Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5915 NY-81, Norton Hill, NY 12083
Phone: (518) 966-4745
Website: https://greenhillcafepizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Green Hill Cafe Pizzeria – Norton Hill, NY – 5915 NY-81 – Hours …
Order Hours About. 2:00 PM-9:00 PM; Shop address is 5915 NY-81, Norton Hill, NY 120835915 NY-81, Norton Hill, NY 12083; (518) 501-1807.
Green Hill Cafe Pizzeria – View Menu & Order Online – 5915 NY-81 …
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Norton Hill, NY! Green Hill Cafe Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Greenhill Cafe | Norton Hill NY – Facebook
Greenhill Cafe, Norton Hill. 652 likes · 6 were here. A family restaurant serving Italian-American favorites and delicious pizza! We are now offering IN…
Reviews
Ger Ard
I think they changed ownership. Plenty of parking, place looks a little run down on the inside and tables weren’t cleaned but it was also 8pm and they closed at 9pm. The staff could be a bit more welcoming and it could be a cultural thing too or again because it was 8pm. They were not rude though. We came in for pizza and pasta but the owners were now South Asian and they had Indian/Pakistani food on the menu and that’s what we ordered instead. Had chicken biryani which was spicy and I did not get any warning. It was good and came with 3pcs of chicken and plenty of basmati rice. Flavorful, spicy and aromatic. The chicken was dark meat and cooked in spices and wasn’t dry. I would come back again and try the pizza next time.
… moreAuthentically Alyson
If you haven’t been to Green Hill Cafe in Greenville, NY, stop what you’re doing and go—this place is the definition of a hidden gem! In my opinion, this is hands down the best pizza anywhere in the area. The sauce is absolutely incredible: the perfect balance of fresh tomatoes, garlic, and basil that hits every note just right. The pizza itself is cooked to perfection—not overdone, not underdone—just that ideal crisp yet soft bite that dreams are made of. The crust? Flavorful and airy, clearly made with quality ingredients (none of that cheap, bland stuff you get elsewhere).
I also tried their garden salad, which was crisp, vibrant, and fresh, and their stuffed shells were pure comfort food bliss. Generous portion size, served with a garden salad and—wait for it—an entire loaf of warm, garlicky bread that could win awards all on its own.
Here’s the twist that makes this spot even more unique: alongside their phenomenal pizza and Italian dishes, they also offer Pakistani and Indian cuisine. Yes, you read that right. Their chicken biryani? Absolute perfection. The spice level is balanced beautifully—not overpowering, but enough to make your taste buds dance. It’s the kind of dish you think about days later.
What ties it all together is the atmosphere: this is a family-run business where you’re greeted with a big smile and a warm “hello” the second you walk through the door. It feels personal, like you’re visiting old friends who just happen to be amazing cooks.
If you’re anywhere near Greenville, this is the place to be. Whether you’re craving pizza, pasta, or biryani (or all three—no judgment here), Green Hill Cafe will make you happy you came hungry.
“Food that feeds the soul, beauty that speaks volumes, and travel that tells a story always through the eyes of Italy Loves India.”
— Alyson Savino
IG: Alysonnyc212
Hashtags:
#BestPizzaInGreenville #GreenHillCafe #PizzaPerfection #StuffedShellsHeaven #ChickenBiryaniLove #IndianCuisineInNY #PakistaniCuisineDelight #FamilyOwnedAndOperated #WarmWelcomeVibes #HiddenGemEats #GreenvilleNYEats #FoodieApproved #PizzaAndBiryaniCombo #GarlicBreadGoals #FreshAndFlavorful #SupportLocalRestaurants #UltimateComfortFood #GreenvilleDiningSpot #HighlyRecommendedEats #AlysonNYC212
… moreI also tried their garden salad, which was crisp, vibrant, and fresh, and their stuffed shells were pure comfort food bliss. Generous portion size, served with a garden salad and—wait for it—an entire loaf of warm, garlicky bread that could win awards all on its own.
Here’s the twist that makes this spot even more unique: alongside their phenomenal pizza and Italian dishes, they also offer Pakistani and Indian cuisine. Yes, you read that right. Their chicken biryani? Absolute perfection. The spice level is balanced beautifully—not overpowering, but enough to make your taste buds dance. It’s the kind of dish you think about days later.
What ties it all together is the atmosphere: this is a family-run business where you’re greeted with a big smile and a warm “hello” the second you walk through the door. It feels personal, like you’re visiting old friends who just happen to be amazing cooks.
If you’re anywhere near Greenville, this is the place to be. Whether you’re craving pizza, pasta, or biryani (or all three—no judgment here), Green Hill Cafe will make you happy you came hungry.
