Lyla Santoro
I wish I’d gotten a better photo of the amazing cake Haylie made for my husband’s 35th birthday, but let me tell you it was a HIT! We just moved to the area and this was our first order with Haylie. Let me tell you, we were so happy with the experience! It was affordable, easy to order, and Haylie was flexible with me on the theme of the cake when I changed my mind. On top of that, the cake itself was delicious. It was rich chocolate, smooth and flavorful frosting, and the perfect size for our gathering. Thank you, Haylie, and we can’t wait to come again!!
… moreJuice Demon
Haylie B’s has so much to offer. The fresh, fun, unique menus that change every month have kept me coming back. Her case sells out fast, but that’s because everything she fills it with looks and tastes amazing. From an afternoon treat solo or with friends, to celebrating birthdays with a custom cake, Haylie B’s has never disappointed. Her attention to detail, quality ingredients, and commitment to service is unmatched. Haylie B’s is a local, small business owned and operated by one person. Whenever I’ve reached out about custom orders, product questions, or stopped in the shop in person, Haylie herself has responded to me with courtesy, professionalism, and greeted me with a smile. I very much appreciate everything that Haylie has provided for my friends, family, and myself, and because of this I will continue to personally recommend and patronize her business.
… moreHeather Warthen
I have been a customer of Haylie B’s since she opened her storefront in downtown Batavia. We regularly order for the holidays from her as well as I have done custom orders – which you have to book early in advance. Everything Haylie created is well done and delicious which is why you need to offer plenty of lead time for special orders. Consistency is key in the food business and she definitely delivers on this. She has impeccable customer service. I also have yet to ever have something I didn’t like. Our family has become fans of her treats and look forward to celebrations together to enjoy a taste of her talents. I cannot recommend Haylie B’s enough!
… moreLindsey Sagan
I have ordered several birthday cakes from Haylie B’s and have NEVER been disappointed. The quality in her baking is top notch and everyone at our parties have been amazed at the taste and decorating skills. She is also a VERY friendly and kind person. I would highly recommend her.. i have never had an issue in placing my orders as I do give her a months warning and i also ASK.. not ASSUME that she has space for my order as i am well aware she is a small privately owned bakery.
… moreChelsea Esposito
Absolutely love what Haylie makes. Ordered a custom cake for my mom’s birthday and it was stunning and delish. Everyone at the table was amazed by the design/aesthetic and the taste! SO GOOD. My mom said it was the best tasting cake she’s ever had.
Highly recommend this bakery!! Please keep in mind custom orders can take some time, please plan and order well ahead of time and you will receive a stunning creation! Beautiful crafts take time.
… moreErin Hanrahan
Haylie made our wedding cake and cupcakes for us back in August and they were perfection – looked and tasted amazing! What more can you ask for. Our guests are still raving about these desserts. And so are we! We highly recommend Haylie B’s and can’t wait to order again for future celebrations.
… moreCourtney Bila
Haylie B’s is amazing! We ordered some custom watermelon cupcakes (and other treats!) for our co-ed BBQ-themed baby shower last summer, and they turned out SO cute, and were absolutely delicious. Our guests couldn’t stop raving.
We can’t wait to order more treats for future celebrations!
… moreShayna Price
I have used this local gem of a bakery for many occasions and in general to stop by and grab some scrumptious treats. Haylie always makes top notch cakes is so many ways- her frosting is outstanding, the cakes are perfection and the decoration and design is thoughtful and elegant.
100000/10 will be back again.
… moreBrooke VanKleeck
Always love stopping in to Haylie’s for a treat when I can! We knew as soon as we got engaged that we wanted to hire Haylie to create our wedding cake, and she delivered above and beyond on everything we’d hoped for. Absolutely delicious flavor and beautiful decoration work, we received tons of compliments from our guests. The ordering process was easy and painless with appropriate planning ahead, and I’d gladly look to Haylie for any custom baked goods we need in the future.
… moreSamantha
If you’re in need of a cupcake fix, a delicious cake or cupcakes for an event or a holiday – Haylie B’s is the place to go! We love that she has a few new flavors to try each month on top of her signature flavors. If you stop in on the weekends to try, get there early – she’s a town favorite and sells out quick!
… more