Small, unfussy outlet offering counter-serve pies with varied toppings, plus slices & wings.
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 103 N Main St, Mansfield, OH 44902
Phone: (419) 522-2211
Website: http://www.hamiltons.love/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Hamilton’s On Main
Formerly Two Cousins Pizza – voted the best pizza in Mansfield by Google Reviews – Hamilton’s On Main continues the tradition you know and love. · We offer dine- …
Hamilton’s On Main – Mansfield, OH – 103 N Main St – Hours, Menu …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-6:30 PM; Shop address is 103 N Main St, Mansfield, OH 44902103 N Main St, Mansfield, OH 44902; (419) 522-2211.
Hamilton’s On Main – 103 N Main St, Mansfield, OH 44902 – – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Mansfield, OH! Hamilton’s On Main is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Reviews
Shane Cooper
The food was absolutely fantastic! The Chicago-style pizza I ordered was enormous and incredibly satisfying, leaving me pleasantly full after just a couple of slices. It arrived piping hot, with the cheese perfectly melted and the crust delightfully crispy yet soft on the inside. I was thoroughly impressed and would not hesitate to order it again on my next visit. This was my first experience with Chicago-style pizza, and it certainly did not disappoint. To top it all off, I indulged in a slice of cotton candy cheesecake, which was heavenly—rich and creamy, with a playful sweetness reminiscent of carnival treats. Overall, it was an unforgettable meal!
… morewuSchu
Well…I’m going to go on a limb and say that it may not be the roadwork that’s hurting your business. It may be the product. I’m all about supporting local business, which is why I went out of my way to get it from the South Side, but if you’re serving up pies like this, then I’ll be the first to say that the road work didn’t do this. You did. And, well…I’ll stick with the other local shops here. Service and atmosphere are good, but you can’t BS your way through pizza. Pizza is sacred. And, this was a disaster.
… moreCarrie Miller
My honest review of my first experience.
Placed order through Slice for delivery at 6:15 pm. Order arrived on time.
Ordered:
Medium cheese pizza with light sauce- crust was decent, with that crispy, chewy bite. Perfect amount of sauce.
Meatball Sub- lightly baked
Meatballs are decent and flavorful. Perfect amount of sauce and the bread was perfectly lightly baked.
Classic Italian Sub- no mods
Honestly my favorite part of my order. Crispy flavor roll, crispy edges on the meat. Definitely will order this again.
Carrot Cake & Banana Nut Cake
Unfortunately they were out of cake, and allowed me to choose from a couple different frozen mini cream pies. That was disappointing, not sure how they are but honestly I would have rather had the cakes.
That’s my only truly disappointing experience- was the cake being unavailable. The food is kinda pricey but would try again.
… morePlaced order through Slice for delivery at 6:15 pm. Order arrived on time.
Ordered:
Medium cheese pizza with light sauce- crust was decent, with that crispy, chewy bite. Perfect amount of sauce.
Meatball Sub- lightly baked
Meatballs are decent and flavorful. Perfect amount of sauce and the bread was perfectly lightly baked.
Classic Italian Sub- no mods
Honestly my favorite part of my order. Crispy flavor roll, crispy edges on the meat. Definitely will order this again.
Carrot Cake & Banana Nut Cake
Unfortunately they were out of cake, and allowed me to choose from a couple different frozen mini cream pies. That was disappointing, not sure how they are but honestly I would have rather had the cakes.
That’s my only truly disappointing experience- was the cake being unavailable. The food is kinda pricey but would try again.
Kyle
I think this might be the best deep dish I have had and yes I have been to Chicago. While prices are a bit high and wait times are long I think the pizza is worth it. The only size they have is almost $40 and was an hour wait. But they walked it over to Phoenix Brewing for me so there’s things to do while waiting. Pizza is also huge and will likely feed 3 people. I ate 3 slices and was stuffed.
