Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 253 Jackson St, New Milford, PA 18834
Phone: (570) 465-7437
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
HOT PIES Pizzeria | New Milford PA – Facebook
We will be CLOSED SUN SEPT 1st for a short break! We love you all!! We will open on Wed – Sun next week 11am! Enjoy your holiday!
Hot Pies Pizzeria – Reviews, Photos & Phone Number – Updated …
Hot Pies Pizzeria is a newly established pizza place located in New Milford, PA, known for its friendly service and reasonably priced menu. Customers appreciate …
Hot Pies Pizzaria, 253 Pa-492, New Milford, PA 18834, US – MapQuest
Hot Pies Pizzaria is a cozy eatery in New Milford, PA that specializes in serving freshly made pizzas and other Italian dishes.
Reviews
John Clum
When they first opened I was not impressed but just recently tried d them again and was very pleased. I get the half sheet with pepperoni, mushrooms and onions. It was excellent. The mushrooms are fresh and that makes all the difference.
… moreKevin Guilfoyle
when they opened i got a plain slice and they said thats plain just cheez on bread. lol . Just tried them again not as bad as that . But they had i sweet girl the i found out was so smart that she was finishing high school a year early !!! So im out and so are so many of the people that said i should go back with this kid there ! KEEP your keep your crappy pizza !
… moreDavid Barber
Decent crust and sauce. Variety of offerings in their ready-made pizza slice case. Worth the stop for a quick bite. I had the bacon and ham. My son had the plain/cheese. Friendly staff. Thanks!
… moreMargaret Karmazin
Not impressed and won’t go back. Maybe I ordered the wrong thing, but it was a large pizza, thin crust, half white with onions and half plain with red sauce. Extra cheese. And two serving of chicken tenders with honey mustard sauce. The pizza was thin and kind of rubbery and hardly anything on it. The extra cheese, if it was there, was invisible. There was one barely visible piece of onion about every two inches. All of this cost $42 something. Never again. Frozen pizza is better. The place was clean.
… moreBrandon Terk
Usually their pizza is great. However not when you don’t have service to pay for the food you ordered and they are too lazy to ask their boss or co-workers for the wifi password instead they say “I don’t know” and you have to drive around for 20 minutes looking for service. They didn’t even try to keep my food warm or anything $30 for a COLD pizza.
If you’re gonna make people drive around and look for service instead of letting them use your wifi for 2 seconds then the least you could do is keep the damn food warm.
… moreIf you’re gonna make people drive around and look for service instead of letting them use your wifi for 2 seconds then the least you could do is keep the damn food warm.
Jennifer Davis
Called a placed an order. I was coming from 1/2 hour away and female on phone was so nice and gave me directions.
Got there and picked up our pizza and wings. We had never been there before. The pizza looked great and could t wait til we got home to have a piece…..had one in the car. It was the best pizza I’ve had lately. Got home and had a couple wings. PHENOMINAL. Definitely will go back and may be a weekly dinner . So glad we found it .
… moreGot there and picked up our pizza and wings. We had never been there before. The pizza looked great and could t wait til we got home to have a piece…..had one in the car. It was the best pizza I’ve had lately. Got home and had a couple wings. PHENOMINAL. Definitely will go back and may be a weekly dinner . So glad we found it .
Koya
I’m absolutely in love with their square pizza which is huge for me because I’m not a fan at all of square pizza and I actually want it like all the time. Their cheesy breadsticks are amazing, wings always cooked to perfection, steak and cheese is to die for. Only request, please sell mozzarella sticks otherwise, 110% reccomend trying! Their round is also delicious, super big slices and worth every penny.
… moreBill Joseph
1st time there wish we didn’t wait as long to try it. Round pizza was great, asked for crispy wings they were spot on, garlic fries were delicious, knots had nice crisp and fluffy inside and my daughter said the spaghetti and meatballs was really good. Definitely recommending to friends and family.
… moreRob Collins
A rather new pizza place between the I-81 exit and New Milford. Reasonably priced for the area. Excellent friendly service. I highly recommend their cheesesteak Stromboli.
… moreJosh Butchko
Just passing through new Milford and saw this place, friendly staff, pizza was great!
… more