Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Local pizzeria chain serving NY-style pies, subs & calzones in a relaxed, stylish setting.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–3 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–3 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–12 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1211 Main St, Cincinnati, OH 45202
Phone: (513) 381-3625
Website: https://www.goodfellaspizzeria.com/otr
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
OTR – Cincinnati – Goodfellas Pizzeria
Goodfellas Over-The-Rhine ; Seasonal Cocktails. Check out this season’s crafted cocktails by our staff here at Distillery. View Cocktails ; Book Your Private …
Goodfellas Pizzeria – OTR | Cincinnati OH – Facebook
Due to incoming inclement weather, all our shops will be closed today. The safety of our staff and guests is always our top priority, and with the winter storm …
Goodfellas Pizzeria – OTR, 1211 Main St, Cincinnati, OH 45202, US
Hand-tossed NY-style slices & pies + full craft cocktail bar in Over-the-Rhine, Cincinnati. $10 Lunch, ½-price 12” Mondays. Patio murals, Wiseguy Lounge.
Last Updates
Reviews
Moe Habib
Everything was great, the staff were professional and friendly. I ordered two pizza one cheese and the other with few Veggies and Beef. The sauce was good, the dough had good texture, perfectly cooked but was tough. It gives your jaws a good workout. I am assuming the dough was fresh and didn’t have time to rest. Another complaint I have, I ordered beef for my pizza topping and without exaggeration, you can’t see it, it felt like beef powder. I paid 80+ and didn’t enjoy to be honest. However, I understand it was late night so I am going to try them again and write a fair review:
UPDATE: 12/27/25 We came in again, but during the day to try it out again. Different staff, still professional and very friendly. They took our order which was almost exactly the same as last time but this time i came with guests. Now thats a ***** great pizza. The dough was perfect the sauce was amazing and the portions for the beef was just perfect.
12/29/25 I am now here again with the kids. We were greeted by Dunk’n, he was great, remembered us immediately, gave us a vip treatment, helped us with Monday promotions, without even knowing about the review. His attitude and hospitality made our day. Will definitely make this our future go to place.
… moreUPDATE: 12/27/25 We came in again, but during the day to try it out again. Different staff, still professional and very friendly. They took our order which was almost exactly the same as last time but this time i came with guests. Now thats a ***** great pizza. The dough was perfect the sauce was amazing and the portions for the beef was just perfect.
12/29/25 I am now here again with the kids. We were greeted by Dunk’n, he was great, remembered us immediately, gave us a vip treatment, helped us with Monday promotions, without even knowing about the review. His attitude and hospitality made our day. Will definitely make this our future go to place.
ala alsheyaa
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Amazing Experience!
I’m a huge pizza fan, and Goodfellas Pizza on Main absolutely delivered. I love New York–style slices, and this is one of the few places in Cincinnati that really gets it right. The slices are big, flavorful, and they always have a great variety to choose from. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite while walking through downtown or sitting in for a full pie, this spot is a must-try.
Don’t forget the breadsticks—they’re incredible. I usually mix and match different slices with different toppings, and every time the quality is consistently great. The whole vibe of the place reminds me of New York.
If you’re in downtown Cincinnati, don’t miss out on Goodfellas Pizza. Highly recommended!
… moreAmazing Experience!
I’m a huge pizza fan, and Goodfellas Pizza on Main absolutely delivered. I love New York–style slices, and this is one of the few places in Cincinnati that really gets it right. The slices are big, flavorful, and they always have a great variety to choose from. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite while walking through downtown or sitting in for a full pie, this spot is a must-try.
Don’t forget the breadsticks—they’re incredible. I usually mix and match different slices with different toppings, and every time the quality is consistently great. The whole vibe of the place reminds me of New York.
If you’re in downtown Cincinnati, don’t miss out on Goodfellas Pizza. Highly recommended!
Emily Anderson
Really well prepared pizza. Vegetarian options. All the other pizzas looked good too. Large slices. We went a little after 900p and they still had a lot to pick from. Huge bread sticks. Nice spot with the bar upstairs. We got our pizza to go. You have the option to eat in as well.
… moreEmily
Love the fact the pizza is available pretty late. We bought a couple of slices. They are pretty good sized! Not bad pizza. The atmosphere is nice too. The bar upstairs has a ton of whiskey or bourbon. If you like that stuff its definitely the place to get top shelf booze.
… moreUsinda Thompson
02/14/26-We went on valentine’s day since everything was so over booked. There was no wait. The stuff was nice and fast. We got a few slices. It was so delicious. The only thing I don’t like about the slices is we do not eat pork and if they do a half and half it can be cross contaminated. The slices are pretty large. The crust is thin and a little crisp(which i like). No reservation needed. We were able to walk right in. The parking is crazy in that area. There are a few lots you can park in its rarely any street parking unless its early in the day. The tables needed cleaned. They didn’t have enough cheese shakers for the tables so another couple asked for the one we had.
… morePaul Johnson
Pizza was tasty like always. Breadstick could have been a little sifter but was good especially when paired with nacho cheese. Lots of seating options in the speakeasy with a cool bar! Staff is friendly and helpful. Worth a stop!
… moreZurab Tskhadashvili
Great atmosphere, huge slices. You got to try bread sticks.
… moreCat
Excellent pizza and drink selections!! Helpful and gracious staff. We didn’t know what we were doing; crazy tourists!!!
… moreErin Sparks
Food was delicious, i loveeee the chewy crust. The staff was very friendly, the atmosphere was nice and chill. Family friendly upstairs seating until 9pm.
… moreCassi
Food was truly terrible. The crust was chewy on the bottom and hard on the end. Asked for extra cheese and I could still see sauce through the cheese and the cheese wasnt even close overflowing with a good melt. $3 up charfe for extra cheese too. Everything was just hard or chewy. $50 pizza and cheese sticks by the way. Don’t waste your time or money. Or try a different location.
… more