Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Easygoing pizzeria with brick-oven pies, classic pastas & other Italian favorites, plus a full bar.
Hours
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 9641 Olio Rd, McCordsville, IN 46055
Phone: (317) 336-6666
Website: https://www.goodfellasindy.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Goodfella’s McCordsville
Our ingredients are fresh, and our staff is friendly and courteous. For your convenience, we offer dine-in, pickup and delivery service. Check out our menu and …
Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta Restaurant – McCordsville
Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta Restaurant – McCordsville, McCordsville. 232 likes · 154 were here. Opening our doors in 2007, Goodfella’s Pizza &…
Menu – Goodfellas Pizzeria
View the full Goodfellas Pizzeria menu online! Explore pizza, sides, salads, and more in Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, and Tennessee.
Reviews
Tracy Streeter
It’s an excellent option for Italian food. The brick-oven pizzas and pasta dishes are delicious. But my wife had the shrimp scampi and wasn’t keen on its vinegary taste. The chicken wrap was very appetizing.
… moreAndrew Mancebo
We ordered the traditional Pepperoni and a traditional Margherita.
The Pepperoni was ok just too much cheese not enough sauce. The Margherita was better than the Pepp.
I was impressed at their brick oven but even more impressed that the Pizza didn’t taste like it was even in there. No char, no undercarriage, what a shame.
The service was nice, good vibes inside. Overall ok pizza, the Mrs and I are glad we went, just don’t think we’ll be back
… moreThe Pepperoni was ok just too much cheese not enough sauce. The Margherita was better than the Pepp.
I was impressed at their brick oven but even more impressed that the Pizza didn’t taste like it was even in there. No char, no undercarriage, what a shame.
The service was nice, good vibes inside. Overall ok pizza, the Mrs and I are glad we went, just don’t think we’ll be back
Jeremiah
Wife and I have been here 2x now. Kind of a date night when the kids aren’t home for dinner. The place is cozy, as we grabbed the same table in the bar area on both visits. Awesome calamari, we got it for an app both times. The first visit, I tried the lasagna and loved it. The second visit, I ordered a supreme pizza. We got a couple desserts to-go last time. Service was perfect both times. We will be back, and try something new here soon. If you are in the area, and wanna try something new… try it out, the menu has tons of options. Plenty to choose from… but most folks seemed to be ordering their brick oven pizzas. 5 stars
… moreAllie Mcbeal
The layout of this restaurant is very nice. It is a lot larger on the inside than it looks on the outside. The wine selection is just to die for. My husband, a friend and I sat at the bar last night. Bethany was our server. She informed plus of the half price wine night (Tuesday) and made meal suggestions. My husband had the Bianca pizza which I tasted and was the show stopper! I had the veal which was great but I ate too much fresh bread and oil so I couldn’t finish. My friend had the rigatoni which was also amazing. We will definitely return.
… moreMark Rumney
We definitely had a fun visit on a busy Friday night visiting Goodfellas, not to confused with a similarly named pizza place.
As I had to do, went straight at the veal parmigiana. Nice portions, sauce was fresh and cutlet, tasty for a patty mix. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoy them but nothing compares to the actual cut of veal.
Had a wonderful cocktail from the menu after some planning and substituting since a key item was out.
What deserves it own 5 stars to me was the Carrozza. It takes your idea of friend mozzarella to another level. It’s been that long since I saw it on menu and highly recommend it.
… moreAs I had to do, went straight at the veal parmigiana. Nice portions, sauce was fresh and cutlet, tasty for a patty mix. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoy them but nothing compares to the actual cut of veal.
Had a wonderful cocktail from the menu after some planning and substituting since a key item was out.
What deserves it own 5 stars to me was the Carrozza. It takes your idea of friend mozzarella to another level. It’s been that long since I saw it on menu and highly recommend it.
Rebekah Ditrapani
I had a really rough day at work, and to top it off my car wouldn’t start at the end of my shift. I walked over here feeling overwhelmed and upset, and the kindness I was met with genuinely meant more than I can put into words.
Aubrey, the bartender, immediately noticed I was crying and treated me with such compassion. She gave me a hug, made me a delicious drink, and took the time to talk with me and help me calm down. She was incredibly intuitive, warm, and kind—exactly the kind of person you hope to encounter on a hard day.
Liam was also very kind and welcoming, and even the owner came over to check in, which really spoke volumes about the culture of this place. It’s rare to find a business with staff who are not only great at what they do, but who also lead with genuine empathy and humanity.
Thank you for employing such kind-hearted people. You made a really difficult moment feel manageable, and I won’t forget that
… moreAubrey, the bartender, immediately noticed I was crying and treated me with such compassion. She gave me a hug, made me a delicious drink, and took the time to talk with me and help me calm down. She was incredibly intuitive, warm, and kind—exactly the kind of person you hope to encounter on a hard day.
Liam was also very kind and welcoming, and even the owner came over to check in, which really spoke volumes about the culture of this place. It’s rare to find a business with staff who are not only great at what they do, but who also lead with genuine empathy and humanity.
Thank you for employing such kind-hearted people. You made a really difficult moment feel manageable, and I won’t forget that
Sheryl Leavell
Ordered by phone, due to website not taking orders. Carry out. Ordered extra crispy calamari & baked ziti. Calamari was extremely chewy, not edible. Ziti wasn’t anything like the menu description. Just a drip of melted cheese on top not covering 1/6 of dish. Ziti was a very large amount; however, it wasn’t very good. I threw the calamari away and I’m going to try to remake the Ziti tomorrow. I was very disappointed and will not be ordering from this establishment again. Further, I had a carryout but looked around and the restaurant is not one that I would personally choose to dine in
… moreMatthew Acker (Uncommon Elixir)
A pleasant mix of brick oven and sports. The night I went, got to watch some Olympic skiing, enjoy a red chicken pasta, and chat with some friends. Atmosphere is relaxed and friendly. I’m thrilled to go back again.
… moreNancy OKeefe
Called order for a specific time (.called an hour in advance to the time I wanted to pick up). Arrived at the specified time – initially they could not find the order. When they found my order the desk person said they never submitted the order so they were going to make it right away. However they said it wouldn’t be ready for another 15-20 minutes. Extremely poor service!
To add insult to injury, the quality of the pizza was also poor – but you can be the judge from the pictures. Order 3 pizzas and calamari. Quality of the pizzas were unacceptable – for Two of the cheese pizzas, the cheese slid off the pies in the box and the pizza were underbaked. Calamari was cold and chewy.
If I could give 0 stars, I would! Not worth the $90 spent.
… moreTo add insult to injury, the quality of the pizza was also poor – but you can be the judge from the pictures. Order 3 pizzas and calamari. Quality of the pizzas were unacceptable – for Two of the cheese pizzas, the cheese slid off the pies in the box and the pizza were underbaked. Calamari was cold and chewy.
If I could give 0 stars, I would! Not worth the $90 spent.
Amayah Armstrong
We ordered the Goodfellas Pizza, it was full of flavor and so delicious! What really set this experience apart from other restaurants in the area however, was the service. Service was top tier. Cindy did an exceptional job and went above and beyond for us. Will definitely be returning!!
… more