Morgan Williams
Really disappointed. I used to frequent this place. My favorite sandwich, the babushka, is no longer on the menu. So I opted for an everything bagel with their jalepeno flavored cream cheese. $5.55 for a bagel with very little cream cheese and at least a 1/4 cup of pickled jalapeños. The whole thing tasted of vinegar. I would not have ordered this if I had known it was a pickled jalepeno sandwich. The bagels in general are not as good as they once were.
… moreA
I come here several times a week. As soon as I walk in the door I am greeted with friendly service and the food is always delicious every time. Ashley is the star of the show and amazing at her job. I’ve noticed she always helps the other staff even when it’s busy. Taylor is an artist when it comes to making bagels, and Peter brings it all together from the kitchen.
… moreRobert Ribar
Great bagels (large variety) and coffee. I’m especially a fan of the whitefish salad. Their online ordering system is easy to use and the food will be ready and waiting. If you are looking for an early coffee and food in Catskill (and want to support a local business) this is one of your best bets since they open early most days. Some counter seating there or easy to takeout. There’s parking there and it’s a 2 minute drive to Catskill’s main street.
… moreJohn Barriga
There’s something special happening at Goodies Bagels. Not only have their bagels gotten even better and more delicious, but they’ve also added breakfast and lunch sandwiches to their menu – a major improvement to an already great spot. I recently tried their pumpernickel bagel with scallion cream cheese and it was absolutely amazing. It’s no surprise that a lot of people are stopping by to place and pick up their orders. I make sure to visit at least once a week, it’s definitely worth the drive. The staff is friendly and Vanessa, the owner, was there personally making cappuccinos. The coffee was fantastic and I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a delicious and friendly bagel experience.
… moreshelswanderlust
Hate when a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel costs $8. But I have to say this one was DELICIOUS!! The blonde lady that took my order was not very friendly. But the curly haired young lady w eyeglasses that handed me the sandwich was very kind and actually thanked me. She should be up front to greet people instead of frowny face.
… moreShira Sternlicht
Did not eat there since I’m a vegan. They pride themselves of having vegan options but the only vegan thing is cream cheese! Non of the bagels are vegan according to the cashier which is needlessly confusing.
… moreJeff Wood
Was here right after they originally opened. I asked for an everything with butter and cream cheese. They squirted butter on it and then proceeded to use melted cream cheese. That was 2 years ago.
I went back today. Everything with butter and cream cheese. Toasted dark. There was hardly any butter, and maybe, maybe, 1/4 inch of cream cheese. The bagle was like raw dough. Wouldn’t go back. Guess I’m just used to Bagel Thyme in Hudson and Lox of Bagels in Saugerties. If I’m paying over $5 for a bagel it better be good. Unfortunately this one wasn’t. I gave them 2 chances. Price Chopper is better.
… moreEmmanuel A (epajet)
Frequented Goodies often before the change of ownership and they were by far the best bagel you could find anywhere in the area.
Returned once after the re-opening and got stale bagels of three different kinds, so no accident. We were very surprised and disappointed so we made the effort to go back and report our experience. A staff member took down our number, promised a call from a manager, months later we’re still waiting…Haven’t returned since.
… moreLi S
Amazing bagel spot!! These bagels are fluffy, fresh and tasty. The sandwiches were amazing! Italian Stallion was fresh and flavorful. Babooshka was hearty and filling and my BTL was perfectly crispy and dressed well.
Service was a little hectic, but I think they had a few new folks on staff.
Seating is limited, but chic traditional diner style stools. The decor is bright and airy.
Bathroom was spacious and well-decorated (clean, modern). But only one bathroom.
I don’t believe it is very accessible, the door is a bit narrow. Also there is one step to get in the restaurant.
… morePetrovsky Yura
I placed an order around 8:00 AM on Saturday — just a simple order of soup and bagels with cream cheese. Despite the place not being busy, I waited over 15 minutes while several people who ordered after me received their food.
When I finally asked about my order, the staff offered to give it to me for free, but that wasn’t the issue. I didn’t want a free meal — I just wanted timely service. Waiting that long for something so simple on a quiet morning is unacceptable. Really disappointing experience.
… more