Address and Contact Information
Address: 1742 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Phone: (631) 808-3029
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Locations – Goldberg’s Famous Bagels
Southampton ; Sag Harbor Village · Sag Harbor Village. 111 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 ; Mattituck · Sag Harbor Village. 10095 Main Road. (Mattituck Plaza).
The Original Goldberg’s Famous Bagels
Please don’t be intimidated by our long lines over the Summer months, they move fast! Goldberg’s Famous Bagels. 801 County Road 39, Southampton, New York 11968, …
Goldberg’s Famous Bagels (111 Main St) – Sag Harbor – Uber Eats
Use your Uber account to order delivery from Goldberg’s Famous Bagels (111 Main St) in Sag Harbor. Browse the menu, view popular items, and track your …
Reviews
Jordan Paredes
One of the best bagels in town. Cooked well and taste great. They also make there bagels in house so it is always fresh. Bacon egg and cheese sandwich are just like the ones in NYC or better.
… moremoses burdon
EDIT; second time in a row I’ve gone there and what was in my bag hardly even resembles what I ordered. You have one job, choice of bread, toasted or untoasted, choice of topping. how do you get this wrong every time?
every time!
decent bagels nothing special, not as good as the competition they eliminated. twice upon a bagel made better bagels, now it’s a McGoldbergs, bagel bouy made better bagels, they’re gone and there’s 2 McGoldbergs in town now… high prices to reflect the Hamptons standards. Goldberg’s is doing to bagels what the mafia did to garbage. You take the service we give you because you don’t have much other choice.
… moreevery time!
decent bagels nothing special, not as good as the competition they eliminated. twice upon a bagel made better bagels, now it’s a McGoldbergs, bagel bouy made better bagels, they’re gone and there’s 2 McGoldbergs in town now… high prices to reflect the Hamptons standards. Goldberg’s is doing to bagels what the mafia did to garbage. You take the service we give you because you don’t have much other choice.
Just React
Been coming to this place since it opened on the turnpike. Started really well, seems like over the past year or so all the old staff aren’t working there anymore. The past 3 times I’ve went there with the new staff I got overcharged the first time, my order was wrong the second time, and today they forgot add ons I paid for. I don’t know if it’s the new staff or just carelessness but personally I’m seeing a downhill trend.
… moreEllen McCarthy
Breakfast wrap was meh… much better one from Cromers or Cove Deli & the bagels aren’t so great either.
… moreBoris Major
Ordered multiples from here. Always ask for well toasted bagel and every single time I get a bagel that looks the same as it did before it got toasted. How is that a well toasted bagel. They don’t care how it comes out as long as it’s fast and they can help next person.
… moreCamila Antelo Iriarte
I do think they were great bagels. Did they change my life? Mm. would I go out of my way? Mm. Are they the best I’ve had? Mm.
… moreJeff Surut
Good bagels and Flagels.
Egg, cheese and sausage on a toasted sesame flagel.
… moreEgg, cheese and sausage on a toasted sesame flagel.
Daniel Chen
A simple delicious with ample breakfast and lunch choices (sandwiches, rolls, omlettes, eggs etc.) Friendly service and quick preparation. Can get pretty busy during weekends, holidays and Summer break.
… moreKimberleigh M
I’ve been in here several times. I’ve never experienced an incorrect order. Bagels are always delicious and I always take 2 dozen to go to take back to Kentucky. They freeze and defrost well and are delicious every time!
… moreTee Bee
This place is fine except for one thing I noticed: when you order lox and bagel, they don’t use regular cream cheese; they use cream cheese SPREAD. I don’t know whether this is a short-cut (easier and faster to smear on the bagel or whether it’s cheaper. Regardless, I don’t like it. I like regular cream cheese. It has a different taste and texture from the spread.
… more