was great.
I had 4cheese pizza. Really delicious.
My son said he wanted to come one more time. We had a good memory and a nice lunch.
… moreFirst, I didn’t expect it. But It was great.
I had 4cheese pizza. Really delicious.
My son said he wanted to come one more time. We had a good memory and a nice lunch.
Levi Wark
Good pizza, though the dough is a bit sweet for my taste. Very friendly customer service. I went for the popeye, and it was yummy.
… moreO T
Guys I was so happy to hear that you got this place from mean Jim. But despite his awful reputation his pizza was incredible and recipe was great. From the beginning you have been doing great following his recipes but recently something has changed and your pizza, unfortunately, is not the same anymore. And delicious white pizza as well. You guys are very sweet and nice, I wish you luck and happiness, but please bring back the original recipe, it was great before!
… moreJim Mconnell
This guy makes each menu item a specialty!
You can taste it in his pizza(great crust), his fresh wings. Those subs are perfectly accompanied by shredded lettuce onions tomatoes sliced thin…no shortage of meat and all very fresh.
If I lived nearby I’d eat here every other night!!
Great quality, and fair prices, can’t ask for better than that. Thank you Pops Jim’s!!
We’ll be back.
… moreYou can taste it in his pizza(great crust), his fresh wings. Those subs are perfectly accompanied by shredded lettuce onions tomatoes sliced thin…no shortage of meat and all very fresh.
If I lived nearby I’d eat here every other night!!
Great quality, and fair prices, can’t ask for better than that. Thank you Pops Jim’s!!
We’ll be back.
Joe Mauceri
What terrible people that work here. I’m visiting from our of town and ordered $100 worth of pizza. They make you wait outside in your car and bring your order to you. That’s all fine in these crazy times but the owner was sooo rude and did not give me my pizza because I didn’t have a mask in my own car. He walked away and told me he’s been telling me this for 16 months? It’s my first time here! Absolutely the worst experience I’ve ever had. Couldn’t tell you how the food was because we never got it. The owners needs to check the news to keep up with the times. We would up at Pizzaworks around the corner which was a far better experience. Do not go here if you expect any kind of service at all.
… moreJacalyn McLaughlin
This Oct 27, Thursday I place order on line because no one answered the phone but that’s nothing new for this business. So put order on line. The order was excepted and confirmed and said that pick up would be @ 6:50. We’ll door was locked and sign on door. Giving employees day off.. Credit card was charged. REALLY About 3 months ago ordered and went to pick up and door locked said they were out of dough. This business is so unreliable very poor. Rating -0.
Oct 27 was Thursday not the weekend so what’s that got to do with the weekend?
Yes you were closed on 10/27/22 and but my credit card was still charged for 17.44 receipt # S462300798027221
I have not seen a refund as of yet.
… moreOct 27 was Thursday not the weekend so what’s that got to do with the weekend?
Yes you were closed on 10/27/22 and but my credit card was still charged for 17.44 receipt # S462300798027221
I have not seen a refund as of yet.
scjmc
This place took a while to come into its own, but I can say that it is great now. The pizza is delicious and fresh. The weird covid crazy owners are long gone. These people are welcoming and friendly. I wish that they delivered.
… moreTom G
It was dinner time and I was a first time walk-in. I ordered a large “Thin Crust Meat Lovers.” The staff was quite friendly, said it would be ready in (20) minutes. Went over to Walgreens and got a movie at Redbox, then stopped off at Winn-Dixie for some cookies. I was back there in (20) minutes, just as they were pulling it out of the oven. Most notable is the quality of the crust – you can really taste the difference. The meat portions were more than generous … overall a good tasting pizza. Will definitely be back for more. On a side note the price was considerably less than where I’d been going, so that’ was an added perk.
… moreJosh Nerison
We tried to order a pizza from this place at 8:00 on a Thursday night but nobody would answer the phone so we drove up there at 8:30 and the guy was SUPER rude and said “I already put everything away” when we tried to order a pizza inside the dirty little kitchen… There were flies everywhere landing on the pizza so I’m sure we were better off going to “Slice of Paradise” 7 minutes down the road anyway the pizza here was awesome! Don’t waste your time at popa flies!!!!
… more