Kayce Ball
Whitney at the bar is always so friendly. Drinks are cold, fresh and delicious. Pizza is always spot on. We order ahead online to avoid the wait. We always look forward to going here and bring friends often when they come to town! We’ve been coming for years and look forward to many years ahead!
… moreJeff Ward
Good pizza joint. Great pizza! We did pepperoni and banana peppers. It was perfect. We had a 12″ pizza and it was perfect for 2 people. Great selection of drinks. Great old building. It felt cozy inside. It is right next to 2 distilleries, so we stopped by after our tour. Perfect end for the day.
… moreMitch Lilly
Goodfellas Pizzeria and Distillery is a must go establishment if you are in or near Lexington. The atmosphere is truly one of a kind. The attention to detail and the preservation of the building’s history is commendable. If the service and food wasn’t so good. I’d still recommend going just to see it, but the full experience will leave you completely satisfied.
… morecasey farthing
We got our pizza to go mind you, but the interior is beautiful. The staff was very friendly and helpful and the pizza is some of the best ive had. It’s popular so placing an order ahead of time is smart, otherwise expect about an hour wait
… moreElvin Harkins
The best New York-style pizza in Lexington! This is one of my favorite places to have lunch or dinner. The spacious patio is very inviting, and the inside dining has lots of options. The pizza is available by the slice, or you can order a whole pie. The service has always been excellent, warm & friendly. I can’t wait to go back!
… moreDanny Cadiz
Great location, amazing NY style slices and a great staff! The bar is top notch! 10/10
… moreK Graham
If you’re visiting Lex,KY you should definitely give Goodfellas a try! The pizza is excellent! The garlic breadstick is to die for! The vibe is spot on! Love when the guy making the pizza sings along to the music! Friendly staff clearing tables!
… moreNick Biratsis
First time going to Goodfellas while visiting our daughter at UK. Despite the long line, it was worth the wait.
Pizza was fantastic. Very fresh and lots of options. We got the Goodfella and Tommy Two-Times. Would like to see some gluten free options, but they had a good caprese salad.
The staff was hard working and friendly. Great atmosphere and music – cool historic vibe.
Would highly recommend a visit if you are in Lexington.
… moreRoss Blank
Came for the pizza, surprised by the bourbon selection. I know this is Kentucky, but holy smokes!!
The $5 old fashioned slapped, too.
The pizza? Really really good.
… moreMac Zeimet
Incredible pizza. The crust was perfectly crisp and the sauce had a fresh, balanced flavor. You can tell they care about quality and craft. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to.
… more