High Street Bagels is your famous one stop shop in Sayville, NY for all delectable and delicious foods. We offer a wide variety of breakfast and lunch foods, as well as an extensive selection catering options for your occasion. From our bagels to our cream cheese, from our delicious custom made breakfast burritos, omelets, to our mouth-watering sandwiches and smoothies we have an extensive menu to choose from. At High Street Bagels our dishes are prepared with the freshest and finest of ingredients, fresh herbs & spices to bring you some lip-smacking yet healthy delicacies to bring you a meal that doesn’t just satisfy you, but keeps you coming back for more!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 217 N Main St, Sayville, NY 11782
Phone: (631) 319-1540
Website: https://www.storedirect.grabulldirect.com/menu/high-street-bagels-217-north-main-street-sayville-ny
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
High Street Bagels Sayville | Order Online Bagel Store Restaurant
Bacon, ham, turkey or sausage. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, shellfish, or fresh eggs, may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you …
High street bagels (@hightstreetbagelcafe) – Instagram
32 followers · 18 following · 8 posts · @hightstreetbagelcafe: “High Street Bagels Fresh, handmade bagels daily Sayville, NY | High Street Catering …
High Street Bagels Delivery Menu – Sayville – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from High Street Bagels in Sayville! View High Street Bagels’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with …
Reviews
Mark Young
I found this place after visiting Sayville on business and seeing my “normal” spot closed, gave this place a try. Ignore the lower rating. These nice owners just took over the business Sept 2023. You can order any egg sandwich with bagel or roll options. They also have omelettes, pancakes and baked goods. Prices and service are both very good. The staff is very friendly. The quality of the food is outstanding – had the egg bagel special one day and a Western Omelette the next. The omelette comes with a bagel all for only $7.99. This will be my new “go to” bagel / breakfast place when I am in town. I highly recommend you give them a try. Look at the reviews since they have owned it from Sept 2023 to current day.
… moreTara Clampett
I got turkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce and tomato on an everything flagyl and my bf got an everything flagyl with scallion cc, lox, capers, tomato and onion. We both loved it and he’s super picky. We also got a blueberry bagel with strawberry cc just to try and it was delicious! We’ll definitely be back!
… moreRanveer Singh
Alright listen, it might seem like I’m exaggerating but this is one of the best places to eat brunch breakfast or lunch. I’ve been here many times and the ppl at the front are EXTREMELY nice and love to help out! I come here so often they know my order and the atmosphere is just amazing! They get your order fast even in a lunch rush and the service is just perfect. Might seem like I’m over exaggerating but this place is JUST perfect. Will he coming back anytime I can!
… moreNicole Edmonds
the only place I found that does a proper scooped bagel, the right portion of cream cheese to bagel and their breakfast sandwiches are some of the best in town!
… moreCarrie Jessup
Went back today…. New owners…. Super nice but again the wrap was horrible
Worst rap of my life! I paid $12 I got a wrap and a monster! There was two pieces of turkey bacon an eighth of an avocado and maybe 6 to 10 spinach leaves it was absolutely horrible I will never go back here they used to be really good but now their horrible…. Oh and when I called to complain it’s a voicemail
… moreWorst rap of my life! I paid $12 I got a wrap and a monster! There was two pieces of turkey bacon an eighth of an avocado and maybe 6 to 10 spinach leaves it was absolutely horrible I will never go back here they used to be really good but now their horrible…. Oh and when I called to complain it’s a voicemail
Jay Abra
So if you order on Uber eats this place is also listed as “Sunny and Fine’s Breakfast Burritos” let me tell you there was nothing fine about this burrito. The pictured burrito cost $10.50. Total rip off. I also ordered coffee with milk and sugar which came with no sugar. Would not recommend.
… moreFuzzys kitch katch
Om Gosh Today decided to go in and give them a try ,sooo good ,i cut it in half its big and oh so fresh n Good
… moreMendoza Mendoza
Best bagels in the town. I had other day egg sandwich and it was so delicious. I definitely recommended. Customer service is best. I believe her name is dazy helped me that day made my lunch so good and fast.
… moreDonna Zabo
Clean and very fast! Had a sunflower seed bagel with BEC and was very content. Great selection of drinks and snacks. My one gripe was after eating, I took my garbage and bag of chips (already paid for with my original order) and went to buy another drink, the woman wrung up my juice as $3.25 and I gave her $20.25. She quickly gave me $12 in change. I walked out and quickly checked my change to see it was clearly missing $5. I went in and told the cashier. She asked how I paid and I explained, she gave me my $5. I hope this was an honest mistake. If I go back, I might pay exact change, credit card or look carefully BEFORE leaving.
… moreParminder Saini
I was in the area and decided to grab breakfast and was pleasantly surprised. I ordered a breakfast sandwich and a smoothie. Both items had fresh ingredients and tasted really good! Will definitely be returning with my family next time.
… more