Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 214 N Franklin St, Red Lion, PA 17356
Phone: (717) 850-1601
Website: https://heftyleftys.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Hefty Lefty’s – Franklin Street Social
Hefty Lefty Menu. All hoagies and grinders include lettuce, onions, tomatoes, olive oil, red wine vinegar, sea salt and oregano.
Hefty Lefty’s
Authentic Philadelphia style sandwiches in York! Yep, you read that right! At Hefty Lefty’s we are obsessed with hoagies, grinders and cheesesteaks!
Hefty Lefty’s – Franklin Street Social | Toast
Hefty Lefty’s – Franklin Street Social · All American Hoagie Hardy. cooked ham, cooked salami, bologna, cooper sharp american cheese, lettuce, onions, tomatoes, …
Reviews
River Bottom Roasters
Curly fries were awesome. Balboa was the boss. I thought the OC cheesesteak was a little under salted, but I just added curly fries on top my sub and it was great
… moreDave Brooks
To be honest, I was not expecting this! I got the OC Cheesesteak Hefty with everything. It really was amazing! Very large, cheesesteak and onions over flowing the sesame seed roll. The bread was perfect, you could actually taste the sesame in each bite, very fresh. The cheese is cooked into the steak, not just a slice on top. The fried onions were super sweet and delicious. Great quality steak, no gristle. I haven’t had a steak sub better than this since Captain Harvey’s in Dundalk, MD. The “LARGE” fries left me wanting. They were good, just not what you would consider as large. The atmosphere is loud and chaotic, but in a good family friendly way. I’ll be back!
… moreJustin Nation (The Nindersect)
Legitimately the best sub I’ve had in decades. Too many places don’t take making great and affordable subs seriously, but this place does it right. Plenty of food for the money, and it tastes great!
… morelaurenn lewis
I guess you should double and triple check your to go order before you leave, that includes unwrapping your sub. my first experience here. my order was completely wrong, asked to add sweet peppers to my cheesesteak, i guess doing that meant you loose the other topping that were listed to come already on your sandwich, also they curly fries were completely inedible, barely cooked pretty much raw. for 20$ I was hoping for a better experience for sure
… moreCheryl Smith
Great Steak Subs! Love the amount of steak, onions and cheese. I would prefer a softer sub roll…but the taste is amazing.
… moreAndrew Mueller
Thank GOD they started doing delivery. I’ll be ordering about once a month when I’m up this way.
The Italian hoagies are humongous..the pics dont do them justice. More importantly, these seeded rolls are better than anything you can get outside of South Philly. The sharp provolone is excellent as is the meats. But what’s shockingly AWESOME is the lettuce and tomatoes. Seriously tastes like they came fresh from the farmer’s market.
And finally, the cheesesteaks. Again, the best you’re gonna get outside of Philly. The O.C. (subbed in sharp provy) sat for 2hrs while I was working on a project so it was half soggy and wilty. I STILL housed every single bite of it and it was still friggin phenomenal. Steak is high quality and plentiful. Onions are cut and cooked perfectly. Only way they could upgrade these are to offer fried mushrooms and/or fried peppers.
Only gripe is the marinara. I’m big on steaks with sauce on em and the first steak I got from here I got with sauce. It was way too sweet so I ended up tossing it and focusing on the Philly Special (which was more than enough for a meal anyway). Minor complaint…I’ll keep getting them, just without the red sauce.
… moreThe Italian hoagies are humongous..the pics dont do them justice. More importantly, these seeded rolls are better than anything you can get outside of South Philly. The sharp provolone is excellent as is the meats. But what’s shockingly AWESOME is the lettuce and tomatoes. Seriously tastes like they came fresh from the farmer’s market.
And finally, the cheesesteaks. Again, the best you’re gonna get outside of Philly. The O.C. (subbed in sharp provy) sat for 2hrs while I was working on a project so it was half soggy and wilty. I STILL housed every single bite of it and it was still friggin phenomenal. Steak is high quality and plentiful. Onions are cut and cooked perfectly. Only way they could upgrade these are to offer fried mushrooms and/or fried peppers.
Only gripe is the marinara. I’m big on steaks with sauce on em and the first steak I got from here I got with sauce. It was way too sweet so I ended up tossing it and focusing on the Philly Special (which was more than enough for a meal anyway). Minor complaint…I’ll keep getting them, just without the red sauce.
TJ Behlert
The “philly” cheesesteak we got was disgusting, a huge mess and had more onions than steak, I mean WAY MORE onions than steak. It was inedible and this isn’t the first time I got an inedible sandwich from here which is why I am posting this review. Ew. 0/5 will not ever be back.
… morecindy carmickle
It is worth the hype! For seating and parking purposes I will avoid busy weekend meal hours though
… moreBrineshia McNealy
Best cheesesteak in York. Fries were good but since they are thin they probably could have been taken out the fryer a bit sooner.
… moreTodd Lloyd
You will thank yourself for choosing Hefty Lefty’s… and you’ll be thankful to them for creating such a masterpiece.
… more