“Food that feeds the soul, beauty that speaks volumes, and travel that tells a story always through the eyes of Italy Loves India.”
— Alyson Savino
IG: Alysonnyc212
Hashtags:
#BestPizzaInGreenville #GreenHillCafe #PizzaPerfection #StuffedShellsHeaven #ChickenBiryaniLove #IndianCuisineInNY #PakistaniCuisineDelight #FamilyOwnedAndOperated #WarmWelcomeVibes #HiddenGemEats #GreenvilleNYEats #FoodieApproved #PizzaAndBiryaniCombo #GarlicBreadGoals #FreshAndFlavorful #SupportLocalRestaurants #UltimateComfortFood #GreenvilleDiningSpot #HighlyRecommendedEats #AlysonNYC212
jesse stern
I can’t even comment on the food from this place, as I never received it, but was still charged for it. I was out running errands and decided to order from their website (and also pay in advance), thinking I could stop by and pick up my order on my way home. Both their website and Yelp listing showed that they were open. I also received an order status text saying my food was being prepared and approximate time it would be ready. When I arrived at the restaurant, the owner was just getting there and letting himself in. He said he had canceled my order since they weren’t open yet, but if I wanted to come back in two hours I could order then, I said no thank you and told him to cancel it, to which he said “ok.”
I found out later that night that they processed the payment for the canceled order anyway. Apparently their website orders are processed through the Slice app. I contacted Slice and was told they couldn’t do anything about a refund and that I would have to obtain it through the restaurant owner. The restaurant owner in turn told me he couldn’t do anything about it and that I would have to contact Slice.
So yea, I’m pretty pissed. I was screwed out of about $25 while they pointed their fingers at each other. So buyer beware – avoid ordering through their website. And to the restaurant owner, maybe get your business off the freaking internet, since you clearly don’t know how to navigate it!!
And while I’m here, I can comment on the establishment itself: their use of the quaint word “cafe” in their business name is ridiculous – the place is a hole. I guess it used to be a nice restaurant, but changed ownership, so maybe only pay attention to reviews after 2024.
… moreI found out later that night that they processed the payment for the canceled order anyway. Apparently their website orders are processed through the Slice app. I contacted Slice and was told they couldn’t do anything about a refund and that I would have to obtain it through the restaurant owner. The restaurant owner in turn told me he couldn’t do anything about it and that I would have to contact Slice.
So yea, I’m pretty pissed. I was screwed out of about $25 while they pointed their fingers at each other. So buyer beware – avoid ordering through their website. And to the restaurant owner, maybe get your business off the freaking internet, since you clearly don’t know how to navigate it!!
And while I’m here, I can comment on the establishment itself: their use of the quaint word “cafe” in their business name is ridiculous – the place is a hole. I guess it used to be a nice restaurant, but changed ownership, so maybe only pay attention to reviews after 2024.
Kristian Murnane
The people were great. I asked if I could get their BBQ chicken pizza but to make it a white pizza instead of traditional. They told me it was no problem at all. The food was great.
… moreWajiha Ijaz
Found a gem!! Excellent place to enjoy halal food in upstate new York. The owner is very nice and friendly and offered us complimentary tea. Food was fresh and very tasty. Pizza was delicious.
… moreLaurie Ann
Pizza was amazing. Taste is spot on ! We got a sausage, pepperoni and onion . It was delicious. Also got mild wings and they were excellent too.
… moreJody Busolt
First time coming here being new to the area. Garlic knots were dry and burnt. The pizza was so so. Sauce was like jar sauce used maybe some people like that. Unhappy with the meal and the manager saw nothing wrong with it. I tried to resolve this before here
… moreSandra
First time we’ve ever been here. Ordered a Silician cheese pizza, and it was delicious. Customer service was outstanding. Owners went out of their way to make us feel comfortable. We are definitely coming back and would recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants an authentic, and delicious, Sicilian pizza!
… moreJeremy Hills
Stopped in on way back from zoom flume. Starving kids, stopped quick on the fly. Dogs barking going buck wild. People came out from the back, ready to make us food. All set and ready to go, then I saw the cockroaches on the floor. Will never step food in this dirty dump again!
… moreBarbara Roccio
We really enjoyed our pizzas, wings extra crispy as we ordered and Buttered Chicken! Online ordering was a breeze. Delivery to Greenville is a PLUS!! The 2 person delivery team were very pleasant. We will definitely be ordering again! Pizza crusts were excellent! Thank you to everyone at Green Hill & Slice!
… more