Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 42 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone: (631) 647-4856
Website: https://www.goodytwoshoesbar.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Goody Two Shoes
Goody Two Shoes brings a whole new experience to Bay Shore’s Main Street! Goody Two Shoes is a place to let out all your inhibitions after being on your …
Goody Two Shoes (@goodytwoshoesbar) · Bay Shore, NY – Instagram
Good eats, pours & vibes. THURS. LIVE MUSIC 7pm | DJs FRI. & SAT 9pm | BRUNCH SAT. & SUN. 11-2. Book your party. Photo by Goody Two Shoes on December 09, …
Order Goody Two Shoes | Bay Shore – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Goody Two Shoes at 42 East Main Street in Bay Shore. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Reviews
Chandanee Budnie
We hosted our legal ceremony after-party at Goody Two Shoes, and I truly cannot recommend this place enough. From start to finish, the entire experience was incredible.
Melanie, the manager, went above and beyond for us. She took care of everything we needed — even the things I didn’t get to finish myself, she handled without hesitation. Her attention to detail and genuine care made the night feel effortless and special.
Our server, Gabby, was absolutely amazing. She was attentive, kind, and made sure everyone felt taken care of throughout the night. The bartenders were just as fantastic — the drinks were flowing all night, and they crafted everything perfectly. Their energy and service really helped make the celebration unforgettable.
We also received help from other staff members whose names I didn’t catch, but every single person we interacted with was wonderful.
Thanks to the entire team at Goody Two Shoes, we had an unforgettable night. If you’re looking for exceptional service, fantastic staff, and a place that truly treats you like family, this is it.
… moreMelanie, the manager, went above and beyond for us. She took care of everything we needed — even the things I didn’t get to finish myself, she handled without hesitation. Her attention to detail and genuine care made the night feel effortless and special.
Our server, Gabby, was absolutely amazing. She was attentive, kind, and made sure everyone felt taken care of throughout the night. The bartenders were just as fantastic — the drinks were flowing all night, and they crafted everything perfectly. Their energy and service really helped make the celebration unforgettable.
We also received help from other staff members whose names I didn’t catch, but every single person we interacted with was wonderful.
Thanks to the entire team at Goody Two Shoes, we had an unforgettable night. If you’re looking for exceptional service, fantastic staff, and a place that truly treats you like family, this is it.
Joe Sander
My wife and I just finished up brunch here. Wonderful place, food is delicious waitstaff is very friendly. Playlist was wonderful, playing millennial punk pop classics.
… moreDebbie Zisman
Melanie is the best! Planning a retirement party for my husband pending a potential storm. Melanie was so kind, understanding and accommodating. She made it happen. Gabby was our server who was wonderful. Not sure who the bartender was, but there were no complaints about the drinks!! If you’re considering a small or large gathering, speak to Melanie. You will not be disappointed.
… moreEugen Martin
The food, unfortunately, wasn’t as hot as I would have liked—my burger was lukewarm, and the corndog was similar. However, the pita bread was served nice and warm, and they offer a small selection of nonalcoholic beers, which was a pleasant touch. While it wasn’t a bad experience overall, it might not be the best choice for a date, as the noise level made conversation a bit challenging. On a positive note, the service was quick, and the staff were very friendly.
… moreJustin Walker
This one star is only for the food… I ordered takeout and got their double smash and I didn’t realize they would give me two cheeseburgers… I’m thinking to myself this is amazing! Wrong! The most disgusting vile burger I’ve had in ages. This is not McDonald’s or burger king(which would’ve probably been better) these were not smash patties these were just grade D meat and prepackaged burger shapes that they put in the oven. Fat all around the burger. Pink inside. Where the hell was the smash? The burger was thicker than Meg the stallion. Never again
… moreJennifer Post
Cute little gem of a bar! Dropped in unexpectedly with a coworker for a quick lunch. The server/bartender Nasser (I think) was absolutely amazing and personable!! Drinks and flatbread were excellent. We only shared a couple of appetizers, but would def go back!
… moreLeon Pena
100/10 could not recommend enough! Me and my partner came here on a very busy Tuesday night and our server Gabrielle was so sweet! The food came out less than ten minutes are we ordered, the pretzel and quesadilla were very tasty, and the mulled wine spritz is excellent. Run to goodys!
… moreTara Nicosia
The restaurant is designed wonderfully.
It has ALOT of potential. However I think the menu needs a revamp. And I’m saying because I’m a chef owner operator w 25 years in the biz.
Staff was pleasant …
… moreIt has ALOT of potential. However I think the menu needs a revamp. And I’m saying because I’m a chef owner operator w 25 years in the biz.
Staff was pleasant …
Carolina Flores
Walked into Goody Two Shoes, after drinks at verde but ended up checking out the apps on date night. My husband had the burger and I ordered the wings and the birria egg rolls! The wings were a bit dry, I like my wings breaded but overall OK. However the birria tacos are my favorite thing!!! They were cheesy, full of beef and crispy on the outside soooooo delicious! They also had the birria dipping sauce which was AMAZING!
My husband enjoyed his steakhouse burger and yuca fries. The fries were great! Loved the chipotle dipping sauce! I asked for more. Next time I want to try the short rib Mac and cheese and the pupusas! Looking forward to dinning here again. I will also get more birria egg rolls!
The dining area is recently renovated and has nice lighting, an outdoor seating area with beautiful lighting and seating.
The service was fast in the dining area despite the crowded bar scene up front. The venue was packed and it was a good time!
… moreMy husband enjoyed his steakhouse burger and yuca fries. The fries were great! Loved the chipotle dipping sauce! I asked for more. Next time I want to try the short rib Mac and cheese and the pupusas! Looking forward to dinning here again. I will also get more birria egg rolls!
The dining area is recently renovated and has nice lighting, an outdoor seating area with beautiful lighting and seating.
The service was fast in the dining area despite the crowded bar scene up front. The venue was packed and it was a good time!
Michael
Sat at the bar. The staff members behind the bar were very kind and accommodating. Drinks were great. I got the dirty pickle cocktail and it was awesome. My entree that I ordered, the smash burger, was unfortunately underwhelming. It came as two separate burgers, but they were just regular thick hamburger patties on grocery store level potato buns (assuming Martin’s). Don’t get me wrong, they tasted fine, they just were definitely not smash burgers. More like a backyard style burger. The fries were great. I still want to come in and try some other menu items because the menu has a lot of variety and the staff was super nice.
… more