… moreDavid Kempt
I was in Mansfield with my dad so he could take care of some business and I decided I wanted a couple slices for lunch. After a quick google search I found Two Cousins . I went and got 2 slices of Pepperoni pizza and boy was it delicious. I gave it a 7.9 on the one bite scale. I’d definitely recommend going there and wish I would of just grabbed a full pizza. Good environment and friendly staff
… moreChristine Slone
Ordered a pick up order for BBQ chicken stuffed crust and pepperoni bites both are really good. A little overloaded on BBQ sauce Ordered online for pick up and said it should be ready in 25 minutes got there to pick up on time and had to wait another 25 minutes for it to be ready noticed the inside of restraunt looked very dirty windows floors counters all looked like they haven’t been cleaned in a week. Staff not very friendly. Not sure I would return even with the food being good.
… moreSadie Cunningham
Have always had a good experience and delicious pizza. Typically order through the app and will have our order ready to go in 20-30 mins. Except for last night- ordered the special pepperoni pizza and added mushrooms/banana peppers with an order of cheesy bread around 6:30, app said it would be ready by 6:51. Arrived to the shop at 6:53, was told it would be another 10-15 minutes. Then was told the order was just being started. Staff was super nice and tried to make it right by upgrading the order with an extra pizza and making them extra large. Continued to wait for nearly 50 more minutes. When I finally make it back home a little after 8, hungry and ready to eat, there is not a single piece of pepperoni on either pizza. Crazy experience. I’m sure I’ll be back, but may need a little hiatus
… moreJon Vega
Food is good, but ask about combos and let them get the extras… otherwise the à la cart gets very pricey.
… moreAmanda Boor
We ordered deep dish pizza tonight. We wanted green pepper, onion, and mushroom. We accidentally got pepperoni. The pizza was delicious. And they offered to make us another to make up for the mistake. We will go back for this. It tastes great and the service is so nice. They really want you to have good food.
… moreRyan Davis
I ordered a medium spicy pep duo pizza, jalapeno poppers, and a small order of cheesy breadsticks for lunch today. Always exciting to try a new pizza joint out. I can say I wasn’t disappointed, but I also wouldn’t say I was wowed either.
This is very straightforward local pizzeria quality food. The pizza was good. I liked the sauce a lot and the pepperoni were really good. I’m not sure it was worth $16.50 for a medium though.
The jalapeno poppers were the weak point in the meal, and they often are when ordered at a pizza joint. I put some hot honey sauce on them and that perked them up a bit. They aren’t bad, but they aren’t anything that’s gonna bring you back. The portion size for them is great though. You get eight of them for a little over $8. That’s really good value.
The best part of the meal, and by a long shot, were the cheesy bread sticks. They had a very healthy helping of parmesan cheese and garlic on them. Absolutely delicious. I assumed they came with some sort of marinara, sadly they did not. That’s on me. I should have asked about that when I called in my order. But man, with marinara these would be fantastic. And at $7.50 for a small, (and despite being called a small it’s a sizeable serving), there is great value there.
Depending on what you get, I could easily see this place being a 4/5 pizzeria. The poppers really disappointed me though.
Will I be back? Maybe. Lot of competition in the pizza industry, but they do offer by the slice. Which might be enough to have me come back for a smaller meal with a friend to try some other items on their menu.
It’s definitely worth trying at least once.
… moreThis is very straightforward local pizzeria quality food. The pizza was good. I liked the sauce a lot and the pepperoni were really good. I’m not sure it was worth $16.50 for a medium though.
The jalapeno poppers were the weak point in the meal, and they often are when ordered at a pizza joint. I put some hot honey sauce on them and that perked them up a bit. They aren’t bad, but they aren’t anything that’s gonna bring you back. The portion size for them is great though. You get eight of them for a little over $8. That’s really good value.
The best part of the meal, and by a long shot, were the cheesy bread sticks. They had a very healthy helping of parmesan cheese and garlic on them. Absolutely delicious. I assumed they came with some sort of marinara, sadly they did not. That’s on me. I should have asked about that when I called in my order. But man, with marinara these would be fantastic. And at $7.50 for a small, (and despite being called a small it’s a sizeable serving), there is great value there.
Depending on what you get, I could easily see this place being a 4/5 pizzeria. The poppers really disappointed me though.
Will I be back? Maybe. Lot of competition in the pizza industry, but they do offer by the slice. Which might be enough to have me come back for a smaller meal with a friend to try some other items on their menu.
It’s definitely worth trying at least once.