Shimmy Mo
We were a little late but they were still accommodating in letting us keep our table for 6 people. Visiting from NJ, so my family is accustomed to having different cuisines that are cooked just right. We started off with crab dip, it was delicious. Unfortunately, we weren’t able to take a picture because it didn’t last long at our table, but the pieces of crab meat were huge. The portions for all of our meals were huge, so the price is worth it. Everything was seasoned well and all of our meat was cooked throughly without being dried out. Our server was very kind and patient with us, as we had some picky eaters(children). He made sure we were content with our meals, and continued to check on us throughout our dinner there.
… moreSpencer Williams
The cakes are incredible! They have the best lemon cake in Raleigh in my opinion (their lemon blueberry cake). You can walk in and order cake slices to go from the cake display counter. You can also order full cakes in advance but they are huge, so you’ll need several friends to help you finish it!
The food was good as well – highlights that we tried were the meatloaf and the crab dip. We plan to go back to try more of their food menu (and more cake).
Back to the cakes – lemon blueberry is my top choice and the chocolate peanut butter mouse pie is a close second!
… moreLindsey R.
Hands down absolutely our favorite restaurant of all time! We lived in Raleigh from 2000 to 2010 and we tried a lot of restaurants. This 1940’s throwback dinner quickly became our go to date spot. Classic American dishes that are done to perfection and outstanding dessert options you cannot pass up.
We recently had the opportunity to visit Raleigh after 15 years of being gone and to our greatest delight Hayes Barton was still open and just the same as it was when we first went there.
This is a hidden gem that will take you back in time with comfort food and a cozy atmosphere. Don’t miss out! Be sure to make reservations (parties of 4 or more).
… moreGina-Maria Pomann
I got really sick within a couple hours of eating here and I hadn’t eaten anything all day that would’ve caused the issue that I had. I called the restaurant and they said that they were going to call me back and that nobody else had any issues, but they never even called me back… honestly it tasted amazing and the atmosphere was terrific. However, that was last week and the fact that I called to tell them that the fish potentially made me sick after dropping a few hundred on a meal, and I never got a call back ends with this rating.
… moreRhonnie Mapp
One of my favorite restaurants everrrrr. Make sure to book a reservation unless you’re there just to grab dessert. We’ve been here many times and have enjoyed ourselves. Everything is good. Cute, quaint, relaxing small restaurant. It’s one of the oldest restaurants in Raleigh. They are also known for their HUGE cakes. You can’t leave without a slice of cake!
… moreRandy Parnell
This is historic Raleigh! They have the best cake around. The hardest part is choosing which cake to have during your visit. I would go with the staff’s recommendation. The staff was super friendly and helpful.
… moreElizabeth Scott
Such a fun atmosphere! We had lunch and the food was pretty good. I had a BLT that was nice. To be honest, the real reason I went there was to take home a couple of pieces of cake. Just took a couple of bites so I could let you know… They are phenomenal. I got the seasonal patty (which was a berry layer cake) and the chocolate raspberry. I gotta go now so I can finish off those cakes Lol!
… moreAshley Moore
DELICIOUS. nothing else to say.
make a reservation in advance! at least a week before, I called 2 just to make sure. set menu with additional rotating options. and set aside your cake slice right when you get there too, they will sell out!
… moreEmily Fong
Amazing cake! They always have the best flavors and the slices are huge. Really nice diner look that encompasses the “old” Raleigh atmosphere. They close early so keep that in mind when you go!
… moreKatie Crenshaw
This is such a cute place to dine or indulge on a sweet treat! The atmosphere is a fun retro cafe setting. The menu items are great. Food and service is terrific. The desserts are AMAZING! This place is perfect for all occasions whether it is a date night or a family fun night. I highly recommend reservations.
… more