Upscale venue in the Eataly food hall with a focus on Italian seafood dishes, plus wine & beer.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
Phone: (212) 229-2560
Website: https://www.eataly.com/us_en/stores/nyc-flatiron/restaurants/il-pesce
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Seafood Restaurant in NYC Flatiron District – Il Pesce – Eataly
Located inside Eataly NYC Flatiron, Il Pesce features fresh, responsibly-sourced seafood dishes with an Italian twist, plus an extensive Italian wine menu.
Eataly NYC Flatiron – Il Pesce Restaurant – New York, NY | OpenTable
Book now at Eataly NYC Flatiron – Il Pesce in New York, NY. Explore menu, see photos and read 213 reviews: “all beautiful excellent food and wine I am a …
Il Pesce | Flatiron restaurants | NYCtourism.com
For fish lovers, chef Dave Pasternack presents creative and traditional takes on Italian seafood at Eataly’s fish counter, Il Pesce … NEW YORK CITY. Things to …
Reviews
J
My son and I had such a great experience here! Armando was warm, attentive, and professional. The food was delicious—everything came out fresh and full of flavor. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming, perfect for enjoying a relaxed meal with family.
One of the highlights was the made-to-order ice cream dessert. It was so good—and big enough for about five people! I highly recommend this restaurant, we left happy and full!
… moreOne of the highlights was the made-to-order ice cream dessert. It was so good—and big enough for about five people! I highly recommend this restaurant, we left happy and full!
Igor Matheus Moreira
Good experience overall. I stayed at the bar and went for the Cesare salad with a shrimp portion on the side and then went with the spinach Tagliatelle with mushrooms and asked for the additional black truffle. Portion sizes were adequate in my opinion, but I tend not to be that hungry on average so I might deviate from the average in that respect. Thanks for the service!
… moreTonnette Alcide
My family and I had an absolutely wonderful experience at Il Pesce! We visited with my husband and daughter, and from the moment we walked in, everything was just perfect.
First of all, the food was exceptional. The seafood was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared — it’s such a treat to find a place that truly celebrates responsibly sourced fish rather than farm-raised options, which I deeply appreciate.  Everything felt grilled, healthy, and vibrant, making our dinner both delicious and wholesome.
The service was a standout. Our waiter was friendly, attentive, and genuinely engaged — handling our meal with professionalism and care. The atmosphere was welcoming and kid-friendly, which made dining with our daughter stress-free and enjoyable. 
A special shout-out to Elizabeth, the manager — she went above and beyond to make sure we felt taken care of. Her warmth, hospitality, and genuine attention to detail made our visit even more memorable. It’s rare to find hospitality that feels so personal and sincere.
Il Pesce delivered on every level — fresh food, great service, and a welcoming vibe. We will absolutely be coming back, and I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for fantastic seafood and exceptional service in NYC.
… moreFirst of all, the food was exceptional. The seafood was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared — it’s such a treat to find a place that truly celebrates responsibly sourced fish rather than farm-raised options, which I deeply appreciate.  Everything felt grilled, healthy, and vibrant, making our dinner both delicious and wholesome.
The service was a standout. Our waiter was friendly, attentive, and genuinely engaged — handling our meal with professionalism and care. The atmosphere was welcoming and kid-friendly, which made dining with our daughter stress-free and enjoyable. 
A special shout-out to Elizabeth, the manager — she went above and beyond to make sure we felt taken care of. Her warmth, hospitality, and genuine attention to detail made our visit even more memorable. It’s rare to find hospitality that feels so personal and sincere.
Il Pesce delivered on every level — fresh food, great service, and a welcoming vibe. We will absolutely be coming back, and I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for fantastic seafood and exceptional service in NYC.
Alan Tan
During a meeting near the Flatiron District, I decided to revisit Eataly and stopped by II Pesce for lunch. Located on the ground floor, the restaurant is bustling with food traffic, so it’s not the best spot if you’re looking for an intimate or quiet dining experience. That said, the food was decent—nothing extraordinary, but solid and enjoyable. The service was friendly and efficient, matching the casual vibe of the place. Overall, it’s a good option for a quick meal if you’re in the area, but don’t expect a standout culinary experience.
… moreSan San Tso
Food was great, I spent 1/2 of the year in Italy so I know Italian pretty well by now and the food is good!! Staff are very nice too. Deserved to have higher overall rating!!
… moreMina Z
Located inside eataly, next to shops around you, interesting environment. Authentic Italian foods.Lunch special has reasonable prices.
… moreAnn G
Pasta was okay but the calamari was very bad, fishy and bitter. Service was not great at all, felt brusque. For the price it is not at all worth eating here.
… moreEric Arminjon
The meal was excellent and the service fine, but the Maitre D had a little bit of an attitude when I told him it was really loud and maybe also the restaurant felt like a food court at a Mall… When you spend 325$ for 2, I believe a little more intimacy would be needed. I Would never go back, and mostly I would never recommend this restaurant to any of my friends. They can do much better just next door.
And a side note to the Maitre D, when a client that has spent 325$ for two, gives you very politely constructive criticism, just say yes, I will pass this information to the management, even if you don’t do it. Don’t answer back “well that’s not what we were going for”. It’s rude.
… moreAnd a side note to the Maitre D, when a client that has spent 325$ for two, gives you very politely constructive criticism, just say yes, I will pass this information to the management, even if you don’t do it. Don’t answer back “well that’s not what we were going for”. It’s rude.
Ecem İz
On the evening of September 25, we visited your restaurant Il Pesce with the intention of dining. We had our baby with us and needed a high chair, yet the lady in charge offered us no assistance. Despite the restaurant being almost empty, she directed us to a cramped table. What’s more, while she treated other guests who arrived later with a smile, she displayed a dismissive and negative attitude towards us.
This behavior gave us the impression that we were not welcome, particularly because we had a child with us. On the other hand, one of your male staff members was very kind and tried to support us. Nevertheless, this unpleasant experience greatly damaged our overall impression of your restaurant. It is quite surprising that an employee responsible for greeting guests, showing tables, and handing out menus would perform her duties so unwillingly.
I have traveled in the United States and many other touristic regions before, yet I have never encountered such disrespectful treatment. I am seriously filing a complaint against this employee, as I believe such behavior harms the quality and reputation of your restaurant.
… moreThis behavior gave us the impression that we were not welcome, particularly because we had a child with us. On the other hand, one of your male staff members was very kind and tried to support us. Nevertheless, this unpleasant experience greatly damaged our overall impression of your restaurant. It is quite surprising that an employee responsible for greeting guests, showing tables, and handing out menus would perform her duties so unwillingly.
I have traveled in the United States and many other touristic regions before, yet I have never encountered such disrespectful treatment. I am seriously filing a complaint against this employee, as I believe such behavior harms the quality and reputation of your restaurant.
Mariana Ferraro
Javier Abboud gave us an amazing experience, the tasting of the wine the service wow increíble ! I don’t live in NYC and this is our second time here and Javer lucky has attended us increíble
… more