Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 246 NJ-23, Sussex, NJ 07461
Phone: (973) 875-5258
Website: http://hollandamericanbakery.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Holland American Bakery
Since 1954, The Holland American Bakery has been serving rural northern New Jersey with authentic Dutch baked goods. By popular demand, our treats are now …
Holland American Bakery | Sussex NJ – Facebook
Holland American Bakery, Sussex. 11556 likes · 328 talking about this · 1541 were here. A family owned business for the past 60 years after the…
Holland American Bakery, 246 State Route 23, Sussex, NJ 07461, US
Holland American Bakery in Sussex, NJ offers a wide variety of Dutch baked goods, cheeses, candies, and specialty items imported from Holland.
Reviews
Jennifer Pasquariello
Absolutely amazing place — family owned, welcoming, and everything is just delicious.
Their cronuts are the best, and each one comes in different flavors like maple, chocolate, and cinnamon — so flaky, tasty, and perfectly baked. Every pastry is amazing, and the cakes are incredibly fresh and delicious.
This bakery is truly a gem in Sussex. If you love great pastries and desserts, this is a must-stop. Highly recommend — Holland Bakery never disappoints.
… moreTheir cronuts are the best, and each one comes in different flavors like maple, chocolate, and cinnamon — so flaky, tasty, and perfectly baked. Every pastry is amazing, and the cakes are incredibly fresh and delicious.
This bakery is truly a gem in Sussex. If you love great pastries and desserts, this is a must-stop. Highly recommend — Holland Bakery never disappoints.
Rebekah Mann
I have been coming here since I found this gem
In 2014 but realized I’ve never done a google review on them. We have never had anything we didn’t like from their breakfast sandwiches to their pastries. They have their fish fry food truck on Fridays, which my husband enjoys. Workers are always friendly and with a smile. Bonus they are a Christian bakery!
… moreIn 2014 but realized I’ve never done a google review on them. We have never had anything we didn’t like from their breakfast sandwiches to their pastries. They have their fish fry food truck on Fridays, which my husband enjoys. Workers are always friendly and with a smile. Bonus they are a Christian bakery!
Celeste
I had my son’s first birthday party 08/30/25 and we got his cake from this bakery. Our original cake maker got hurt and could not make his cake so I called on Tuesday and was able to get half a sheet cake and a smash cake. The design was amazing and exactly what I wanted. The cake was light, airy and the frosting was AMAZING. It tastes like it has sea salt which is different and tastes amazing. I will definitely use them again in the future as well as recommended them to friends!
… moreJohn Clarke
Want a place to gain weight from just looking? Go no further!!! My wife is out to destroy my diet, and she picked the perfect place to stop. Lots of delicious pastries pies cakes. The cronuts are addictive and you can’t eat just one. They have them in glazed, cinnamon sugar, and maple. You can’t beat the old-fashioned donuts either. My wife really wanted to try their crumb cake as she heard from a friend how great it is.. Luckily, there was one small piece left. I wish I could tell you how good it was, but it was devoured without sharing
… moreAllison Szczepanski
We had the most beautiful sheet cake for my baby shower! The cake itself was moist yet light and everyone loved the raspberry filling.
Was just so so happy how beautiful the cake turned out!
… moreWas just so so happy how beautiful the cake turned out!
John Reda
Real Dutch bakery making traditional Dutch food. They also have gifts from Holland. The staff is attentive, happy and extremely polite. Great food, try the cinnamon bread of you are not sure what to get. This place is a must stop of you are in the area.
… moreBrian Weintraub
I hate this place. Every time I go I know I’m going to gain weight. Everything is INSANELY GOOD and SUPER CHEAP. Especially considering it’s all freshly made. A massive selection of every treat you can imagine. All authentic Dutch. They also have a large variety of black licorice… including the sour and salty European stuff. Plus a lot of other little treats and decorations. DO NOT GO HERE IF YOU ARE ON A DIET! Be extra careful around the cronuts.
… moreCaron B
A friend brought one of their cakes (mocha butter cream) for a party I ghosted and I’m OBSESSED!! Best cake I’ve ever eaten, hands down!!! Buy one… or 4… you won’t regret it!! Wish I lived closer to this place!! Actually, scratch that. Thank GOD I don’t live closer to this bakery!! I’d eat their cakes every day!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreJohn Vee
Been going here for years, never disappointed with the baked goods or service; always greeted with a smile. During Lent they have a food truck serving fish, along with a Bible verse, every Friday until Easter. My wife and I look forward to it every year and it’s always delicious and priced very reasonable.
… moreAmanita Virosa
Lovely old time bakery. With Dutch gifts as well. Its been open since the 50s. Took a variety of the cookies home. They have interesting sweets rotry, things you’ve never seen before. Staff was pleasant.
… more