Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Greek Tony’s has been a family owned and operated business since 1984. Homemade dough, fresh vegetables chopped, and fresh meats prepared daily. We are here to provide the best food possible without taking any of the corporate shortcuts. With that being said, be patient if it takes a bit longer, good food takes time. We’re happy to serve the best food to our very best customers every day!
Simple, popular spot offering a selection of pies & slices, plus sandwiches, gyros & salads.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1732 E 116th St, Carmel, IN 46032
Phone: (317) 846-1200
Website: http://www.carmelslastrealpizzajoint.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
GREEK TONYS PIZZA & SUB SHOP – Home
#1 pizza joint in Carmel, Indiana for nearly 40 years. Always expect GREAT TASTE, GOOD TIMES. Picture We make dough for our pizza and breadsticks every morning.
Greek Tony’s Pizza & Sub Shop | Carmel IN – Facebook
Greek Tony’s Pizza & Sub Shop, Carmel. 2602 likes · 244 talking about this · 1940 were here. Greek Tony’s has the most relaxing feel once you enter the…
Greek Tony’s Pizza & Sub Shop- E116th- Carmel | Order Online
Garden spring mix lettuce with ham, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella, mushrooms, green and red peppers, olives, onions, radish, tomatoes, & creamy italian dressing …
Reviews
Jerry Allen
Worst pizza ever. Ordered delivery. Didnt show up. Ordered again. They “rushed” it. Crust not done. Person on the phone a complete airhead that had to ask other people about things. It is 8:44. I ordered around 7pm. Lack of ingredients. Very little sauce. Garlic bread with cheese…no sauce. These people must running short of ragu. Im not impressed. Sorry. Not sorry. Do bettet.
… moreCharise Keith
Tried this pizza a at a market and it was so good. Their breadsticks were amazing. Lucas was such a kind spirit. He was very knowledgeable, respectful, and friendly. He truly made our first time trying them a great experience. Will be adding them to my favorite places to eat.
… moreJustin G
I generally dislike Carmel area restaurants, but this place is different. Worth a trip for the breadsticks alone. Pizza by the slice is great and the fountain drinks are still about 1.50. Sandwiches are too slim for the price, but still good. The only place in Carmel I recommend to everyone I know.
… moreMatt Leisure (Water • Fire • Mold)
Tried the gyro was delicious, $12 delicious but $8 portion. Friendly staff and old style deli environment with 40 years of doing business in Carmel, Indiana so doing things right.
Tony’s Supreme 16in pizza looked and smelled fabulous.
… moreTony’s Supreme 16in pizza looked and smelled fabulous.
LB
I have been going here since I was a kid. It is a great local chain that is ACTUALLY local (owned by a CHS alum and staffed by locals). The quality has only gotten better and the breadsticks are the best of any pizza place i’ve ever tasted. I order from here at least 2-3x a month because the food is world class, but also because it’s nice to see a small business with local ownership succeed. If you are thinking about getting pizza and sticks, skip the corporate chain and get Greek Tony’s!
(Get a larger order of breadsticks than you think you will need, you’ll want more!)
… more(Get a larger order of breadsticks than you think you will need, you’ll want more!)
chris courtney
Worked in the area in the late 90’s to early 2000. Coworker’s talked about this place and how great it was. Unfortunately never tried and moved on from area. But was in the area today with my mom which we are pizza junkies! So I was like hey I remember this place and area let’s check it out… well let me tell you it was amazing and Lucas if you were the only one in there making the pies and sticks for the ones in their prompts to you! Pizza was amazing and will definitely be back for a if I heard right a wet beef sandwich! Gotta keep the small family businesses like yours around!
… moreNodNikolai45
This place has been around forever, and it’s been good for as long as it’s existed, pizza and breadsticks are immaculate, I can’t speak for anything else as I only get pizza here, but I highly recommend visiting here. It does take awhile to get the food out, but it’s definitely worth it. Also some people may find the interior dated, but I think it’s very cozy feeling, and I like seeing all the old things they have hung on the walls.
… moreStephanie Jones
had an amazing experience at this pizza place! The staff went above and beyond to accommodate me, even making a custom Gyro style pizza topped with pepperoni and loaded with gyro meat exactly the way I wanted it. The flavor was incredible — perfectly balanced, with a crispy crust and high-quality toppings that made every bite memorable.
And the breadsticks… easily the best I’ve ever had in my life. Soft, buttery, perfectly seasoned, and absolutely addictive. I would come back for those alone!
If you’re looking for great service, delicious food, and a place that truly listens to its customers, this spot is a must-visit. Highly recommend! ✨ if you go, I highly recommend adding gyro meat to your pizza. You will not regret it.
… moreAnd the breadsticks… easily the best I’ve ever had in my life. Soft, buttery, perfectly seasoned, and absolutely addictive. I would come back for those alone!
If you’re looking for great service, delicious food, and a place that truly listens to its customers, this spot is a must-visit. Highly recommend! ✨ if you go, I highly recommend adding gyro meat to your pizza. You will not regret it.
Nicole Scherrer-Realtor
We had a work event that we wanted pizzza and the staff at Greek Tony’s (especially Sarah) were so helpful. The pizza and breadsticks were a hit and the pizzas were ready just exactly when I needed them! Great place for pre-ordering for a large event!
… moreSteve
Has potential. Love the recipe ideas. The “way too much butter” breadsticks has minimal. Cheese sauce that comes with might as well be plastic. I had to force it to stick to the breadsticks to try it. Pizza was good though.
… more