Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Holbrook Bagel Bakery – Facebook
92% recommend (9 Reviews). . $. . Closed now. . 1073 Main St, Holbrook, NY, United States, 11741-1618. Links. . holbrookbagelbakery.com. Contact info. . ( …
Holbrook Bagel Bakery: Your Destination for Fresh, Delicious …
Located at 1073 Main St, Holbrook, NY, we offer takeout, delivery, and a dog-friendly space. Join us for a taste that’s been called the best on Long Island!
Holbrook Bagel Bakery, 1073 Main St, Holbrook, NY 11741, US
Holbrook Bagel Bakery, located in Holbrook, NY, offers delicious bagels and pastries to satisfy any craving. Customers have the chance to win a dozen free …
Reviews
Steve D
After walking out of another bagel place due to chaos and disorganization, I stopped into this shop down the block—and I’m so glad I did. What a night-and-day difference.
The service here was friendly, fast, and actually competent. I ordered the same two egg sandwiches I had tried to get elsewhere, and they nailed it. My order was taken clearly, prepared right away, and handed to me in a reasonable amount of time—exactly how a bagel shop should run.
The food itself? Fantastic. Fresh bagels, perfectly cooked eggs, great flavor, and everything put together with care. You can taste the difference when a place actually takes pride in what they’re serving.
On top of that, the staff was pleasant and attentive. It’s refreshing to walk into a spot where people seem to genuinely care about the customers instead of treating the counter like controlled chaos.
This is the kind of place that earns repeat business. I went in frustrated from a bad experience and walked out with a great breakfast and an even better impression. I’ll absolutely be back.
… moreThe service here was friendly, fast, and actually competent. I ordered the same two egg sandwiches I had tried to get elsewhere, and they nailed it. My order was taken clearly, prepared right away, and handed to me in a reasonable amount of time—exactly how a bagel shop should run.
The food itself? Fantastic. Fresh bagels, perfectly cooked eggs, great flavor, and everything put together with care. You can taste the difference when a place actually takes pride in what they’re serving.
On top of that, the staff was pleasant and attentive. It’s refreshing to walk into a spot where people seem to genuinely care about the customers instead of treating the counter like controlled chaos.
This is the kind of place that earns repeat business. I went in frustrated from a bad experience and walked out with a great breakfast and an even better impression. I’ll absolutely be back.
Pete Coste
Bagels and sandwiches are always excellent quality and the service is fast and friendly. At least two of the one-star reviews of this shop are fake: one is complaining about food this shop has never offered in the 40+ years I’ve been coming here under multiple owners, and another talks about going “down the street” to a place that doesn’t exist and never did. This is the bagel shop you want on Main Street. The only downside is that their landlord doesn’t match the owners of this business in doing things right.
… moreJoe Fragano
The best bagels in Holbrook and surrounding area. They look and taste so fresh and fluffy. They’re almost a good as the bagels we get in lower Manhattan. The other plus? They put the seasoning not only on the top but also the bottom.
… moreMykhailo
Worst bagel place ever the lady and the daughter are so rude at the front and there bagels were overcooked and dry extremely rude customer service very disappointed never coming back again
… moreBrendan D
I’ve been coming here forever and they never disappoint. Best bagels hands down and the egg sandwiches come out perfect every time
… moreSusana Florio
I have to say their bagels are good but their attitude isn’t!! No personality and rude!!! Especially the daughter!! She once refused to serve me because “they” misunderstood the order and instead of apologizing like any store owner would do, she told her sour faced mother to give me my money back and to not serve me!! Nice customer service!! I’m surprised they’re still in business with that attitude!! SMH!!
… moreDave Busching
I can’t believe that a deli owner would put a sandwich that looks like this out into the public. This is supposed to be a turkey bacon with mayo on a wrap and it’s almost as thin as a sheet of paper. I don’t know if any of those ingredients are in this sandwich. Service is terrible don’t recommend at all
… moreJane Doe
Wow just left there. I was refused a toasted bagel with cream cheese because they were closing soon and the girl told me “ sorry the toaster takes to long” when asked what time you close she said 2. I said it takes 40 mins to toast a bagel?? She said fine if I want one I’ll do it. I left and went to toasted bagel down the block who is better anyway. This isn’t the first time this happened but the last time it was 15 mins b4 so I said maybe they cleaned it already… just in aw
… moreBig Joe
Nice people working the counter. Kept the line moving while being friendly. Bagels were terrific! Might make this our new favorite bagel shop!
… moreDoug R
If you make a Salt bagel, put SALT on the bagel. This is pathetic – I’m sorry. Do better and open your eyes to the product you’re making. I won’t be back. Too many others doing bagels better – not that hard guys.
… more