Amy K
Wow, this ice cream is delicious! Friendly, great service and pleasant atmosphere with loads of outdoor seating and games for the kids (cornhole, sidewalk chalk, balls to toss). Did I mention the delicious ice cream?! This place has loads of different gourmet flavors plus the classics. Best ice cream in the county!
… moreVeronica Reed
Excellent location and outstanding customer with corn hole games and plenty place to sit in their patio tables to enjoy the view of Orleans, IN … and their ice cream flavors simply delicious!
… moreAnnie petty
Through multiple email exchanges I made arrangements for 100 cups of ice cream to be delivered to a pool party on July 13 from Hometown Scoops.. As early as May 1st, Hometown wrote “Thanks for getting back to me! I’m happy to help clarify everything:
In an email I was told “We will provide the cups on the day of the party. If the date changes due to weather, we’d simply reschedule delivery for the new confirmed date.
You can choose how many cups you’d like to order, and that’s the amount we will prepare and deliver. Just let us know the final count when you’re ready.”
A total of 10 emails were exchanged including a request a few days before the event asking whether or not spoons would be provided.
I left a message on July 12 to verify the delivery and contact information. My tel # was included on multiple email exchanges.
Hometown did not deliver our ice cream With absolutely no communication they just could not be bothered to show up.
Under no circumstances would I ever recommend Hometown Scoops for any special event.
In spite of 10 email exchanges Hometown decided that the “details surrounding this particular request raised concerns that made it difficult for us to move forward confidently. Unfortunately, due to limited context and uncertainty, we made the decision not to proceed with the delivery. In hindsight, I recognize that I should have been more direct about our concerns and limitations instead of allowing the situation to remain unclear.”
10 emails were exchanged and at any time they could have contacted me.
A more bogus excuse would be hard to find – it does not matter how good the product is if the service is this lousy.
… moreNoah Mahan
After a slight miscommunication I was able to get what I had ordered and enjoy its awesome goodness. The staff all were very nice and promptly got it straightened out. It wasn’t a big deal at all to me but it made me feel good knowing the amount of care and professionalism I was shown. As always. Keep up the good work
… moreMichael Magill
Best ice cream around this area, no competition. The ice cream is so much more flavorful and enjoyable than the generic soft serve you get from fast food joints or even the hand-dipped you get from other local shops. Last summer, we visited the shop weekly, and we really liked that there were almost always new flavors to try. The outdoor atmosphere is enjoyable, with tons of yard games for kids and adults to enjoy.
We got shakes just tonight, and they were awesome. Perfect consistency, great balance between ice cream, milk, and mix-ins. If you haven’t tried this place, you need to! It’s less than a block away from Historic Congress Square!
… moreDwayne Murphy
Traveled from Montgomery IN to eat at Speakeasy pizza and stumbled upon this little ice cream shop. Talked to some people sitting on the picnic table and they told me the history of this place. What a great business and friendly to boot. We will definitely be back to get some ice cream and maybe swing by Speakeasy Pizza too
… moreHarry Matz
I purchased my first Hometown Scoops ice cream in Paoli at the Fall Festival on 9/11/2021. I purchased their Blueberry Cheesecake icecream and it was some of the best ice cream I had ever tasted. It was so creamy and smooth, I would compare it to Culver’s Custards. I will definitely be traveling to Orleans in the future to get my ice cream fixes!!
… moreElizabeth Blanton
It is small and does it’s job you want good homemade ice cream then this js your place…would have liked to seen more flavors then what most people have or something different but pricing was on point, staff was smiling and nice ,and it was clean and a nice atmosphere
… moreKelly Myers
Very good ice cream, loved the family atmosphere. My husband and daughter played 2 games of checkers and my son enjoyed playing with the hula hoops and corn hole boards.
… moreChristine Flaherty
Oh my goodness thus is real ice cream from the dairy land of Wisconsin. Super cool place to go for a relaxed atmosphere and good ice cream with unique varieties.
… more