

This large, chic American eatery on the 2nd floor of Bal Harbour Shops has an alfresco patio bar.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 9700 Collins Ave, Bal Harbour, FL 33154
Phone: (786) 260-6650
Website: http://www.hillstonebalharbour.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Hillstone at Bal Harbour
Hillstone at Bal Harbour
Hillstone restaurant
Reviews
Service was among the worst I’ve experienced. Four people ordered drinks and we all asked for water; two glasses arrived, just 2. After asking twice more, it still took over 20 minutes to get the remaining two glasses. They were refilled where convenient, once, empty rest of the night, and the size of a Dixie cup. Drink orders: one arrived after apps, drink order 2 sat at the bar for roughly 15 minutes without delivery. When we attempted to retrieve them ourselves as we could see them at the bar, we were told we couldn’t take them. Only after the manager intervened did the drinks finally arrive.
From the start of her poor efforts, the server was clearly trying to rush / turn the table. Several of us have years of restaurant experience, and the lack of attentiveness and basic hospitality was obvious and entirely off-putting. If she was inexperienced, she shouldn’t have been at this place. If she was experienced, that’s worse—there was zero tact and less customer awareness or attentiveness. The attitude felt performative, as if “Bal Harbour snootiness” was part of the role. It didn’t land.
Management was good, and the young men did attempt damage control, effectively but a bit too late, which is the only positive note. The compped drinks didn’t redeem the experience: the dirty martini arrived without olive juice; when requested it to be corrected, a weak side of olive juice was brought instead. Make it right maybe??
I wouldn’t return under any circumstances. Beyond the restaurant, the general vibe of the area was cold and judgmental—people there were more interested in posturing, wearing all black, gray or white, looking down their nose at passers by
..so weird to see a culture of that other than being out enjoying themselves. Money without warmth is just gross noise, no where on the area exuded such stark judgy nonsensical and patently uncool atmosphere. This place, and the surrounding scene, left no impression other than superficial and joyless. Hard pass. These Bal Harbor people have found a way to collectively put off a vibe that just sucks. Food was fine, actually sushi was way better than expected, and French dip was amazing. Lots to work on otherwise, but had to add that…
Later, another glass was brought, but it was also not properly clean. In addition, the plates we were served on were wet and visibly worn, which raised serious concerns about hygiene and cleanliness.
This level of hygiene and customer service is unacceptable. The restaurant should pay much more attention to cleanliness and basic service standards.
had a deeply uncomfortable and unacceptable experience at this restaurant.
I entered with my legally protected service dog, which Florida law and the ADA clearly allow in restaurants. At one point, my dog needed water. I was given a disposable box by staff, filled it with my own water, and quietly let my service dog drink next to me. There was no mess, no disruption, and no health issue.
When the manager noticed it was for a dog, I was told to stop immediately, throw the box away, and was given an ultimatum: leave the restaurant or stop giving my service animal water.
This was humiliating, unnecessary, and discriminatory.
The law does not require restaurants to provide water for service animals — but it also does not prohibit owners from caring for their service animals themselves. Threatening removal simply because a service dog drinks water is unacceptable and shows a complete lack of understanding of disability rights.
If you or someone you care about relies on a service animal, be aware: you may not be treated with dignity or basic human decency here.
I will not be returning, and I strongly discourage others from supporting a business that treats service animals this way.
The service is attentive, professional, and genuinely warm.
The atmosphere is perfect for a date night – soft lighting, romantic vibe, and just the right level of background noise. It strikes that balance between upscale and cozy. Highly recommend for a special evening out!