Kelly Frank
We had originally planned to hike in the area, but it was a dreary day so we found sought some ice cream to cheer us up. So glad we stopped in . There is a such a great selection of homemade ice cream and cakes . The ice cream was delicious and full of flavorful. The staff were cheerful and helpful. We can’t wait to go again to one in our local area .
… moreMark Smiles
Our daughter turned us onto the Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen for some seriously amazing pies and cake during our latest visit to Louisville. I got the Chocolate Cake with Buttercream Frosting which was dense rich and delicious. My wife got the Dutch Apple with caramel topping and my daughter a Coconut Cream Pie which were also rave-worthy. We sat on the patio and thoroughly enjoyed the beautiful weather.
… moreDavid Barber
Tasty and sweet baked goods. We got a slice of chocolate cake with butter cream frosting, banana pudding, and Dutch Apple Pie. All items were worth the stop.
… moreBrandon Baylot
Ordered a brownie, chocolate chip cookie, strawberry cake slice, and cookie monster. Total for all four was $18, pretty reasonable at bakery standards.
Review Insights
-Strawberry cake was the favorite, the icing is sweet, however the cake is not very sweet at all to contrast. 8.4/10
-The brownie has a good texture and the icing reminds of the old school high-school cake icing (in the best way!!) 7.8/10
-the cookie monster icing was a bit much but not too bad like great american cookie double doosies. The cookie is soft and overall great for a sweet tooth or carb day!!! 7/10
-The chocolate chip cookie could do without the chocolate drizzle as the cookie itself is perfect with the brown butter and semi-sweet chocolate chip flavor/ratios. 7.5/10
(Ratings based on all other similar items ever tried.)
… moreZachary Casey
This location is like walking into a blast from the past. The interior is comfy and cozy looking. The staff is super friendly and the pies they make tasted spectacular. I can’t wait to come back with my kids. It is a great site down shop that can 100% satisfy your sweet tooth craving.
… moreNAC
It was delicious and ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ for the service. I’ll be back soon!
… moreJason Quinn
milkshakes were great… pies were so good my relatives ate both before I got to try a piece!
they told me it was great…
… moreJennifer Scheetz
What a find for a sweet tooth. Driving in Louisville Highland district, found this little shop, easy to miss from the busy road. Nice selections of pies and cakes. Even little Ohio buckeyes. Variety of ice cream. Delicious, sweet and an old time atmosphere with window stools and even an antique Wurlitzer!!!
… moreAlex Cross
One of my favorite places to stop for pie in Louisville! They make a delicious strawberry rhubarb pie and I would definitely recommend it. Also, they have a good selection of ice cream and it’s all very tasty. The staff is very friendly and the atmosphere is great. They also have a nice area outside you can sit. Overall, it’s a great place and I would definitely stop by for a visit and bite to eat!
… moreHeather H
Love love love this place!! Quaint little place with homemade pies, ice cream, cookies and cakes and even coffee. Very friendly staff as well! Their chocolate chip and praline ice creams are very yummy!! The chocolate chip cookies are pretty good too. I took home a piece of the mixed berry pie, wish I had taken home the whole pie!! Talk about delicious!! Will definitely visit again when in the area!
… more