Johnny Throckmorton
Josh is very friendly and puts a lot of love in his pizza. He was only open on Tuesday night when we visited, so make sure he is open and that you visit and grab a pie. Crust A+, quality ingredients and sauce. Best pizza I have had in the Paonia area. Tip go to the brewery next door and enjoy a beer while you wait. I will be back next visit to the area. Thanks again for being awesome!
… moreSarah McIntire
The pizza is incredible. The fermented dough, homemade sauce… so authentic and delicious.
… moreRose Black
Excellent pizza. Thin crust with loads of veggies that consisted of green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and jalapenos, pepperoni & sausage
… moreFilip Sipos
Josh’s pizza isn’t just a meal, it’s an experience. The magic lies in three key ingredients:
The Dough: Forget flimsy crusts! Josh’s dough is the perfect balance of thin and crispy ,yet providing a sturdy base for all the delicious toppings.
The toppings: well-seasoned red sauce, quality fresh ingredients, and always cooked al dente.
A Generous Heart: More than just a pizza maker, Josh is a pillar of the community. Knowing your pie supports a good cause adds a feel-good factor to every slice.
Josh’s pizza is a guilt-free indulgence that warms your stomach and your heart every time.
… moreLouis Ross
Honestly a great spot. And not a bad price for the quality of pizza!
… moreZeke’s Autowerks
Josh, thank you for the pizzas and more importantly the conversation. Paonia really made an impression on us and we hope to be back around sooner than later. -Zeke and the fam.
… moreMario Fernandes
Awesome pizza, fresh ingredients, super tasty and crunchy! Highly recommend it!
… moreOlivia King
Best pizza I’ve ever had, it’s light and chewy with such depth of flavor.
… moreFra
Few weeks ago I ve been in Paonia , as Italian a craving for pizza started, I can say that is a good one
… morePastor Martinez
Amazing supreme pizza cooked by some amazing people. Josh and Andy are very welcoming!
… more